Orangutans are able to 'talk' about the past

World 20:43 18.11.2018

The ability to issue warnings is a common feature in animal communication. Alarm calls can warn group members about the presence of a predator, and can even provide information about the type of predator, as well as its location. Such warnings happen in real time, while the danger is present.

Humans do this too, of course, through screams (which are useful for raising alarm, but not really all that informative) and through language. Importantly, human language also has a unique feature called displaced reference, which is the ability to share information about a past or future event, or about something that is not present at the moment.

Displaced reference is found throughout all human languages and is, in fact, considered a primary hallmark of language. However, beyond humans and, curiously, a handful of insects like the honeybee (which is known for using distinct movements to provide spatial information about  resource location), displaced reference is rare in the animal kingdom. Among primates, humans are alone in possessing this particular communication skill. Or at least that’s what we thought.

Now, researchers at the University of St Andrews in Scotland have discovered that orangutans can use displaced reference to ‘talk’ about past events.

Adriano Lameira, a primatologist at St Andrews, carried out an intriguing study in the Ketambe jungle in Sumatra. He designed an experiment wherein a scientist draped in a sheet with one of four designs — tiger print, white, white with multicolored spots, and an abstract color pattern — would slowly crawl across the forest floor in proximity of an orangutan mother sitting in a tree. Once seen by the orangutan, this artificial ‘predator’ would pause for 2 minutes and then move along, out of sight.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

There were 24 trials in all, and in 12 of these, the mother waited an average of 7 minutes before vocalizing an alarm call.  In one case, an orangutan waited nearly 20 minutes after she first spotted the ‘predator’ before raising a prolonged alarm.

This delay was not only observed when the orangutan was alone (i.e. when they perceived danger for themselves) but it was also observed when mother orangutans sensed their child was in danger (i.e. when they perceived danger for another individual).

So why did those orangutans wait before raising the alarm?

Lamiera proposes that the decision to call or not call may be linked to a perceived danger for others coupled with the need to not make matters worse. Vocalizing in the presence of a predator comes with a risk, as it could reveal the location of the orangutan and her infant, putting the latter in particular danger. Thus, the delay could be a safety-first maneuver, followed by the need to alert others and, importantly, teach the child about the danger that has just passed. Indeed, it seems that mothers with younger, less experienced offspring were more likely to emit a delayed alarm call than mothers with older offspring.

Orangutan mother and baby reaching for each others hands as they move towards Semenggoh wildlife center to look for food.GETTY

This is capacity for displaced reference has not been observed in other primates such as lemurs, monkeys, and great apes, which are known to raise vocal alarms as soon as an artificial predator is spotted.

As Lamiera and his colleague Josep Call explain in their paper published in Science Advances, these new findings point to a form of high-order cognition in orangutans.

“Postponing behavior in time and space inherently expresses a role of high cognitive processing of the stimulus and general intelligence,” they say.

“Our observations, thus, suggest a scenario for language evolution in hominids.”

In other words, displaced reference may be more than just a hallmark of language, it could be a fundamental component in its evolutionary development.


Azerbaijan Defense Minister informs NATO chief on situation in Azerbaijan-Armenia conditional border -VIDEO

News line

Pakistan restricts foreign travels of ministers, government officials
Pakistan restricts foreign travels of ministers, government officials
20:39 18.03.2024
EU to boost military support fund for Ukraine by EUR 5 bln — Hungarian foreign minister
20:00 18.03.2024
Industrial zones to be created in Azerbaijan’s Zangilan, Jabrayil, and Gubadli
19:16 18.03.2024
Reuters: Only an oil slump can stop Russia
19:00 18.03.2024
Top Hamas operative killed in hospital raid, IDF says
Top Hamas operative killed in hospital raid, IDF says
18:33 18.03.2024
President Ilham Aliyev congratulates people of Azerbaijan on occasion of Novruz holiday - UPDATED
18:00 18.03.2024
Jens Stoltenberg: We fully support Georgia's sovereignty and territorial integrity
Jens Stoltenberg: We fully support Georgia's sovereignty and territorial integrity
17:47 18.03.2024
2 dead, 6 injured in Türkiye factory explosion
2 dead, 6 injured in Türkiye factory explosion
17:28 18.03.2024
Armenia’s anti-Russian policy reaches new level
17:11 18.03.2024
"The Middle Corridor plays a key role for Green Energy" - Expert Ali Pasha
16:45 18.03.2024
Central square of Khankandi named “Victory Square”
16:22 18.03.2024
President: We demonstrated tremendous heroism during the II Karabakh War and the anti-terror operation
16:16 18.03.2024
Nobel Peace Prize Laureate Muhammad Yunus visited IEPF - PHOTOS - VIDEO
16:00 18.03.2024
Historic opportunity emerged to advance the Azerbaijani-Armenian peace agenda - FM Bayramov
15:21 18.03.2024
Bayramov and Stoltenberg discuss normalization process between Azerbaijan and Armenia
15:03 18.03.2024
Azerbaijan Defense Minister informs NATO chief on situation in Azerbaijan-Armenia conditional border -VIDEO
14:58 18.03.2024
Stoltenberg's visit to the Caucasus: "NATO is in panic" - OPİNİON
14:29 18.03.2024
Hikmat Hajiyev holds discussions for upcoming COP29 with Chinese Vice FM
Hikmat Hajiyev holds discussions for upcoming COP29 with Chinese Vice FM
14:00 18.03.2024
Stoltenberg concludes his official visit to Azerbaijan
13:42 18.03.2024
Geomagnetic storm expected on March 20
13:33 18.03.2024
Mbappe celebrates his 250th goal in PSG
Mbappe celebrates his 250th goal in PSG
13:19 18.03.2024
President Ilham Aliyev makes a phone call to Vladimir Putin
13:00 18.03.2024
President Ilham Aliyev lit Novruz bonfire in Khankandi and congratulated Azerbaijani people
12:34 18.03.2024
Foreign students attacked in India over Ramadan prayers
12:30 18.03.2024
Spring comes to Northern Hemisphere
Spring comes to Northern Hemisphere
12:17 18.03.2024
Why does Azerbaijan matter to the European Union? - OPINION
12:00 18.03.2024
Number of human remains found in mass grave in Khojaly reaches 19
11:45 18.03.2024
Hikmat Hajiyev meets Pakistani envoy to China
Hikmat Hajiyev meets Pakistani envoy to China
11:33 18.03.2024
EU Council to discuss Armenian-Azerbaijani normalization
11:23 18.03.2024
Global Terrorism Index: Azerbaijan among countries with highest anti-terror rating worldwide
10:56 18.03.2024
Oil prices keep rising
Oil prices keep rising
10:40 18.03.2024
Stoltenberg: NATO looking forward to further strengthening partnership with Azerbaijan
10:23 18.03.2024
Azerbaijani police found numerous weapons and ammunition in Khankandi
10:10 18.03.2024
President Ilham Aliyev: There is a good chance for settlement of Azerbaijan-Armenia relations
09:57 18.03.2024
Putin warns about possible war between Russia and NATO
09:40 18.03.2024
Hikmat Hajiyev meets with Vice Minister of Ecology and Environment of China
09:23 18.03.2024
Azerbaijan relocates 123 more residents to Fuzuli city
08:53 18.03.2024
President Ilham Aliyev held expanded meeting over dinner with Jens Stoltenberg
23:07 17.03.2024
Putin wins the presidential elections for fifth term, exit poll shows
22:43 17.03.2024
COP29 will be turning point, says NATO Secretary-General
21:54 17.03.2024
Hamısı