A need for serious answers The Ghazni battle

Analytics 00:34 22.08.2018
The battle for the Afghan city of Ghazni is over. That an important provincial city was largely captured is more important in the minds of vulnerable Afghans than that the Taliban were driven out. Now, important questions need to be answered. And the answers need to result in action.
 
After 17 years of war, many people have their minds made up. Those who consider the war lost will rush to find proof of that in the battle. Those who defend the war are likely to point out that the new strategy of building Afghan forces has barely begun and that the Taliban were driven out with serious losses. Neither of these viewpoints is worth much without a serious consideration of what happened and what needs to be done.
 
The Obama administration put money and equipment into building the Afghan forces but denied the time or personnel needed to give the effort a chance. Only 50 percent of required training teams were ever fielded and the major training effort lasted barely three years, scarcely time to more than double the Afghan forces. The current strategy wants to take the time to train and repair the mistakes of the past. Fielding the current, largely U.S. training force took time, and the real effort has been under way only a few months, far too short a period to judge whether increased training can make a difference on the battlefield. But training can make a difference only if the will to use it is present in the Afghans. Ghazni raises disturbing questions.
 
I certainly do not have a full picture of what happened. But fragments I hear from Afghans, and what I read, are disturbing: a breakdown in command, Afghan police, intelligence services and the army not supporting each other; forces asking for help and not getting it. The stories are anecdotal fragments but they suggest a wide-scale breakdown in command and control. It is possible that some units failed to fight well, but this is unconfirmed. There are other news stories of small Afghan bases overrun in the north and east. In these cases also, requests for help are said to have gone unanswered.
 
These are first impressions, and those are often wrong in Afghanistan. Calls for help sometimes have been exaggerated by local commanders to gain extra supplies or equipment. But the stories are all too similar to the accounts that came out of the fall of the city of Kunduz three years ago.  If these stories are correct, then there seems to have been little improvement in the Afghan command. Above all, they suggest too many officers remain failures. If that persists, then the war eventually will be lost.
 
Now is the time for answers to very fundamental questions.
 
On the side of the Afghan security forces and NATO, will there be a ruthless after-action appraisal? Will lessons be drawn and fundamental changes undertaken to improve? This could be a moment of great learning and realistic appraisal of what needs to be done. But that has not happened in the past. There are some really competent Afghan commanders, but they must be put in charge and supported, not micro-managed, especially for political reasons, as they improve their commands. Those who fail the test of leadership and efficiency need to be rooted out by the Afghan government and command, but the civilian government must avoid micro-management.  The government of President Ashraf Ghani needs to hold the security services responsible but not seek to manage too much from Kabul.
 
On the side of the Taliban, what lessons are drawn?  If they had high casualties, is morale up or down? Can they just go on repeating this sort of attack? And, what were their goals? Did they just want a political victory, which they got, although perhaps at a high cost? Did they think they could hold the town? Why did they stay and take losses in the last days of fighting? If we don't figure out fact-based answers to some of these questions, and instead just make assumptions, our policy responses risk being seriously wrong.
 
Lastly, there is the issue of what the outcome in Ghazni might mean for peace. Is it a Taliban rejection? Is it positioning for starting talks from a stronger position? Speculating about these important questions without solid evidence is foolish. We need to keep the questions open while we work on both fighting and talking.  
 
In short, there is a great deal we need to learn. There even may be opportunity to correct fundamental problems and adjust policy. But until we have fact-based answers to guide our actions, both rapid policy decisions and the speculation of the commentariat are a waste of time.
Azerbaijan takes measures to turn Khankandi into safe city - VİDEO

News line

How will the EU's visit to the South Caucasus affect the peace process? - Former ambassador talks to Ednews
13:00 29.03.2024
Azerbaijan tightens sanctions for breaching special operation zone rules on religious extremism
12:45 29.03.2024
Azerbaijan toughens penalties for non-compliance with rules of social emergency environment regime
12:33 29.03.2024
About $7 bln of foreign direct investment was invested in Azerbaijan last year
12:00 29.03.2024
Number of people injured in Crocus City Hall terrorist attack reaches 382
11:48 29.03.2024
Media: Netanyahu rejected the Mossad Chief's proposal for a possible agreement in Gaza
11:37 29.03.2024
Azerbaijani Parliament's meeting kicks off
11:26 29.03.2024
An American couple founded a website, which identifies brands that support Israel
An American couple founded a website, which identifies brands that support Israel
11:07 29.03.2024
US scientists name infection more dangerous for brain than coronavirus
US scientists name infection more dangerous for brain than coronavirus
11:00 29.03.2024
Parviz Shahbazov: Foundations of 4 new renewable energy plants will be laid this year
Parviz Shahbazov: Foundations of 4 new renewable energy plants will be laid this year
10:50 29.03.2024
Japan eyes self-driving expressway lane network
10:40 29.03.2024
Oil prices end 1Q24 with strong growth
10:30 29.03.2024
SECRETS of the European Union's visit to the South Caucasus - Fikret Sadigov EXPLAINS
10:25 29.03.2024
Israeli strikes on Syria kill dozens, security sources say
10:20 29.03.2024
Ammunition found in Khankandi
Ammunition found in Khankandi
10:10 29.03.2024
Iran’s top diplomat: Military presence of third countries in Caspian Sea goes against interests of region
Iran’s top diplomat: Military presence of third countries in Caspian Sea goes against interests of region
10:00 29.03.2024
Armenia officially announces freezing its participation in CSTO
09:50 29.03.2024
US hopes to return to purchase of 72 fighter jets per year amid budget cuts
09:38 29.03.2024
Another 138 IDPs leave for Fuzuli
09:28 29.03.2024
Netanyahu: "We have strategic assets of Hamas"
09:17 29.03.2024
Date of next meeting of Armenian and Azerbaijani Parliament Speakers announced
09:00 29.03.2024
Russia prepares for new offensive in May-June l – says Zelensky
23:52 28.03.2024
Russian investigators have evidence of Ukraine link to Crocus terrorists
22:24 28.03.2024
Committee members of the EU Council will visit the South Caucasus region
19:48 28.03.2024
Bayern to pay Thomas Tuchel 12M euro compensation
Bayern to pay Thomas Tuchel 12M euro compensation
19:00 28.03.2024
Crocus City Hall terrorists took drugs before attack - law enforcement agencies
Crocus City Hall terrorists took drugs before attack - law enforcement agencies
18:33 28.03.2024
Azerbaijan, UN Development Program mull future co-op
18:00 28.03.2024
An Independent Trade Union Established within International Eurasia Press Fund - First in NGO sector - PHOTOS
17:39 28.03.2024
Italian PM condemns Macron for idea of sending troops to Ukraine
Italian PM condemns Macron for idea of sending troops to Ukraine
17:23 28.03.2024
Azerbaijan lends clarity to color requirement for taxis
17:02 28.03.2024
Isaac Herzog: Israel has no greater friend than US, and US has no greater friend than Israel
Isaac Herzog: Israel has no greater friend than US, and US has no greater friend than Israel
16:45 28.03.2024
Nigerian army eliminates over 200 militants in 2 weeks
16:30 28.03.2024
Armored Vehicle Coalition for Ukraine launched in Poland
Armored Vehicle Coalition for Ukraine launched in Poland
16:15 28.03.2024
Russia strengthens transport security measures after terror attack at Crocus City Hall
Russia strengthens transport security measures after terror attack at Crocus City Hall
15:55 28.03.2024
Türkiye plays an important role between Russia and Ukraine - says political scientist Ismail Cingoz
15:45 28.03.2024
2 schoolchildren detained in France on suspicion of sending bomb threats
15:35 28.03.2024
Ski resort in Georgia hit by avalanche
Ski resort in Georgia hit by avalanche
15:26 28.03.2024
Another protest against French colonialism held in New Caledonia, Azerbaijani flag raised
Another protest against French colonialism held in New Caledonia, Azerbaijani flag raised
15:15 28.03.2024
Media: US did not transfer all information about terrorist attack in Crocus City Hall to Russia
15:00 28.03.2024
Movement ‘Together’ calls on Armenia’s parliamentary forces to express vote of no confidence in Pashinyan
14:41 28.03.2024
Hamısı