From Brexit to Yellow Vests, a common thread of economic hardship

Economists say many issues currently plaguing Europe are rooted in policies that pushed citizens to the financial brink.

Politics 11:38 15.12.2018

Angry. Fractured. Fed up. Europe is storming into winter on a wave of discontent.

Britain slipped further into Brexit chaos this week after Prime Minister Theresa May narrowly survived a leadership challenge by her own party. France is bracing for what could be a fifth weekend of "gilet jaunes" (yellow vests) protests by citizens struggling to make ends meet. And in Hungary, thousands are up in arms over changes to overtime rules critics decry as "slave laws".

The lightning rods of revolt differ from country to country. But the tinder they feed on, economists say, is rooted in policies that have pushed a vast and growing swathe of European citizens to the financial brink.

"This has been building for a while," Thomas Ferguson, professor emeritus at the University of Massachusetts, Boston, told Al Jazeera. "If you squeeze people forever, they revolt."

University of Texas progressive economist James Galbraith, who recently returned from France, also links the current unrest to policies that have created a dual economy of haves and have-nots.

"The status quo in Europe is just not sustainable," Galbraith told Al Jazeera. "What we are seeing is a revolt of people who have been stressed for years and years by a series of austerity policies which have diminished their livelihoods and which have undermine their employment base."

Austerity & Brexit

Anti-globalisation and anti-immigration sentiment are often cited as the driving forces of Britain's decision to leave the European Union. But research suggests that austerity policies likely tipped the scales towards Brexit by activating existing economic grievances born of increased competition from free trade and the free movement of labour. 

University of Warwick economist Thiemo Fetzer set out to quantify how cuts to social welfare programmes designed to help those left behind by globalisation influenced voter attitudes in Britain's 2016 Brexit referendum.

What we are seeing is a revolt of people who have been stressed for years and years by a series of austerity policies which have diminished their livelihoods and which have undermine their employment base.

His research suggests that had it not been for austerity policies passed in 2010, support for leaving the EU could have been up to 9.51 percentage points lower – enough to have swung the vote in favour of remaining.

"Up until 2010, the UK's welfare state evened out growing income differences," Fetzer writes. "This pattern markedly stops from 2010 onwards as austerity started to bite."

Tax policy & the yellow vests

Policies that exacerbate economic dissatisfaction are also evident in the yellow vests protests.

Galbraith said flyers distributed in support of the movement carried demands to restore the balance between France's urban wealthy and its struggling, rural working classes.

"The one's I've seen were a straight-forward defence of a France that used to exist for a large part of this population," he told Al Jazeera. "One that provided high quality public services, that provided an effective transportation system, that provided the quality of schools people wanted to have and things of that nature and that taxed in a much more even and fair way." 

The yellow vests protests started as a backlash against a planned fuel tax hike and widened into a broader revolt against President Emanuel Macron and his pro-business agenda.

Last year, Macron abolished a decades-old wealth tax on households that own assets, including stocks and bonds, worth more than $1.5m, and replaced it with one more narrowly focused on real-estate.

Supporters argued the move would stimulate the French economy by encouraging the well-off to invest in French firms.

But such justifications ring hollow with critics, including the yellow vests who refer to Macron as "president of the rich".

"It's very much a movement of social justice," Celia Belin, visiting fellow at the Brookings Institution told Al Jazeera. "Who should pay for things, who should be taxed and who should contribute to the collective effort."

Macron attempted to assuage the protesters by dropping the fuel tax hike and adopting policies to help the working classes, such as a state-funded supplement to the minimum wage and eliminating taxes on overtime pay.

But the measures have failed to mollify many of the yellow vests.

"They wanted to see a symbolic gesture," said Brookings Belin. "One of them could have been reinstating the wealth tax, which is something he's completely unwilling to do."

A 'de-facto' alignment

Macron's concessions to the yellow vests could blow a sizeable hole in France's budget, putting it on course to breach the EU's strict budget deficit ceiling. 

That has potential ramifications for Italy where the populist, Eurosceptic coalition government has been in a standoff with the EU over a rule-breaking budget designed to offer relief to the country's poor and working classes.

"The Italians are chortling," said Galbraith. "You're seeing a de facto alignment of French policy with Italian policy."

Whether that alignment is temporary depends on many factors. But the European elections in 2019 could prove a decisive moment for an economic status quo which is increasingly under assault.

"The European elections of next year will be really meaningful," said Brookings Institution's Belin. "It will tell us a lot of the direction that the EU will take."

Top Ukrainian Commander's Stepson Leads Pro-Russian Convoy in Sydney - VIDEO

News line

Georgian Parliament adopts bill ‘On Transparency of Foreign Influence’ in third reading
16:05 14.05.2024
Biden raises tariffs on $18B of Chinese imports: EVs, solar panels, batteries and more
Biden raises tariffs on $18B of Chinese imports: EVs, solar panels, batteries and more
15:50 14.05.2024
EU finally approves Ukraine’s reform plan to receive 50B euros in aid
15:40 14.05.2024
Nikol Pashinyan: Armenia is ready to join EU this year
Nikol Pashinyan: Armenia is ready to join EU this year
15:23 14.05.2024
Azerbaijani MP: Preparations for COP29 are in full swing, whole team is mobilized -INTERVIEW
14:45 14.05.2024
Azerbaijani FM says peace treaty must contain no open issues
14:13 14.05.2024
COP29 Expectations and Azerbaijan's Green Energy: Insights from Hungarian Professor Vasa László - VIDEO
13:51 14.05.2024
Borg: Peace process between Baku and Yerevan priority for OSCE
13:36 14.05.2024
Azerbaijani FM: Lot of work has been done with Armenia in last 6 months on normalization
13:14 14.05.2024
COP29 president meets with OECD secretary-general
12:45 14.05.2024
Nikolai Patrushev appointed assistant to President of Russia
Nikolai Patrushev appointed assistant to President of Russia
12:09 14.05.2024
Tête-à-tête meeting between Azerbaijani FM and OSCE Chairman-in-Office kicks off
11:45 14.05.2024
Ilham Aliyev receives Vice-Chairperson of National Committee of Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference
11:38 14.05.2024
Russian president Putin to visit China
11:30 14.05.2024
Yerevan police detain 38 opposition activists
11:18 14.05.2024
10th congress of the Azerbaijan National NGO Forum kicks off
11:03 14.05.2024
President Ilham Aliyev receives delegation led by OSCE Chair-in-Office
10:41 14.05.2024
Hermès Heir Leave Half of $12 Billion Fortune to Former Gardener
Hermès Heir Leave Half of $12 Billion Fortune to Former Gardener
10:25 14.05.2024
COP29 president meets with chair of Pakistani Prime Minister's Youth Program
10:15 14.05.2024
Azerbaijan relocates next group of residents to Shusha
10:02 14.05.2024
Volume of exported gas reached 8.5 bcm, says Azerbaijan's Energy Minister
Volume of exported gas reached 8.5 bcm, says Azerbaijan's Energy Minister
09:50 14.05.2024
US Army officer resigns over Washington's support for Israel
09:38 14.05.2024
Belgium hails new round of Azerbaijan-Armenia negotiations
09:22 14.05.2024
Blinken arrives in Ukraine in show of US solidarity amid Russian attacks
09:00 14.05.2024
Sunak: 'World closer to nuclear escalation than at any point since Cuban missile crisis'
22:00 13.05.2024
Kazakh former economy minister sentenced to 24 years in prison
18:40 13.05.2024
British embassy in Tbilisi suspends issuance of visas due to protests
18:20 13.05.2024
Pashinyan's peace promise until November: Truth or illusion? - Experts talk on Ednews
18:00 13.05.2024
SCO foreign ministers to meet in Astana next week
18:00 13.05.2024
Amazon to invest $1.3B in France, create 3,000 jobs
17:40 13.05.2024
50 families to be relocated to Khojaly in coming days, official says
17:28 13.05.2024
Cuban diplomat visits Seoul for talks on opening embassy
Cuban diplomat visits Seoul for talks on opening embassy
17:20 13.05.2024
New appointment at Central Bank of Azerbaijan
17:00 13.05.2024
World’s biggest banks ‘financed fossil fuels by $6.9 trillion since Paris Agreement’
16:40 13.05.2024
Dedicated sessions for small island states to be held within COP29 framework
16:20 13.05.2024
U.S. Embassy Holds Alumni Summit in Shabran
U.S. Embassy Holds Alumni Summit in Shabran
16:00 13.05.2024
President Ilham Aliyev received Secretary-General of the Commonwealth
15:43 13.05.2024
Armenia's Political Dilemma: Analyst Suggests Peace Treaty with Azerbaijan as Pivotal Step
14:40 13.05.2024
What can a temperature rise of 3 degrees do to Earth?
What can a temperature rise of 3 degrees do to Earth?
14:15 13.05.2024
ANAMA reveals number of landmines found in liberated territories last week
13:50 13.05.2024
Hamısı