Freeing states to boost the recovery of threatened wildlife

Analytics 19:45 05.05.2018
This year marks the 45th anniversary of the Endangered Species Act. In at least one key respect, the law has worked as intended — only 1 percent of species protected by the law have gone extinct. But the act has been far less successful at recovering vulnerable species, with less than 2 percent of protected species achieving that goal. Achieving both goals will require reform to boost the recovery rate for species while preserving the law’s effectiveness at protecting species from extinction.
 
The Department of Interior is considering a reform to do just that by adjusting the extent of regulatory burdens imposed to the degree of threats a species faces, so that restrictions are strengthened as species decline and relaxed as they recover. This reform would dramatically improve the incentives for recovering species, without disturbing the strict regulations for the most vulnerable species that have led to the statute’s success at preventing extinction.
 
That may sound counterintuitive. How does relaxing regulations better protect species? A new report from the Property and Environment Research Center explains how: the reform would allow states to pursue innovative, market-based conservation programs and it would align the incentives of private landowners with the interests of species.
 
The reform recognizes the crucial difference between the Endangered Species Act’s two categories of protected species: “threatened” and “endangered.” Species in these categories can face dramatically different prospects. The endangered dusky gopher frog, for example, is found only at a few sites in Louisiana. It is much more vulnerable to extinction than the northern long-eared bat, a threatened species numbering in the millions spread across 37 states.
 
Think of the difference between “threatened” and “endangered” as points along a continuum. Congress intended the threatened species listing as an early warning system against species’ slide toward endangered status. But, because threatened species face lower risks than endangered species, Congress chose not to extend the same regulatory protections to them.
 
In particular, Congress reserved the controversial and burdensome “take” prohibition for endangered species, viewing it as a necessary last resort for the most at-risk species. That prohibition forbids private activities that harm protected species and it applies to far more activities than you might think. Catching a protected species for conservation purposes or accidentally getting too close to one is considered “take.” So are many common land use activities that may inadvertently affect species’ habitat, including building homes, farming and harvesting timber.
 
In other words, when the take prohibition applies, it places extremely heavy burdens on property owners whose land provides habitat to species. Congress deemed that trade-off necessary for the more vulnerable endangered species — but not for threatened species.
 
This critical distinction was the result of careful thinking. California Democratic Sen. John Tunney, urging the statute’s adoption in 1973, explained that the “two levels of classification facilitate regulations that are tailored to the needs of the animal while minimizing the use of the most stringent prohibitions.”
 
“States,” Tunney continued, would be “encouraged to use their discretion to promote the recovery of threatened species and federal prohibitions against taking must be absolutely enforced only for those species on the brink of extinction.”
 
Unfortunately, the wisdom of that distinction was cast aside by a 1975 regulation declaring that the take prohibition would automatically be applied to threatened species. This decision eliminated the distinction between the two categories as a potential incentive to promote recovery efforts.
 
It’s time to restore the law’s original intent. Repealing this regulation, as the Department of Interior is considering, would free states to pursue innovative conservation programs; encourage voluntary collaborations between government, landowners and conservationists; and provide the necessary incentives to boost the rate at which we recover species.
 
Recent state-led conservation efforts provide powerful evidence that states are ready to seize the opportunity this reform would give them. For example, the Obama administration encouraged forward-thinking state leaders, landowners and conservationists to work together to conserve the greater sage grouse, lesser prairie chicken and gopher tortoise. These efforts illustrate that there are better ways to recover species than inflexible, potentially counterproductive federal regulations.
 
Restoring the Endangered Species Act’s distinction between endangered and threatened species would also improve landowners’ incentives to help recover species. Most habitat for endangered species is on private land. Thus, species recovery ultimately hinges on the incentives for landowners to protect and improve habitat on their land.
 
Failing to differentiate between endangered and threatened species results in misaligned incentives. For example, regulating endangered and threatened species the same way means that landowners who successfully recover endangered species receive no reward for their efforts because the same regulatory burdens continue to apply when the species improves to threatened.
 
Congress’s original design of tightening regulatory restrictions as species decline, and relaxing them as species recover, better aligns landowners’ incentives with the interests of wildlife.
 
Although the Endangered Species Act has protected numerous species from extinction, it has failed to achieve the same success at recovering species. The Department of Interior should follow through on reform to preserve what the statute does well, while boosting the incentives to recover species.
Hikmat Hajiyev: "Azerbaijan is a natural link connecting Central Asia and Europe" - VIDEO

News line

Erdogan to visit US on May 9
Erdogan to visit US on May 9
16:26 29.03.2024
Hulusi Akar, US congressmen mull Azerbaijan-Armenia peace process
15:52 29.03.2024
Russian ambassador sees no reasons to expect Russian-US ties to improve
15:36 29.03.2024
British army lifts ban on serving soldiers having beards
British army lifts ban on serving soldiers having beards
15:29 29.03.2024
Hikmat Hajiyev: "Azerbaijan is a natural link connecting Central Asia and Europe" - VIDEO
15:13 29.03.2024
Azerbaijan weather forecast for March 30
Azerbaijan weather forecast for March 30
15:00 29.03.2024
Tajikistan detains 9 people over Russian concert shooting
Tajikistan detains 9 people over Russian concert shooting
14:46 29.03.2024
Washington Is Forming A New Alliance - OPINION
14:32 29.03.2024
Individuals identified as drug users will not be admitted for service in Azerbaijani tax authorities
14:14 29.03.2024
Philippines' Catholic devotees nailed to crosses to re-enact crucifixion
Philippines' Catholic devotees nailed to crosses to re-enact crucifixion
14:00 29.03.2024
Umud Mirzayev: EU's South Caucasus Visit Aims to Maintain Regional Influence
13:45 29.03.2024
Public Television of Armenia Reveals Villages to be Returned to Azerbaijan
13:39 29.03.2024
Death toll of Israeli strike in Syria rises to 42, war monitor says - UPDATED
13:25 29.03.2024
Azerbaijan toughens penalties for non-compliance with rules of state of emergency regime
Azerbaijan toughens penalties for non-compliance with rules of state of emergency regime
13:12 29.03.2024
How will the EU's visit to the South Caucasus affect the peace process? - Former ambassador talks to Ednews
13:00 29.03.2024
Azerbaijan tightens sanctions for breaching special operation zone rules on religious extremism
12:45 29.03.2024
Azerbaijan toughens penalties for non-compliance with rules of social emergency environment regime
12:33 29.03.2024
About $7 bln of foreign direct investment was invested in Azerbaijan last year
12:00 29.03.2024
Number of people injured in Crocus City Hall terrorist attack reaches 382
11:48 29.03.2024
Media: Netanyahu rejected the Mossad Chief's proposal for a possible agreement in Gaza
11:37 29.03.2024
Azerbaijani Parliament's meeting kicks off
11:26 29.03.2024
An American couple founded a website, which identifies brands that support Israel
An American couple founded a website, which identifies brands that support Israel
11:07 29.03.2024
US scientists name infection more dangerous for brain than coronavirus
US scientists name infection more dangerous for brain than coronavirus
11:00 29.03.2024
Parviz Shahbazov: Foundations of 4 new renewable energy plants will be laid this year
Parviz Shahbazov: Foundations of 4 new renewable energy plants will be laid this year
10:50 29.03.2024
Japan eyes self-driving expressway lane network
10:40 29.03.2024
Oil prices end 1Q24 with strong growth
10:30 29.03.2024
SECRETS of the European Union's visit to the South Caucasus - Fikret Sadigov EXPLAINS
10:25 29.03.2024
Ammunition found in Khankandi
Ammunition found in Khankandi
10:10 29.03.2024
Iran’s top diplomat: Military presence of third countries in Caspian Sea goes against interests of region
Iran’s top diplomat: Military presence of third countries in Caspian Sea goes against interests of region
10:00 29.03.2024
Armenia officially announces freezing its participation in CSTO
09:50 29.03.2024
US hopes to return to purchase of 72 fighter jets per year amid budget cuts
09:38 29.03.2024
Another 138 IDPs leave for Fuzuli
09:28 29.03.2024
Netanyahu: "We have strategic assets of Hamas"
09:17 29.03.2024
Date of next meeting of Armenian and Azerbaijani Parliament Speakers announced
09:00 29.03.2024
Russia prepares for new offensive in May-June l – says Zelensky
23:52 28.03.2024
Russian investigators have evidence of Ukraine link to Crocus terrorists
22:24 28.03.2024
Committee members of the EU Council will visit the South Caucasus region
19:48 28.03.2024
Bayern to pay Thomas Tuchel 12M euro compensation
Bayern to pay Thomas Tuchel 12M euro compensation
19:00 28.03.2024
Crocus City Hall terrorists took drugs before attack - law enforcement agencies
Crocus City Hall terrorists took drugs before attack - law enforcement agencies
18:33 28.03.2024
Azerbaijan, UN Development Program mull future co-op
18:00 28.03.2024
Hamısı