"Erdogan becomes Turkish Putin" Russian historian on the results of the referendum-Exclusive

Interviews 15:39 17.04.2017

Russian political scientist, candidate of historical sciences Oleg Kuznetsov answered Eurasia Diary's questions regarding the referendum held yesterday in Turkey. He spoke about the split in Turkish society and about the consequences of the new reform.

Recall, yesterday Turkey held a national referendum, according to which the majority of the population voted for the expansion of presidential powers. The amendments to the constitution will give President Erdogan unprecedented powers.

Eurasia Diary: Mr. Kuznetsov, why did the Turkish people support the reform?

Oleg Kuznetsov: Let's be honest, the preponderance of 52% of votes against 48% is almost minimal, so I would not say that the entire Turkish population supported Erdogan's innovations. we can name it the majority only when it is explicit  part of society, or as the lawyers say, "qualified" which is the two-thirds or three-quarters of the votes. If this was the case in a referendum of Turkey, then it would be possible to speak about the support of the majority. With such a vote, I cannot be so optimistic. It appears to be not an Erdogan's victory, but the split in Turkish society.

Absolutely all international analysts pay attention to the fact that the resident of Istanbul, Ankara, Izmir, ie, cities - millionaires, centers of concentration of capital and business, did not support the idea of ​​a final transition from a parliamentary republic to a presidential one. After the referendum, the confrontation between Erdogan and the elites will not only  weaken, but also intensify on the contrary. If, up to this point, Erdogan was opposed by the army and bureaucracy, devoted to the ideas of Gazi Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, now big business can stand in opposition to Erdogan, after which his political future will be under serious question.

Eurasia Diary: What is the position of the Russian side on such a reform?

Oleg Kuznetsov: The model of the state administration that Turkey chose for itself in the last referendum is no different from the form of government that exists today in Russia or in Azerbaijan. Therefore, it is understandable and familiar for the Russian political science community, at least for the part that does not earn a living by populism and commenting on events for the sake of political conjuncture. Based on the results of the referendum, Erdogan becomes a Turkish Putin with all the inherent mechanisms of "manual control" of the state by mechanisms and tools. Today we can only state one fact: the republic of Mustafa Kemal Ataturk became a part of past history.

Eurasia Diary: What will the reform actually change? How will the situation in the region and the relationship with the EU alter?

Oleg Kuznetsov: Any referendum has an impact, first of all, on internal political processes in the country, rather than its foreign policy. there are many states in the world with various forms of government, and this does not have the slightest influence on their position in the international arena. In general, I would not link state-legal and foreign policy aspects. Usually, any state in its foreign policy demonstrates the coordinated will of the ruling elites, and the referendum in Turkey has so far led to a split in society. It will take time for the upper layers of society to regain consensus in a new configuration for itself, and until that happens, it will be extremely reckless to talk about any specific impact of the results of the referendum in Turkey on the foreign policy of this country.


Interviewed by Natalya Guliyeva

 

Journalists from Uzbekistan embarked on a visit to International Eurasia Press Fund -PHOTOS/VIDEO

News line

US secretly shipped long-range missiles to Ukraine
11:16 25.04.2024
10th session of Azerbaijan-Hungary intergovernmental commission kicks off in Baku
11:03 25.04.2024
Azerbaijani citizens granted access to visit newly liberated Lachin in their own vehicles
10:51 25.04.2024
Azerbaijan, US discuss implementation of risk-based supervision model in banks
Azerbaijan, US discuss implementation of risk-based supervision model in banks
10:35 25.04.2024
Ammunition found in Khankandi
10:12 25.04.2024
Politico: ‘Ukraine may not receive additional financial aid from US until election’
10:02 25.04.2024
'US welcomes start of border delimitation process between Azerbaijan, Armenia - State Dept
09:47 25.04.2024
Price of Azerbaijan oil increases
Price of Azerbaijan oil increases
09:31 25.04.2024
National Hero Albert Agarunov remembered on his birthday
09:15 25.04.2024
Hungarian FM embarks on a visit to Azerbaijan
08:50 25.04.2024
Antonov: Russian forces will 'burn' all US supplies to Ukraine
23:42 24.04.2024
Kazakhstan, UK sign strategic partnership and cooperation agreement
22:40 24.04.2024
Iraqi President was invited to COP29
Iraqi President was invited to COP29
22:12 24.04.2024
State reception was hosted in honor of President of Kyrgyzstan Sadyr Zhaparov
21:00 24.04.2024
Journalists from Uzbekistan embarked on a visit to International Eurasia Press Fund -PHOTOS/VIDEO
20:10 24.04.2024
Biden signs Israel, Ukraine, TikTok bill into law
20:00 24.04.2024
Doha hosts first face-to-face Russia-Ukraine talks on return of children
19:30 24.04.2024
International experts from 30 countries view restoration work in Lachin
19:15 24.04.2024
Ombudsman informs UK ambassador about landmine terrorism by Armenia against Azerbaijan
19:00 24.04.2024
Israel's Defense Minister: ‘Half of Hezbollah's commanders have been killed’
Israel's Defense Minister: ‘Half of Hezbollah's commanders have been killed’
18:45 24.04.2024
Azerbaijan's insurance market rises
18:30 24.04.2024
Belarus deploys tactical nuclear weapons on its territory
Belarus deploys tactical nuclear weapons on its territory
18:15 24.04.2024
US President Biden once again used "Armenian genocide" term
18:00 24.04.2024
Estonia welcomes remarkable developments in Armenia-Azerbaijan border delimitation process
17:45 24.04.2024
Azerbaijan's Pardon Issues Commission holds next meeting, number of appeals exceed 300
Azerbaijan's Pardon Issues Commission holds next meeting, number of appeals exceed 300
17:30 24.04.2024
Azerbaijan's representation at the UN Committee Against Torture is ongoing - LIVE
17:29 24.04.2024
Azerbaijan, the U.S. mull issues of cyber security in financial field
17:15 24.04.2024
Kazakhstan expects second wave of floods
17:00 24.04.2024
France proposes new EU sanctions against Russia
16:45 24.04.2024
President of Kyrgyzstan highlights construction of secondary school in Aghdam district
16:30 24.04.2024
Erdogan meets with German President
16:15 24.04.2024
Azerbaijani ambassador meets with Gambia foreign minister
Azerbaijani ambassador meets with Gambia foreign minister
16:00 24.04.2024
Pelosi says Israel's Netanyahu 'should resign' as prime minister
15:45 24.04.2024
Türkiye urges world community to support Ankara-Yerevan normalization process
15:30 24.04.2024
Sadyr Zhaparov: Azerbaijan is building its bright future with confidence
15:15 24.04.2024
Media: About 30 Israeli generals and Shin Bet officers held hostage by Hamas
Media: About 30 Israeli generals and Shin Bet officers held hostage by Hamas
15:00 24.04.2024
Monkeypox epidemic declared in Congo
14:50 24.04.2024
Ilham Aliyev: Visit of President of Kyrgyzstan to Azerbaijan will contribute to strengthening friendly, fraternal relations between two countries
14:40 24.04.2024
President Ilham Aliyev: ‘Azerbaijan is determined to continue active interaction with Kyrgyzstan in all areas’
14:38 24.04.2024
President of Azerbaijan invites his Kyrgyz counterpart to COP29
President of Azerbaijan invites his Kyrgyz counterpart to COP29
14:30 24.04.2024
Hamısı