Rights, Wrongs, Future, and Risks of Ukraine’s Kursk Incursion

Experts Weigh In

Analytics 16:00 15.08.2024

Since August 6, Russia has been grappling with Ukraine's unexpected military incursion into the border regions of Kursk. Despite significant efforts, Russian forces have been unable to reclaim the territories now under Ukrainian control. The situation has escalated, with Alexei Smirnov acknowledging in a meeting with President Vladimir Putin that 74 settlements in the Kursk region have fallen to Ukrainian forces. This development raises questions about Kyiv's strategic intentions, leading some to speculate whether this could mark the beginning of a conflict as decisive as the historic Battle of Kursk during World War II.

Experts have weighed in on the potential implications of this confrontation to Ednews:

Irish political analyst and historian Patrick Walsh expressed skepticism about the significance of the current conflict compared to the first Battle of Kursk.

"I doubt the second battle of Kursk will be anything like the scale or importance of the first. Putin is treating the Ukrainian force as essentially a commando group defining this as an anti-terrorist operation rather than an invasion. Russia is dealing with the Ukrainian raid at leisure  knowing it is a sideshow to the real conflict in Donbas, where the war will be decided. The Kremlin know the Ukrainian intention is to get the Russians to divert forces to Kursk but the Russians are not obliging. Kyiv has launched an incursion into an area that has only small settlements and which is of little strategic value and few Russian forces. The idea is to make maximum political impact with declining resources, when an offensive on the main battlefield is impossible for Kyiv. Obviously much will be made of Russian failure to dislodge these forces in the Western media but their continued  presence all depends on what force Russia applies to the incursion. At the moment the Kremlin is treating the situation as an unexpected inconvenience of minor embarrassment rather than a serious threat. The Kremlin wants to stick to the main business and not be diverted by sideshows. Of course, Kyiv's intention is the opposite."

In contrast, German political analyst Brendan Fraser argued that Ukraine's actions could shift the dynamics of negotiations between Kyiv and Moscow.

"Ukraine's attack on Kursk changed the dynamics of the current battles," Fraser stated. He highlighted the unexpected timing of the incursion, suggesting that it occurred when Russia might have been seeking to de-escalate the conflict. Fraser warned that continued Ukrainian advances, with the number of captured settlements reportedly rising to 74, could force Russia to divert resources from other critical fronts, such as Donbas. He also suggested that sustained operations on Russian soil could lead to domestic discontent, potentially destabilizing the Putin regime.

 

IEPF organized a discussion at COP29 on the role of NGOs in combating the climate crisis

News line

How did Western Europe become a puppet?
12:10 15.02.2025
Why Trump’s assault on USAID could change US foreign policy forever
12:06 08.02.2025
Why Gorbochev’s Nobel Peace Prize should be rescinded -Rachel Avraham
15:26 04.02.2025
Parvana Valiyeva has given an interview to the Nigerian press
08:53 30.01.2025
The First Meeting of the IEPF Board of Trustees in 2025 Was Held
19:47 28.01.2025
The historical and cultural heritage of Azerbaijan in Armenia: Obligation of Armenia to preserve and restore
19:55 25.01.2025
"Deprive Gorbachev of the Peace Prize" Open Letter to the Chair and Members of the Norwegian Nobel Committee
16:14 18.01.2025
"Azerbaijan, representing itself in D-9 as a victorious nation, will further solidify its authority."
13:42 16.01.2025
Turning Landmines Into Grapevines In Post-War Azerbaijan -"Forbes" wrote...
16:05 26.12.2024
"Nine countries to become BRICS partners in 2025"
21:09 23.12.2024
"From Zero to Rise" – Umud Mirzayev's Next Meeting with Students Held
17:35 23.12.2024
IEPF Statement on the Resolution of the Lower House of the Swiss Parliament on “Nagorno-Karabakh: Peace Forum”
17:36 19.12.2024
BRI, threats, tariffs and Trump
09:03 04.12.2024
COP29: GLOBAL CALL TO ERADICATE LANDMINES IN AZERBAIJAN AND WORLDWIDE
17:56 18.11.2024
As Trump looms large, can Keir Starmer save the world? Analytics
12:49 17.11.2024
IEPF Holds Side Event at COP29
16:40 15.11.2024
Chief of NGO Branch, Office of Intergovernmental Support and Coordination for SDG, DESA, United Nations visited IEPF
18:08 14.11.2024
Can Trump reconcile Israel and Iran? Analytics
09:11 14.11.2024
IEPF organized a discussion at COP29 on the role of NGOs in combating the climate crisis
18:19 11.11.2024
Why Kamala Harris lost: A flawed candidate or doomed campaign? Analytics
14:32 07.11.2024
What Trump's win means for Ukraine, Middle East and China
09:56 07.11.2024
"Give us back our gods" "Inside Nepal's Museum of Stolen Art"
10:52 06.11.2024
Side Event on Mine Issues Held at UN Geneva Office
17:07 01.11.2024
A lost Maya city has been discovered deep within the jungles of Mexico
13:06 31.10.2024
"How Does Artificial Intelligence Affect Jobs?" Research
12:47 31.10.2024
"Is Europe Ready for Climate Change?"
10:26 31.10.2024
Orban and Tusk: How Did the “Two Brothers” Become Enemies?
15:02 29.10.2024
Why China needs BRICS
13:30 28.10.2024
More than 120 killed and dozens injured after Tropical Storm Trami batters Philippines
10:57 28.10.2024
Lithuania's Parliamentary Elections Conclude - Social Democrats Come to Power
10:27 28.10.2024
Pyrrhic Victory: Japan's ruling party has lost its parliamentary majority
10:03 28.10.2024
Astronauts Have Returned
09:15 28.10.2024
Does Israel Want Ceasfire? Important Messages from the Israeli Defense Minister and President
09:10 28.10.2024
Iran's Leaders Respond to Israel's Attack - "We do not want war, but... "
09:05 28.10.2024
Terrorist attack in Ankara: A message for Erdogan?
09:00 28.10.2024
Entire northern Gaza population at risk of dying – UN
08:45 28.10.2024
The Commonwealth members demand compensation from the United Kingdom
17:31 27.10.2024
Tigers vs tribals: Why are thousands of villagers up in arms against endangered species?
11:00 27.10.2024
Russia wants the world divided and in conflict NATO cannot let this happen
13:11 26.10.2024
Source of "Marburg" Strain Found: Bats Again..
17:35 25.10.2024
Hamısı