EU ministers question Poland over rule of law concerns

World 10:18 19.09.2018

Poland’s right-wing government sought to explain itself to its European Union peers on Tuesday for the second time in three months on Tuesday amid concern over changes to the judiciary that the EU believes undermine it’s courts’ independence.

Polish Minister for European Affairs Konrad Szymanski said on entering the hearing before EU ministers in Brussels that he would defend changes to the judiciary brought by the eurosceptic PiS government. He is facing a tough task.

Image result for EU ministers question Poland over rule of law concerns

In a joint declaration delivered by German Minister of State Michael Roth in the name of France and Germany at the start of the hearing, the two biggest EU countries said that despite numerous discussions already held with Warsaw, concerns over on the rule of law in Poland have not dissipated.

“On the contrary, since July 3rd and the implementation of the new retirement regime for Supreme Court judges, the situation has become more urgent than ever,” delegation sources quoted Roth as telling the hearing.

The hearing is part of the bloc’s procedure, called Article 7, used against countries that violate fundamental rights and the rule of law.

The process first allows EU governments to give a formal warning to a country accused of violating fundamental rights but ultimately could end in suspending its EU voting rights.

Poland’s situation echoes that of Hungary, which the European Parliament last week sanctioned for flouting EU rules on democracy, civil rights and corruption.

The process was triggered by the European Commission because the Polish government has enacted laws forcing into early retirement many Supreme Court judges, and it trying to replace them with its own nominees.

As a result Poland was suspended on Monday from the European Network of Councils for the Judiciary (ENCJ), which decided the Polish council is no longer independent because it is now appointed by politicians, rather than judges as before.

The forced retirement of judges has been criticized by EU institutions, human rights groups and the opposition as going against the rule of law. The Supreme Court itself has asked the European Court of Justice, the EU’s top court, to rule if the early retirement was legal, but an ECJ ruling may take months.

In the meantime, the Polish Supreme Court ruled that the proposed PiS changes should be frozen until the ECJ ruling is made. However, President Andrzej Duda, who is backed by the PiS, has moved to appoint new Supreme Court judges nonetheless.

“As we observe, in the last weeks, first steps are being taken to replace the Supreme Court Judges,” Roth said.

This was problematic, he said.

“We hope that Poland acts constructively and does not take actions which cannot be changed afterwards,” he said.

The PiS has already replaced many judges at the Polish Constitutional Tribunal and the heads of regular courts. Since coming to power in late 2015, it has also tightened its grip on public media and controls over non-government groups.

The legal paralysis of the Polish Supreme Court also poses additional difficulties because it is the institution that declares the validity of elections in the country of 38 million people. Poland is due to hold local elections in October.

In August, the European Commission stepped up its legal case against Poland taking a formal infringement procedure against Warsaw to a second level, giving Poland one month to reverse the changes or face a trial at the ECJ.

But Warsaw has made no concessions and the Commission is expected to file a lawsuit against it at the ECJ on Wednesday.

This is how Rahman Mustafayev exposed the representation of Armenia in ICJ - VIDEO

News line

Final Day of Hearings in 'Armenia vs. Azerbaijan' Case at the Hague Court - LIVE
12:02 19.04.2024
Australia tells citizens to leave Israel
Australia tells citizens to leave Israel
11:50 19.04.2024
'Regrettably, the United States exhibits a biased position regarding peacekeepers' - MP Konul Nurullayeva
11:34 19.04.2024
The US does not want the Zangezur corridor to be opened under these conditions - OPINION
11:20 19.04.2024
Armenian general: Russia is the cause of all troubles
11:02 19.04.2024
Man arrested in Poland over suspected Russian plot to assassinate Zelensky
10:50 19.04.2024
Price of Azerbaijan oil drops
Price of Azerbaijan oil drops
10:35 19.04.2024
Azerbaijani police found numerous weapons and ammunition in Khankandi
10:23 19.04.2024
Chad threatens to kick out US troops
10:00 19.04.2024
Terrorists kill 16 soldiers in Syria
Terrorists kill 16 soldiers in Syria
09:49 19.04.2024
Biden calls China ‘xenophobic’
09:30 19.04.2024
Maduro: Despite US sanctions, Venesuela’s oil industry will develop
09:17 19.04.2024
Kenyan military helicopter crashes, five soldiers killed, police say
Kenyan military helicopter crashes, five soldiers killed, police say
23:45 18.04.2024
Greek PM Mitsotakis to meet Erdogan on May 13 in Ankara
22:55 18.04.2024
Guterres: ‘The Middle East is on a knife-edge’
Guterres: ‘The Middle East is on a knife-edge’
22:33 18.04.2024
CBA chairman discusses importance of COP29 in long-term development of global economy in Washington
22:00 18.04.2024
US Ambassador Marks Visit to Liberated Territories of Aghdam -PHOTOS
21:30 18.04.2024
Georgian State Minister for Reconciliation meets US Senior Advisor for Caucasus Negotiations
Georgian State Minister for Reconciliation meets US Senior Advisor for Caucasus Negotiations
21:21 18.04.2024
US and UK imposed fresh sanctions on Iran
20:43 18.04.2024
A Race Against Time: Can SDGs Goals Transform Our World by 2030? - ANALYSIS
20:18 18.04.2024
Japan to start 5th ocean discharge of Fukushima nuclear
19:30 18.04.2024
What does the departure of Russian peacekeepers from Karabakh mean? - Georgian pundit talks on Ednews
19:02 18.04.2024
EU made it's final decision on imposing sanctions on Iran following attack on Israel
18:42 18.04.2024
The new law in Italy may increase pressure on women
The new law in Italy may increase pressure on women
18:00 18.04.2024
EU Summit Stresses Importance of Stable Relations with Türkiye and Cyprus
EU Summit Stresses Importance of Stable Relations with Türkiye and Cyprus
17:48 18.04.2024
Caspian Sea Desalination Project: A Promising Solution for Water Security - OPINION
17:30 18.04.2024
Tesla Eyes $2-3 Billion Investment in India Amid Market Challenges
Tesla Eyes $2-3 Billion Investment in India Amid Market Challenges
17:21 18.04.2024
The EU will treat the violation of sanctions as a "judicial crime"
17:10 18.04.2024
European Commission to earmark €15M assistance to Armenia
European Commission to earmark €15M assistance to Armenia
16:55 18.04.2024
Was the presence of peacekeepers a threat to Azerbaijan? - OPINION
16:48 18.04.2024
Russia's presence in the South Caucasus is over - Russian Pundit
16:40 18.04.2024
Armenia PM: Turkish army is 50 meters away from Margara village houses, our goal is to get such situation
Armenia PM: Turkish army is 50 meters away from Margara village houses, our goal is to get such situation
16:31 18.04.2024
Iran threatens to attack Israel's nuclear facilities
16:05 18.04.2024
Samuel Wordsworth: Armenian claims of ethnic cleansing remain unfounded - VİDEO
15:43 18.04.2024
Channel for sale of human organs identified in Kyrgyzstan
Channel for sale of human organs identified in Kyrgyzstan
15:30 18.04.2024
This is how Rahman Mustafayev exposed the representation of Armenia in ICJ - VIDEO
15:17 18.04.2024
Azerbaijani NGOs adress open letter to Norwegian Nobel Committee regarding Ruben Vardanyan
15:02 18.04.2024
Russian MFA: West continues to militarize South Caucasus
14:46 18.04.2024
Umud Mirzayev: 'I have been gradually waiting for the Russian peacekeepers to leave Karabakh'
14:32 18.04.2024
Parliaments of Azerbaijan and New Caledonia ink memorandum of cooperation
Parliaments of Azerbaijan and New Caledonia ink memorandum of cooperation
14:17 18.04.2024
Hamısı