Hong Kong golf course row exposes city's social divide

Society 17:06 11.06.2018
Its sprawling greens and woodland have made Hong Kong's historic Fanling golf course a favourite with homegrown and international stars, but it is now under threat after being listed for potential housing development.
 
As the government seeks solutions for the space-starved city's lack of decent homes, the club argues that sacrificing a world-class sports venue is a short-sighted move.
 
But grass roots campaigners say the prime spot in the north of Hong Kong should not remain a playground for the wealthy elite.
 
Located near the border with mainland China, the colonial-era course is part of the Hong Kong Golf Club and has hosted the Hong Kong Open, a mainstay of the European and Asian Tours, every year since 1959.
 
Leading players including former world number one Rory McIlroy, Miguel Ángel Jiménez and Hong Kong golfing star Tiffany Chan have spoken out against bulldozing the site, which is one of 18 options earmarked by the government for affordable housing as it scrambles to find new land.
 
"Losing even one golf course would severely impact Hong Kong's ability to develop talent and provide opportunities for youngsters to learn and play the game," said Ian Gardner, general manager of the Hong Kong Golf Club.
 
Surrounded by urban hustle, the Fanling complex is an oasis of ancient trees and diverse wildlife, including turtles, owls and butterflies.
 
The oldest of its three 18-hole courses was built in 1911 on land that was home to the centuries-old graves of indigenous clans, whose descendants now have to skirt the greens to pay tribute to their ancestors.
 
Its clubhouse features a men-only bar and a plush members' lounge where old photos and maps as well as a letter from Queen Elizabeth II's private secretary adorn the walls.
 
The club faithful say Fanling's history should justify its survival.
 
Members received a letter earlier this year assuring them that the club was working "very hard" to protect their interests.
 
"The trees and all the layout, and the history behind it with all the well-known golfers that played here -- it's irreplaceable," said Tim Tang, 32, a former professional golfer who coaches at the club.
 
- Symbol of inequality -
 
Some critics say the government is under-using space in Hong Kong which is already vacant or has been hoarded by developers as land banks for potential future projects.
 
They argue there is plenty of existing room available for affordable housing without touching green areas and that the small group of influential real estate giants in the city prioritise building profit-making upmarket units.
 
But for others the golf course is fair game and a visceral symbol of Hong Kong's inequalities, set against the backdrop of spiralling property prices and rents which force many residents to cram into tiny homes.
 
Chanting "Land belongs to the people!" and "The grass roots don't want elite golf courses!", protesters filled up holes on the course in March using mud scooped from a nearby village where demolition work has begun for a controversial development plan.
 
Joining one of the city's numerous private sports and recreational clubs can cost hundreds of thousands, even millions, of Hong Kong dollars. Some are said to have decades-long waiting lists.
 
Although Fanling's Gardner pointed out the club offers special access for promising junior athletes each year, playing a round there is out of reach for the majority.
 
Non-members can use the Fanling course Monday to Friday, but have to pay a fee of HK$1,100 ($140) for 18 holes.
 
A corporate membership for the Hong Kong Golf Club goes for HK$17 million, according to one agent.
 
The club refused to divulge its individual joining fees or the length of its waiting list but said monthly fees for members to access its two properties range from HK$700 to HK$3,000.
 
- 'Privileged members' -
 
Private clubs are too exclusive and depend on a "system of privileged memberships" while benefiting from low rents on their swaths of prime land, says Mark Mak, senior researcher at environmental group Green Sense.
 
Mak says low government rents mean the golf club is "subsidised by public resources while not actually serving public interests". He proposes partially redeveloping Fanling for housing or turning it into a park or public golf course.
 
Private sports clubs originally paid only a token premium or nothing at all when land was granted to them by the government through leases which offered generous terms to develop sports and recreational facilities.
 
The government typically charges clubs an annual rent of three percent of their property's rateable value, according to the city's home affairs bureau.
 
The Fanling golf course says it paid HK$2.53 million ($322,410) in annual rent last year to the government for 170 hectares, which amounts to HK$0.14 per square foot.
 
By comparison, the average rental price per square foot for a residential property in Hong Kong is HK$35.9, according to Centaline Property Agency.
 
But Gardner justified the low rents by saying sports clubs were not for profit and had ploughed their wealth into earning "international renown".
 
"For many, many decades they have continued to pour money into developing these world-class facilities," he told AFP.
Insights from Ex-U.S. Ambassador: Georgia Crisis, Peace Talks, & COP29's Global Role - VIDEO

News line

President Ilham Aliyev: Iran-Azerbaijan unity and friendship is unshakable
16:41 19.05.2024
President Ilham Aliyev: We welcome Iran's support regarding peace agreement between Azerbaijan and Armenia
16:29 19.05.2024
President of Azerbaijan: We have major plans in the field of energy
President of Azerbaijan: We have major plans in the field of energy
16:12 19.05.2024
Israel accuses South Africa of false claims at ICJ
15:50 19.05.2024
Ilham Aliyev: Interstate relations between Iran and Azerbaijan reached highest level
15:34 19.05.2024
President Ilham Aliyev: Iranian-Azerbaijani friendship and brotherhood are an important factor for the stability of the region
15:00 19.05.2024
Israeli minister vows to quit war cabinet if PM fails to agree new Gaza plan
Israeli minister vows to quit war cabinet if PM fails to agree new Gaza plan
13:55 19.05.2024
Speaker of Latvian Parliament arrives in Fuzuli
13:33 19.05.2024
Presidents of Azerbaijan and Iran attend ceremony to commission "Khudafarin" hydroelectric complex and inaugurate "Giz Galasi" hydroelectric complex
13:00 19.05.2024
President Ilham Aliyev and President Seyyed Ebrahim Raisi meet at the Azerbaijan-Iran border
11:49 19.05.2024
Burkina Faso, Mali And Niger finalise regional alliance project
Burkina Faso, Mali And Niger finalise regional alliance project
11:00 19.05.2024
Russia could increase Ukraine attacks, says Zelensky
10:22 19.05.2024
France riles allies by inviting Russia to D-Day ceremony
France riles allies by inviting Russia to D-Day ceremony
10:00 19.05.2024
IDF kills top Islamic Jihad commander in Rafah amid wave of Gaza airstrikes
09:35 19.05.2024
Slovak PM's condition forecasted to improve
09:12 19.05.2024
Fifty dead in heavy rain, floods in central Afghanistan, official says
Fifty dead in heavy rain, floods in central Afghanistan, official says
08:45 19.05.2024
Speaker of Latvian Saeima arrives in Azerbaijan for official visit
03:02 19.05.2024
Bayer 04 become first team to go through entire Bundesliga season undefeated
Bayer 04 become first team to go through entire Bundesliga season undefeated
23:00 18.05.2024
Assistant to Azerbaijani President discusses COP29, regional and international issues in USIP
22:00 18.05.2024
President Ilham Aliyev and First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva attended inauguration of Zangilan Mosque -UPDATED
21:00 18.05.2024
Georgian president vetoes ‘foreign agent’ law
20:00 18.05.2024
Turkish Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan to visit Pakistan
19:26 18.05.2024
Pakistan Climate Youth Leaders Roundtable in Islamabad: Empowering Youth to Lead Climate Diplomacy
19:00 18.05.2024
Cole Palmer wins Premier League Young Player of the Season award
Cole Palmer wins Premier League Young Player of the Season award
18:28 18.05.2024
Dabney Coleman: TV and film actor dead at 92
Dabney Coleman: TV and film actor dead at 92
18:00 18.05.2024
Trump: Greatest fear is Biden will steal election
16:50 18.05.2024
Israeli strikes in Jabalia kill 15
16:23 18.05.2024
President Ilham Aliyev and First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva attend inauguration of Zangilan Mosque
15:58 18.05.2024
Germany's Saarland sees flooding after heavy rain
Germany's Saarland sees flooding after heavy rain
15:35 18.05.2024
Hamas says it rejects any military presence on Palestinian land
15:11 18.05.2024
Zelenskyy wants China at Ukraine peace talks, cites ‘influence on Russia’
14:48 18.05.2024
Azerbaijan appoints Major General Namig Islamzade to post of Air Force Commander
Azerbaijan appoints Major General Namig Islamzade to post of Air Force Commander
14:25 18.05.2024
Azerbaijani police found 43 automatic weapons, 3 pistols, 8 rifles in Khankandi city
13:55 18.05.2024
President Ilham Aliyev lays foundation stone for Buyuk Marjanli, Karkhulu and Sariqalli villages of Jabrayil district
13:36 18.05.2024
37,583 hectares in Azerbaijan's liberated territories have been cleared of mines and unexploded ordnance - VIDEO
13:27 18.05.2024
Azerbaijan, Cuba discuss COP29-related issues
13:00 18.05.2024
Price of Azerbaijani oil nears USD 85
Price of Azerbaijani oil nears USD 85
12:17 18.05.2024
Azerbaijani presidential aide meets with US national security advisor
11:59 18.05.2024
US, Iran held indirect talks this week on avoiding more attacks
11:00 18.05.2024
Presidents of Azerbaijan and Belarus visit Shusha - UPDATED
10:35 18.05.2024
Hamısı