The Pentagon’s $2 billion gamble on artificial intelligence

Science & Tech 17:20 16.10.2018
It’s the chilling plot line to every science fiction movie about robots in the future: Once they start thinking for themselves, humanity is doomed.
 
Think of the HAL 9000 in "2001: A Space Odyssey," or the replicants in "Blade Runner," or the hosts in "Westworld."
 
These days the Pentagon is doing a lot of thinking about the nascent scientific field of artificial intelligence, also known as “machine learning,” developing computer algorithms that will allow cars to drive themselves, robots to perform surgery, and even weapons to kill autonomously.
 
The race to master artificial intelligence is the No. 1 priority of the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, the tiny organization with just over 200 workers that was instrumental in developing stealth technology, high precision weapons, and the Internet.
 
“In reality, over about the last 50 years, DARPA and its research partners have led the way to establishing the field of artificial intelligence. We are not new to this game,” said DARPA Director Steven Walker at the agency’s 60th anniversary symposium in September.
 
Early artificial intelligence research perfected systems technology and later statistical learning capabilities, but the next leap in AI is developing what’s known as the “third wave,” technologies focused on “contextual reasoning,” or what we humans call “thinking.”
 
To that end, at the conference outside Washington, Walker announced an initiative to invest up to $2 billion over the next five years in new research efforts aimed at advancing artificial intelligence, to explore “how machines can acquire human-like communication and reasoning capabilities.”
 
The potential for computer-assisted thinking to make America’s future troops into cyborg warriors with abilities beyond normal human limitations is not lost on Gen. Paul Selva, the vice chairman of the Joint Chiefs and one of the deep thinkers about the potential of artificial intelligence to help warfighters make sense of the “mountains of data” on the battlefield.
 
“It should be able to let us see faster, sense faster, decide faster, and act faster,” Selva told defense reporters at a roundtable this year. “If you can’t do all those things, you’re not actually taking advantage of the technology. You’re just admiring it.”
 
Some of what artificial intelligence could do is fairly basic, such as speeding up mundane tasks that consume a lot of human resources, reviewing records for background checks or analyzing hours of drone footage.
 
But some tech companies, including Google, are recoiling at the idea their AI tools might be assisting in the business of war.
 
Last week, Google pulled out of competition for a $10 billion Pentagon cloud-computing contract because it “couldn't be assured that it would align with our artificial intelligence principles," which include a pledge not to build weapons or other systems intended to cause harm, Google said in a statement.
 
And as weapons get smarter, the moral questions get stickier.
 
What ethicists worry about is the rise of LAWS, short for Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems, such as the fictional Skynet in the Terminator movies. A more realistic example is autonomous aircraft, like today’s killer drones with no human pilots at the controls.
 
“The general idea is that a LAWS, once activated, would, with the help of sensors and computationally intense algorithms, identify, search, select, and attack targets without further human intervention,” writes Regina Surber, scientific adviser for a peace foundation based in Geneva.
 
In a paper published this year, Surber laid out the arguments for and against.
 
On the one hand, she points out that autonomous “thinking” systems would not depend on communication links, could operate at increased range for extended periods, would reduce the number of humans needed for some military operations, and could save lives on both sides.
 
“Their higher processing speeds would suit the increasing pace of combat, by replacing human soldiers, they will spare lives; and with the absence of emotions such as self-interest, fear or vengeance, their ‘objective’ ‘decision-making’ could lead to overall outcomes that are less harmful,” Surber wrote.
 
On the other hand, the more artificial intelligence substitutes for human judgment, the greater the risk it could desensitize warfighters to the value of human life.
 
“Further, humans may no longer be able to predict who or what is made the target of an attack, or even explain why a particular target was chosen,” Surber argued. “As a machine and not a human being ‘decides’ to kill,” she wrote, “the physical and emotional distance between the programmer or engineer and the targeted person may generate an indifference or even a ‘Gameboy Mentality’ on the side of the former.”
 
It’s something that Defense Secretary Jim Mattis has considered as he’s watched his Pentagon plunge headlong into the race to obtain a competitive edge in machine learning systems.
 
Mattis told reporters traveling with him this year that taking the human out of the loop could alter what he has always considered an immutable tenet of war, namely that while the technologies change, its fundamental nature does not.
 
Mattis notes that today drones are misnamed when they are called unmanned aerial vehicles instead of remotely-piloted aircraft.
 
“It may not have a person in the cockpit, but there's someone flying it. There's someone over their shoulder. There's actually more people probably flying it than a manned airplane,” he said. “It’s not unmanned.”
 
But if sentient machines replace humans, it could change everything.
 
“If we ever get to the point where it's completely on automatic pilot and we're all spectators, then it's no longer serving a political purpose, and conflict is a social problem that needs social solutions, people, human solutions,” Mattis said.
 
“I'm certainly questioning my original premise that the fundamental nature of war will not change,” he said. “You have to question that now.”
IEPF issued a statement regarding Azerbaijani children at the UN Human Rights Council

News line

WB allocates $2M for preparation of sustainable development project in Baku
22:00 02.07.2025
Malaysia inviting Azerbaijan to participate in trade incentive program
21:45 02.07.2025
Malaysia expects further expansion of palm oil trade with Azerbaijan
21:30 02.07.2025
EBRD updates current portfolio of projects in Azerbaijan
21:30 02.07.2025
12 Georgian MPs lose parliamentary mandates
21:00 02.07.2025
Asan Jakishev: Kazakhstan strengthens status as key transit hub in region
20:40 02.07.2025
Zakharova: 'We call on Baku to take measures to return ties to level of strategic alliance'
20:30 02.07.2025
Kyrgyz ambassador to Azerbaijan also appointed as envoy to Georgia
20:20 02.07.2025
Bangladesh court sentences ex-Premier Hasina in contempt case; first conviction since ouster
20:00 02.07.2025
Russia says reduction or cessation of Western arms supplies to Ukraine brings conflict closer to its end
19:45 02.07.2025
Israeli prosecution cancels Netanyahu’s corruption trial sessions next week over US visit
19:30 02.07.2025
Mamasadyk Bakirov: Kyrgyzstan creates all necessary conditions for business
19:15 02.07.2025
Lachin holds panel session on Role of Women in Urban Development
19:00 02.07.2025
Central banks of Azerbaijan, Georgia mull implementation of systems supported by AI
18:45 02.07.2025
Azerbaijani military personnel participate in International Anatolian Eagle-2025
18:30 02.07.2025
Shavkat Mirziyoyev to open Uzbekistan park in Baku
18:15 02.07.2025
Peskov: Head of Russia's Investigative Committee, Azerbaijan's prosecutor general mull problematic issues
18:00 02.07.2025
South Korean ex-premier, minister summoned over Yoon’s martial law probe
17:45 02.07.2025
Trump says Israel has agreed to 'necessary conditions' to finalize 60-day ceasefire in Gaza
17:30 02.07.2025
DR Congo-Rwanda peace deal ‘does not address serious crimes committed in the east': Amnesty International
17:15 02.07.2025
China again urges its citizens to avoid travel to Iran
17:00 02.07.2025
Australia's Qantas says 6 million customer accounts accessed in cyber hack
16:45 02.07.2025
US accuses UN expert of ‘economic warfare’ over report on companies aiding Israeli occupation
16:30 02.07.2025
150 National Guard troops reassigned from Los Angeles security mission to wildfire response
16:00 02.07.2025
Israeli strikes kill another 29 Palestinians in Gaza Strip
15:45 02.07.2025
Revenue of China’s software industry grows by 11.2%
15:30 02.07.2025
President of Azerbaijan Ilham Aliyev’s one-on-one meeting with President of Uzbekistan Shavkat Mirziyoyev begins
15:20 02.07.2025
Zakharova: Friendly relations between Russia, Azerbaijan extremely important
15:15 02.07.2025
President of Northern Cyprus arrives in Azerbaijan
15:00 02.07.2025
COP29 president: US withdrawal from Paris agreement won't stop global climate movement
14:45 02.07.2025
President of Uzbekistan arrives in Azerbaijan on state visit
14:30 02.07.2025
Saudi Arabia receives written message from Iran
14:15 02.07.2025
Percentage of female students studying in Azerbaijan revealed
14:00 02.07.2025
Five of Russia's neighbors withdraw from Ottawa Treaty
13:45 02.07.2025
Bahar Muradova: Azerbaijan ready to share experience in expanding women's economic rights
13:30 02.07.2025
Prosecutor General's Office: Ziyaddin Safarov died in vehicle of Russian law enforcement agencies
13:15 02.07.2025
Adviser to Uzbek FM: Relations with Azerbaijan demonstrating steady growth in all areas
13:00 02.07.2025
ECO: Significant steps should be taken to increase women's digital skills
12:45 02.07.2025
Some Russian groups want to create crisis in relations with Azerbaijan
12:30 02.07.2025
Israel-Iran ceasefire set to drive oil prices toward $60 range: Experts
12:15 02.07.2025
Hamısı