Rights, Wrongs, Future, and Risks of Ukraine’s Kursk Incursion

Experts Weigh In

Analytics 16:00 15.08.2024

Since August 6, Russia has been grappling with Ukraine's unexpected military incursion into the border regions of Kursk. Despite significant efforts, Russian forces have been unable to reclaim the territories now under Ukrainian control. The situation has escalated, with Alexei Smirnov acknowledging in a meeting with President Vladimir Putin that 74 settlements in the Kursk region have fallen to Ukrainian forces. This development raises questions about Kyiv's strategic intentions, leading some to speculate whether this could mark the beginning of a conflict as decisive as the historic Battle of Kursk during World War II.

Experts have weighed in on the potential implications of this confrontation to Ednews:

Irish political analyst and historian Patrick Walsh expressed skepticism about the significance of the current conflict compared to the first Battle of Kursk.

"I doubt the second battle of Kursk will be anything like the scale or importance of the first. Putin is treating the Ukrainian force as essentially a commando group defining this as an anti-terrorist operation rather than an invasion. Russia is dealing with the Ukrainian raid at leisure  knowing it is a sideshow to the real conflict in Donbas, where the war will be decided. The Kremlin know the Ukrainian intention is to get the Russians to divert forces to Kursk but the Russians are not obliging. Kyiv has launched an incursion into an area that has only small settlements and which is of little strategic value and few Russian forces. The idea is to make maximum political impact with declining resources, when an offensive on the main battlefield is impossible for Kyiv. Obviously much will be made of Russian failure to dislodge these forces in the Western media but their continued  presence all depends on what force Russia applies to the incursion. At the moment the Kremlin is treating the situation as an unexpected inconvenience of minor embarrassment rather than a serious threat. The Kremlin wants to stick to the main business and not be diverted by sideshows. Of course, Kyiv's intention is the opposite."

In contrast, German political analyst Brendan Fraser argued that Ukraine's actions could shift the dynamics of negotiations between Kyiv and Moscow.

"Ukraine's attack on Kursk changed the dynamics of the current battles," Fraser stated. He highlighted the unexpected timing of the incursion, suggesting that it occurred when Russia might have been seeking to de-escalate the conflict. Fraser warned that continued Ukrainian advances, with the number of captured settlements reportedly rising to 74, could force Russia to divert resources from other critical fronts, such as Donbas. He also suggested that sustained operations on Russian soil could lead to domestic discontent, potentially destabilizing the Putin regime.

 

IEPF issued a statement regarding Azerbaijani children at the UN Human Rights Council

News line

The village of Jahangirbeyli is being rebuilt
13:05 24.04.2025
The strategic partnership between Azerbaijan and China is reaching a qualitatively new stage
12:48 24.04.2025
Leyla Aliyeva met with students at Beijing Foreign Studies University
12:33 24.04.2025
Armenia might resort to military provocation against Azerbaijan with France's support
12:23 24.04.2025
"China has become Azerbaijan's 4th largest trading partner"
12:23 24.04.2025
"We have sincere feelings for Azerbaijan"
12:13 24.04.2025
Pakistan ready to expand cooperation with Azerbaijan in peaceful space exploration
12:12 24.04.2025
China and Azerbaijan build comprehensive strategic partnership: messages from the country's leaders to the world
11:51 24.04.2025
Azercosmos to sign up to 10 Memorandums within the Space Technologies Conference
11:37 24.04.2025
Members of the world-famous ''NomadMania'' travel club are in Fuzuli
11:22 24.04.2025
President Ilham Aliyev gave an interview to China's CGTN TV channel in Beijing
11:11 24.04.2025
A book of condolences was opened at the Italian Embassy in Baku on the death of Francis
11:07 24.04.2025
Trainings for government officials responsible for communications organized in Baku Media
10:56 24.04.2025
"Azerbaijani Cinema Days" to be held in Turkiye
10:44 24.04.2025
ILRS can expand cooperation opportunities with Azerbaijan in the space field
10:37 24.04.2025
Space Technologies Conference to be held in Uzbekistan next year
10:31 24.04.2025
The 17th Summit of the economic organization is a struggle in Khankendi
10:23 24.04.2025
Azerbaijan to be represented at regional financial conference in the US
10:19 24.04.2025
Nikol Pashinyan condemned the burning of Azerbaijani and Turkish flags
10:15 24.04.2025
Fitch: US tariff hike will have minimal impact on Azerbaijani banks
10:12 24.04.2025
A solemn concert dedicated to the 140th anniversary of Uzeyir Hajibeyli was held in Bishkek
10:10 24.04.2025
Discussion of "Immunization Week" in Azerbaijan from April 27 to May 3
10:08 24.04.2025
Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev met with the chairman of ''Energy China''
08:22 24.04.2025
Artificial intelligence can detect lung cancer four months before doctors
05:13 24.04.2025
Over 30,000 hectares of fruit orchards established in Azerbaijan
12:45 23.04.2025
Mascots of 3rd CIS Games to be held in Azerbaijan announced
12:42 23.04.2025
China has invited President Ilham Aliyev to the SCO Summit
12:02 23.04.2025
Azerbaijan and China signed documents in Beijing
11:54 23.04.2025
Armenia yet to confirm participation in 3rd CIS Games in Azerbaijan
11:35 23.04.2025
Azerbaijan and Kazakhstan actively develop interparliamentary cooperation
11:29 23.04.2025
Azerbaijan's First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva and other family members visited the Great Hall of the People
11:24 23.04.2025
The 4th meeting of the Space Agencies of the Turkic States Organization is being held in Baku
11:18 23.04.2025
Six green energy documents signed with Chinese companies
11:07 23.04.2025
The Azerbaijan-China strategic partnership is reaching a new stage
11:03 23.04.2025
Azerbaijan's success at COP29 was rewarded in London
10:55 23.04.2025
''I lost two sons in one day": victims of mine terror appeared at the trial of Ruben Vardanyan
10:44 23.04.2025
Members of the Azerbaijan Union of Chernobyl Disabled People visited the Alley of Martyrs
10:44 23.04.2025
The joint satellite of Azerbaijan, Turkey could be the flagship cooperation in the space field
10:40 23.04.2025
The mascots of the III CIS Games to be held in Azerbaijan
10:32 23.04.2025
Azerbaijan-China documents signed in Beijing
10:30 23.04.2025
Hamısı