Europe faces challenge: Revolt of 'Yellow Vests' Interview by Bruno Surdel

Interviews 14:25 12.12.2018

Europe political agenda was shaken by French protests. Spreading violence and civil unrest in Europe is becoming more serious day by day, and make all to think about the root and solution of the revolt.

Eurasia Diary focused the issue and took an interview by Dr. Bruno Surdel.

Dr. Bruno Surdel is an expert at Centre for International Relations Warsaw.

How the revolt emerged and became so popular?

The French protest movement, called “Gilets Jaunes” or “Yellow Vests” has several sources: first, still too much etatism – deeply embedded not only in the French state tradition but also in the French society. France needs even more decentralization or devolution. The powerful Leviathan is quite naturally expected to resolve all the economic and social woes of the people. Second, social injustice and exclusion: 8.8 mln people are living below the poverty line; this makes around 14% of the population, with 65% from that number living in big cities – according to French statistics. The problem increased with the financial crisis of 2008 and the stagnating economy; these issues have not eased until now. Ordinary people are genuinely angry with the reduction of their purchasing power – and on the other hand - slashing of the wealth tax by the current President Emmanuel Macron who after just 18 months in power is called the „President of the rich”. Very many citizens think he has not done enough for them, and instead he has been trying to play a Napoleon on the international stage - including his climate change agenda – a real problem indeed – but probably a lot of French people from provinces think differently. The fuel tax issue became a tipping point, and people exploded. Third, all the revolt wouldn’t have been possible without the incredibly powerful weapon which is social media.

They – with a little help from their owners who had recently introduced some changes in favour of local news – „created” the might of the „Yellow Vests” movement led by ever new viral videos and posts – and sometimes – equally powerful fake news. Fourth, the new French revolt is of that kind that anybody and everybody can subscribe to: ordinary citizens with their everyday, real grievances as well as extreme left and extreme right wing groups. Each of them have their own issues – genuine or imagined – and all of them can be represented within the „Yellow Vests” movement – which is a truly interesting phenomenon. Hence its success:.They could say: „We, the people”. The problem is, however, the terrible violence – it is hard to accept that level of violence. But this is – unfortunately – the lasting tradition of the protest movement in Western Europe.

Do you think that there is 3rd power behind, or is it possible?

- In my personal opinion, the very source of the French protest movement is genuine people’s grievances and problems they face in their everyday lives. On the other hand, however, social media have become the real battlefield for cyber wars waged by various states, including Russia. Actually, I’m not sure if anybody is standing behind the social conflict in France. But, yes – such a conflict is in Moscow’s interests. The weaker and divided the European countries and societies are – the more opportunities and field for the Kremlin’s „divide and impera” agenda. Interestingly, this is China who is interested in a stronger and more integrated European Union as it fits the economic and strategic interests of the Middle Kingdom.

What did the revolts bring to society and politics?

The French revolts have a very long tradition and quite often they had succeeded in changing the ways the governments were doing their business with the society. At least on the surface and in the short term. But this is the people’s self-awareness that gets the maximum empowerment and boost. This is good for France and good for the civil society there. One should bear in mind that such events and images from them become a fuel for people in other countries too. Recently, the Egyptian authorities have got anxious with the yellow vests on the markets’ shelves… Paradoxically, the globalization is working also for the anti-globalists and all the anti-system forces anywhere and everywhere.

It empowers them. Provides them with a unique fuel. But for France, the whole story is a lesson President Macron had to learn, as he proved to be too inexperienced. Now the French government got humiliated a little bit. Is it too less too late? We’ll see this weekend. Probably, Macron’s speech, contrition and promises will work for a part of the „Yellow vests”. The real aim was to divide them and appease a big part of the movement that knows no unity anyway. But – the problem is – that they saw what they have done is working; the government and president are afraid and had capitulated to some extent. Of course, this is just tactics not any capitulation. The reforms have not been revoked. They are just waiting for „better times”. And, sincerely speaking – France needs reforms. But more fairness and solidarity of the rich is needed.

What does this signal mean for France and Europe? 

I think, a kind of a dreadful post-politics world is coming where social media will be creating social movements more than the people themselves. Kind of „Matrix world”. The danger is that any change in social media algorithms made by social media owners, creators and masters will cause social havoc. Real world may – and already can – be steered by the new overlords: social media owners. On the other hand, 2019 year is going to be a real test for all those „Anger groups” living in their virtual worlds and exploding occasionally into the streets. I would prefer instead of violence they go to the polling stations and took part in the elections to the European Parliament next spring. But I’m afraid that very many of those „angry people” will choose staying home instead. Voting is not that spectacular and eye-catching as the live-streaming from demonstrations or riots. It has no chance to become „viral”. So will the people and voters care? I still hope. This is the way we can change the course of European politics. It must be done anyway. „The time is ripe.”

Interviewed by Ulvi Ahmedli

Azerbaijan Defense Minister informs NATO chief on situation in Azerbaijan-Armenia conditional border -VIDEO

News line

Moldova’s Foreign Ministry to expel Russian Embassy employee
Moldova’s Foreign Ministry to expel Russian Embassy employee
13:30 19.03.2024
Azerbaijan weather forecast for March 20
13:13 19.03.2024
Israel, Hamas ready to compromise at Doha talks
13:05 19.03.2024
More than dozen workers trapped in one of Russia's largest gold mines
More than dozen workers trapped in one of Russia's largest gold mines
12:49 19.03.2024
Armenia may face a war if refuses to discuss border issues - Pashinyan
12:22 19.03.2024
North Korea holds firing drill using super-large multiple rocket launchers
North Korea holds firing drill using super-large multiple rocket launchers
11:55 19.03.2024
Fenerbahçe to discuss withdrawing from 'Super Lig'
11:32 19.03.2024
Azerbaijani police found numerous weapons and ammunition in Khankandi
11:08 19.03.2024
US Maritime Administration issues new advisory amid rising maritime threats in Middle East
10:55 19.03.2024
EU looks forward to cooperation with Azerbaijan for successful COP29
10:38 19.03.2024
EU to impose tariffs on Russian grain
10:11 19.03.2024
Embassy of Azerbaijan in France appeals to Azerbaijanis
10:00 19.03.2024
Azerbaijani oil price exceeds $88
Azerbaijani oil price exceeds $88
09:48 19.03.2024
Mehriban Aliyeva makes post on Last Tuesday before Novruz Holiday
09:35 19.03.2024
Pashinyan: Delimitation process between Armenia and Azerbaijan entered practical stage
09:00 19.03.2024
Pakistan restricts foreign travels of ministers, government officials
Pakistan restricts foreign travels of ministers, government officials
20:39 18.03.2024
EU to boost military support fund for Ukraine by EUR 5 bln — Hungarian foreign minister
20:00 18.03.2024
Industrial zones to be created in Azerbaijan’s Zangilan, Jabrayil, and Gubadli
19:16 18.03.2024
Reuters: Only an oil slump can stop Russia
19:00 18.03.2024
Top Hamas operative killed in hospital raid, IDF says
Top Hamas operative killed in hospital raid, IDF says
18:33 18.03.2024
President Ilham Aliyev congratulates people of Azerbaijan on occasion of Novruz holiday - UPDATED
18:00 18.03.2024
Jens Stoltenberg: We fully support Georgia's sovereignty and territorial integrity
Jens Stoltenberg: We fully support Georgia's sovereignty and territorial integrity
17:47 18.03.2024
2 dead, 6 injured in Türkiye factory explosion
2 dead, 6 injured in Türkiye factory explosion
17:28 18.03.2024
Armenia’s anti-Russian policy reaches new level
17:11 18.03.2024
"The Middle Corridor plays a key role for Green Energy" - Expert Ali Pasha
16:45 18.03.2024
Central square of Khankandi named “Victory Square”
16:22 18.03.2024
President: We demonstrated tremendous heroism during the II Karabakh War and the anti-terror operation
16:16 18.03.2024
Nobel Peace Prize Laureate Muhammad Yunus visited IEPF - PHOTOS - VIDEO
16:00 18.03.2024
Historic opportunity emerged to advance the Azerbaijani-Armenian peace agenda - FM Bayramov
15:21 18.03.2024
Bayramov and Stoltenberg discuss normalization process between Azerbaijan and Armenia
15:03 18.03.2024
Azerbaijan Defense Minister informs NATO chief on situation in Azerbaijan-Armenia conditional border -VIDEO
14:58 18.03.2024
Stoltenberg's visit to the Caucasus: "NATO is in panic" - OPİNİON
14:29 18.03.2024
Hikmat Hajiyev holds discussions for upcoming COP29 with Chinese Vice FM
Hikmat Hajiyev holds discussions for upcoming COP29 with Chinese Vice FM
14:00 18.03.2024
Stoltenberg concludes his official visit to Azerbaijan
13:42 18.03.2024
Geomagnetic storm expected on March 20
13:33 18.03.2024
Mbappe celebrates his 250th goal in PSG
Mbappe celebrates his 250th goal in PSG
13:19 18.03.2024
President Ilham Aliyev makes a phone call to Vladimir Putin
13:00 18.03.2024
President Ilham Aliyev lit Novruz bonfire in Khankandi and congratulated Azerbaijani people
12:34 18.03.2024
Foreign students attacked in India over Ramadan prayers
12:30 18.03.2024
Spring comes to Northern Hemisphere
Spring comes to Northern Hemisphere
12:17 18.03.2024
Hamısı