Who guards the guardians?

Analytics 02:31 11.08.2018
U.S. Ambassador Nikki Haley was right to lead efforts over the past year to reform the United Nations Human Rights Council, a 47-nation body that suffers a credibility deficit, with its work often marked by selectivity and politicization.
 
Haley urged the council to improve its membership standards, and to end its singular focus on Israel. After a year of diplomatic prodding, she realized the will wasn’t there. On June 19, the United States decided to withdraw its membership.
 
Several activist groups close to the United Nations lobbied member states to oppose the U.S. withdrawal. Afterward, in an op-ed in The Hill, Human Rights Watch (HRW) director Ken Roth expressed outrage that Haley called out his organization and Amnesty International for having sided with Russia and China in blocking the proposed reform.
 
Roth is wrong to whitewash the council’s betrayal of its mission, and to suggest that HRW and Amnesty are above reproach.
 
Interestingly, in a five-year period, Roth completely switched his position. “Imagine a jury,” he wrote in 2001, speaking of the U.N.’s old Commission on Human Rights, “that includes murderers and rapists, or a police force run in large part by suspected murderers and rapists who are determined to stymie investigation of their crimes.”
 
Yet by 2006, after Kofi Annan successfully moved to scrap the discredited commission and replace it, Roth became the council’s biggest cheerleader — before it was even born, and despite only limited changes.
 
What caused this flip-flop? The Bush administration had clashed with the United Nations over the Iraq war, and Republicans frequently pointed to the Human Rights Commission, which named Libya as its chair in 2003, as a symbol of the world body’s pathologies. When Bush opposed the 2006 reform, Roth became for it.
 
When I debated Roth a month before the council opened in 2006, when even the New York Times called the reform an “ugly sham,” he insisted there was “an enormous difference” between the old commission and the new council. “Under this new system," Roth told BBC, “countries with poor human rights records ... will never have a seat on the council again.” Yet the opposite is true: Numerous tyrannies have won seats.
 
In his op-ed, Roth concedes that “some abusive countries” manage to secure membership. Some? Since 2006, the number of council members who fail to meet basic democracy standards has hovered in the range of 50 to 60 percent. So much for the “enormous difference.”
 
The council has never produced a single resolution, urgent session or commission of inquiry into gross abuses by China, Cuba, Russia, Turkey, Venezuela, Zimbabwe, and the list goes on. Only a few tyrannies are condemned. Even then, though Roth points to the council’s investigation of Syria, one of its commissioners quit in frustration after six years, saying, “We have not achieved anything for justice or the victims in Syria.”
 
Roth takes umbrage that Haley accused his group of siding with Moscow or Beijing, implying this would be absurd. But he omits the specific charge in Haley’s letter: that the only ones to have written against the U.S. reform proposal were Russia, China and Roth’s organization and a few others.
 
The sad fact is that HRW and Amnesty repeatedly side with Russia and China. At every council session, when these and other dictatorships scapegoat Israel under a discriminatory agenda item — in which the world’s democracies refuse to participate — HRW and Amnesty join the jackals. When an international coalition of NGOs called in 2005 for the council to apply equal treatment, Roth refused to sign.
 
Moreover, HRW is a key supporter of the council’s Palestinian-sponsored investigations of the Jewish state, which seek to deny Israelis the right to self-defense against Hamas terrorism. Even HRW founder Robert L. Bernstein denounced the organization’s loss of critical perspective on the Middle East, and quit.
 
Roth insists he only opposed Haley’s method, fearing it would open a Pandora’s Box, but that he truly supports reform. Yet given the group’s complicity with some of the council’s worst pathologies, and his relentless trumpeting of its “significant contributions to human rights,” Roth seems all too content with things as they are.
Azerbaijan takes measures to turn Khankandi into safe city - VİDEO

News line

2 schoolchildren detained in France on suspicion of sending bomb threats
15:35 28.03.2024
Ski resort in Georgia hit by avalanche
Ski resort in Georgia hit by avalanche
15:26 28.03.2024
Another protest against French colonialism held in New Caledonia, Azerbaijani flag raised
Another protest against French colonialism held in New Caledonia, Azerbaijani flag raised
15:15 28.03.2024
Media: US did not transfer all information about terrorist attack in Crocus City Hall to Russia
15:00 28.03.2024
Movement ‘Together’ calls on Armenia’s parliamentary forces to express vote of no confidence in Pashinyan
14:41 28.03.2024
Azerbaijan to participate in international trade fair in Istanbul
Azerbaijan to participate in international trade fair in Istanbul
14:32 28.03.2024
Le Pen accuses French government of fraud
14:22 28.03.2024
Armenian Government Grapples with Internal Division on Village Return Issue - Ishkhan Verdiyan talks on Ednews
14:12 28.03.2024
Ammunition found along route of Crocus City Hall terrorists
Ammunition found along route of Crocus City Hall terrorists
13:41 28.03.2024
Expert Ilyas Huseynov Predicts Peaceful Return of these territories to Azerbaijan
13:20 28.03.2024
Azerbaijan weather forecast for March 29
Azerbaijan weather forecast for March 29
12:55 28.03.2024
Russian MFA concerned about upcoming Armenia-US-EU meeting
12:23 28.03.2024
Secret Points of Pashinyan's Meeting with French Representative: Is Peace Agreement Signing Imminent?
12:00 28.03.2024
Armenia announces recruitment of border guards to work at Zvartnots
Armenia announces recruitment of border guards to work at Zvartnots
11:47 28.03.2024
The US-Armenia-EU Joint Conference is a part of the pressure plan on Azerbaijan - MP Konul Nurullayeva
11:30 28.03.2024
Azerbaijan’s central bank reduces discount rate
Azerbaijan’s central bank reduces discount rate
11:23 28.03.2024
CSTO chief: ‘Yerevan doesn’t participate in our work, but there are no statements about suspension’
11:13 28.03.2024
Ammunition found in Khankandi
Ammunition found in Khankandi
11:00 28.03.2024
Russia had been aware of preparation for terrorist attack at Crocus - says intelligience chief
10:46 28.03.2024
Scholtz reveals date of his last telephone conversation with Putin
Scholtz reveals date of his last telephone conversation with Putin
10:33 28.03.2024
Head of the SSS: France is inciting Armenia to a new war
10:21 28.03.2024
Are we in the brink of World War III? - Pundit talks on Ednews
10:10 28.03.2024
Azerbaijan's National Security: Reflecting on 105 Years of Defending Sovereignty
09:55 28.03.2024
Hikmat Hajiyev: Rasmussen fell in forgetfulness to attach payment to his report
09:35 28.03.2024
Hand grenades found in Kalbajar
09:25 28.03.2024
Titanic 'door' prop that kept Rose alive sells for $718,750
Titanic 'door' prop that kept Rose alive sells for $718,750
08:50 28.03.2024
Twitch's biggest streamer diagnosed with cancer diagnosis at 32
23:55 27.03.2024
Azerbaijan's former Minister of National Security passes away
22:41 27.03.2024
Russia has no unfriendly states, only unfriendly elites — Putin
22:25 27.03.2024
Erdogan vows to make efforts for implementation of UN resolution regarding Gaza
Erdogan vows to make efforts for implementation of UN resolution regarding Gaza
21:44 27.03.2024
Russian MFA: France's presence in the Caucasus is of an intelligence nature
21:00 27.03.2024
Record numbers of migrants arrive in UK in 2024
20:42 27.03.2024
Leo Docherty appointed new UK Minister of State for Armed Forces
Leo Docherty appointed new UK Minister of State for Armed Forces
19:34 27.03.2024
MFA: ‘We reject anti-Azerbaijani allegations in the report prepared by Friends of Armenia Network’
19:00 27.03.2024
Armenian Speaker: We are looking for people who consider those villages to be Armenian territory
18:42 27.03.2024
France evacuates over 170 nationals from Haiti
France evacuates over 170 nationals from Haiti
18:19 27.03.2024
Iran's Concerns Over Enclave Villages Return Highlight Geopolitical Complexities - Iranian political scientest talks on Ednews
18:00 27.03.2024
New details of the Crocus terrorist attack have been revealed - two suspects transited through Türkiye
17:33 27.03.2024
Political Scientist Turab Rzayev Weighs in on Armenia's "Great Armenia" Ambitions: Pashinyan's Realism or Rhetoric?
17:00 27.03.2024
Armenian did not join statement of CSTO PA condemning terrorist act in Crocus
Armenian did not join statement of CSTO PA condemning terrorist act in Crocus
16:39 27.03.2024
Hamısı