How much for that app? U.S. top court hears Apple antitrust dispute

Science & Tech 22:41 25.11.2018

When iPhone users want to edit blemishes out of their selfies, identify stars and constellations or simply join the latest video game craze, they turn to Apple Inc's App Store, where any software application they buy also includes a 30 percent cut for Apple.

That commission is a key issue in a closely watched antitrust case that will reach the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday. The nine justices will hear arguments in Apple's bid to escape damages in a lawsuit accusing it of breaking federal antitrust laws by monopolizing the market for iPhone apps and causing consumers to pay more than they should.

The justices will ultimately decide a broader question: Can consumers even sue for damages in an antitrust case like this one?

Apple, which is appealing a lower court decision that revived the proposed consumer class-action lawsuit, says no, citing a decades-old Supreme Court precedent. The Cupertino, California-based technology company said that siding with the iPhone users who filed the lawsuit would threaten the burgeoning field of e-commerce, which generates hundreds of billions of dollars annually in U.S. retail sales.

The plaintiffs, as well as antitrust watchdog groups, said that if the justices close courthouse doors to those who buy consumer products, monopolistic conduct could expand unchecked.

"A lot of tech platforms will start making the argument that consumers don't have standing to bring antitrust suits against us," said Sandeep Vaheesan, legal director for the Open Markets Institute, a Washington-based antitrust advocacy group.

"Uber could say, we're just providing communication services to ride-sharing drivers," Vaheesan said, referring to the popular ride-sharing company. "If there's an antitrust issue, the drivers can bring a claim but passengers do not have standing."

The iPhone users accused Apple of violating federal antitrust law by monopolizing the sale of paid apps, leading to inflated prices compared to if apps were available from other sources.

Though developers set the prices of their apps, Apple collects the payments from iPhone users, keeping a 30 percent commission on each purchase. One area of dispute in the case is whether app developers recoup the cost of that commission by passing it on to consumers. Developers earned more than $26 billion (£20.28 billion) in 2017, a 30 percent increase over 2016, according to Apple.

The company sought to have the antitrust claims dismissed, saying the plaintiffs lacked the required legal standing to bring the lawsuit.

Apple has seized upon a 1977 Supreme Court ruling that limited damages for anti-competitive conduct to those directly overcharged instead of indirect victims who paid an overcharge passed on by others. Part of the concern, the court said in that case, was to free judges from having to make complex calculations of damages.

Apple said it is acting only as the agent for app developers who sell the apps to consumers through the App Store.

The company said allowing the lawsuit to proceed would be dangerous for the e-commerce industry, which increasingly relies on agent-based sales models. Apple cited companies like ticket site StubHub, Amazon's Marketplace and eBay.

Lawsuits against companies like these would multiply "and lead to the quagmire this court sought to avoid," Apple told the justices in a legal brief.

E-commerce reached $452 billion in U.S. retail sales in 2017, according to U.S. government estimates.

Apple is supported by President Donald Trump's administration. The plaintiffs are backed by the attorneys general of 30 states including California, Texas, Florida and New York.

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce business group, backing Apple, said in a brief to the justices, "The increased risk and cost of litigation will chill innovation, discourage commerce, and hurt developers, retailers and consumers alike."

The plaintiffs and some anti-monopoly groups disagree. They said that app developers would be unlikely to sue because they would not want to bite the hand that feeds them, leaving no one to challenge anti-competitive conduct.

Developers "cannot risk the possibility of Apple removing them from the App Store if they bring suit," the American Antitrust Institute advocacy group said in a brief.

Apple is "trying to make it harder for injured parties to assert their rights under federal antitrust law," said Mark Rifkin, an attorney for the plaintiffs.

The claims against Apple date to 2011 when several iPhone buyers including lead plaintiff Robert Pepper of Chicago filed a class action lawsuit against Apple in federal court in Oakland, California. A judge initially threw out the suit, ruling that the consumers were not direct purchasers because the higher fees they paid were passed on to them by the developers.

The San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals last year revived the lawsuit, deciding that Apple was a distributor that sold iPhone apps directly to consumers.

This is how Rahman Mustafayev exposed the representation of Armenia in ICJ - VIDEO

News line

Azerbaijani police found numerous weapons and ammunition in Khankandi
10:23 19.04.2024
Nuclear sites in Isfahan remain untouched by destruction - VİDEO/UPDATED
10:10 19.04.2024
Chad threatens to kick out US troops
10:00 19.04.2024
Terrorists kill 16 soldiers in Syria
Terrorists kill 16 soldiers in Syria
09:49 19.04.2024
Biden calls China ‘xenophobic’
09:30 19.04.2024
Maduro: Despite US sanctions, Venesuela’s oil industry will develop
09:17 19.04.2024
Kenyan military helicopter crashes, five soldiers killed, police say
Kenyan military helicopter crashes, five soldiers killed, police say
23:45 18.04.2024
Greek PM Mitsotakis to meet Erdogan on May 13 in Ankara
22:55 18.04.2024
Guterres: ‘The Middle East is on a knife-edge’
Guterres: ‘The Middle East is on a knife-edge’
22:33 18.04.2024
CBA chairman discusses importance of COP29 in long-term development of global economy in Washington
22:00 18.04.2024
US Ambassador Marks Visit to Liberated Territories of Aghdam -PHOTOS
21:30 18.04.2024
Georgian State Minister for Reconciliation meets US Senior Advisor for Caucasus Negotiations
Georgian State Minister for Reconciliation meets US Senior Advisor for Caucasus Negotiations
21:21 18.04.2024
US and UK imposed fresh sanctions on Iran
20:43 18.04.2024
A Race Against Time: Can SDGs Goals Transform Our World by 2030? - ANALYSIS
20:18 18.04.2024
Japan to start 5th ocean discharge of Fukushima nuclear
19:30 18.04.2024
What does the departure of Russian peacekeepers from Karabakh mean? - Georgian pundit talks on Ednews
19:02 18.04.2024
EU made it's final decision on imposing sanctions on Iran following attack on Israel
18:42 18.04.2024
The new law in Italy may increase pressure on women
The new law in Italy may increase pressure on women
18:00 18.04.2024
EU Summit Stresses Importance of Stable Relations with Türkiye and Cyprus
EU Summit Stresses Importance of Stable Relations with Türkiye and Cyprus
17:48 18.04.2024
Caspian Sea Desalination Project: A Promising Solution for Water Security - OPINION
17:30 18.04.2024
Tesla Eyes $2-3 Billion Investment in India Amid Market Challenges
Tesla Eyes $2-3 Billion Investment in India Amid Market Challenges
17:21 18.04.2024
The EU will treat the violation of sanctions as a "judicial crime"
17:10 18.04.2024
European Commission to earmark €15M assistance to Armenia
European Commission to earmark €15M assistance to Armenia
16:55 18.04.2024
Was the presence of peacekeepers a threat to Azerbaijan? - OPINION
16:48 18.04.2024
Russia's presence in the South Caucasus is over - Russian Pundit
16:40 18.04.2024
Armenia PM: Turkish army is 50 meters away from Margara village houses, our goal is to get such situation
Armenia PM: Turkish army is 50 meters away from Margara village houses, our goal is to get such situation
16:31 18.04.2024
Iran threatens to attack Israel's nuclear facilities
16:05 18.04.2024
Samuel Wordsworth: Armenian claims of ethnic cleansing remain unfounded - VİDEO
15:43 18.04.2024
Channel for sale of human organs identified in Kyrgyzstan
Channel for sale of human organs identified in Kyrgyzstan
15:30 18.04.2024
This is how Rahman Mustafayev exposed the representation of Armenia in ICJ - VIDEO
15:17 18.04.2024
Azerbaijani NGOs adress open letter to Norwegian Nobel Committee regarding Ruben Vardanyan
15:02 18.04.2024
Russian MFA: West continues to militarize South Caucasus
14:46 18.04.2024
Umud Mirzayev: 'I have been gradually waiting for the Russian peacekeepers to leave Karabakh'
14:32 18.04.2024
Parliaments of Azerbaijan and New Caledonia ink memorandum of cooperation
Parliaments of Azerbaijan and New Caledonia ink memorandum of cooperation
14:17 18.04.2024
Azerbaijan weather forecast for April 19
Azerbaijan weather forecast for April 19
14:01 18.04.2024
Foreign minister of Ukraine met with Anthony Blinken
13:48 18.04.2024
Azerbaijan invited Swedish Prime Minister to COP29
13:28 18.04.2024
Withdrawal of Russian peacekeepers from Azerbaijan continues
13:05 18.04.2024
Pashinyan urges Armenian villagers to find inspiration, not disturbance, in their proximity to Azerbaijan
12:40 18.04.2024
Zelenskyy calls on Congress to speed up making decision on aid package to Ukraine
12:19 18.04.2024
Hamısı