Most of Earth's carbon came from the interstellar medium

Science & Tech 20:30 03.04.2021

We really are made of stardust. New research suggests the majority of Earth's carbon came from the interstellar medium, the diffuse supply of gas and dust found between a galaxy's stars.

According to a new study, published Friday in the journal Science Advances, carbon from the interstellar medium became incorporated into the solar system's protoplanetary disk just a million years after the sun was born.

Previously, scientists hypothesized most of Earth's organic molecules were sourced from nebular gas. As gas from the stellar nebula cooled, researchers surmised, carbon and other molecules precipitated out of the cloud and became incorporated into rocky planets.

The problem with this theory is that once carbon vaporizes, it's unable to condense back into a solid.

"The condensation model has been widely used for decades," lead study author Jie Li, planetary scientist at the University of Michigan, said in a news release.

"It assumes that during the formation of the sun, all of the planet's elements got vaporized, and as the disk cooled, some of these gases condensed and supplied chemical ingredients to solid bodies. But that doesn't work for carbon," said Li.

Most of the carbon pulled from the interstellar medium came in the form of organic molecules. However, vaporized carbon yields more volatile varieties, which can only condense back into solids at very low temperatures.

To avoid this pitfall, scientists considered the possibility that Earth's carbon was never vaporized at all -- that it was acquired directly from the interstellar medium.

Researchers began by using seismic waves to study the contents of Earth's core and gather data they helped them estimate the maximum amount of carbon the planet might contain.

"We asked a different question: We asked how much carbon could you stuff in the Earth's core and still be consistent with all the constraints," said co-author Edwin Bergin, professor of astronomy at Michigan.

"There's uncertainty here. Let's embrace the uncertainty to ask what are the true upper bounds for how much carbon is very deep in the Earth, and that will tell us the true landscape we're within," Bergin said.

To support life, a planet must have just the right amount of carbon. If a newborn planet acquires too much carbon, it's likely to overheat, yielding a hothouse planet like Venus. If an infant planet doesn't get enough carbon, it's likely to host more Mars-like conditions, frigid and dry.

In a related study, published earlier this year in the journal PNAS, scientists analyzed iron meteorites to better understand how much carbon might have survived the planet formation process.

Their findings showed early planetesimals likely lost most of their carbon as a planet's building blocks melted, formed cores and expelled gas.

"Most models have the carbon and other life-essential materials such as water and nitrogen going from the nebula into primitive rocky bodies, and these are then delivered to growing planets such as Earth or Mars," said co-author Marc Hirschmann.

"But this skips a key step, in which the planetesimals lose much of their carbon before they accrete to the planets," said Hirschmann, a professor of earth and environmental sciences at the University of Minnesota.

Together, the Science Advances and PNAS papers suggest both carbon acquisition and carbon loss play important roles in setting the stage for life on rocky planets.

"Answering whether or not Earth-like planets exist elsewhere can only be achieved by working at the intersection of disciplines like astronomy and geochemistry," said co-author Fred Ciesla, professor of geophysical sciences at the University of Chicago.

"While approaches and the specific questions that researchers work to answer differ across the fields, building a coherent story requires identifying topics of mutual interest and finding ways to bridge the intellectual gaps between them. Doing so is challenging, but the effort is both stimulating and rewarding," Ciesla said.

Azerbaijan’s amphibious aircraft joins firefighting efforts in Türkiye - VIDEO

News line

IEPF Issues Statement on Escalating Tensions in the Middle East - Picture
17:13 02.10.2024
President Vladimir Putin makes phone call to President Ilham Aliyev
15:00 28.08.2024
Israeli military launches major West Bank operation
14:00 28.08.2024
Africa reports almost 4,000 new mpox cases in one week
Africa reports almost 4,000 new mpox cases in one week
13:00 28.08.2024
Macron allegedly offered Durov to move Telegram HQ to Paris
12:35 28.08.2024
South Korea vows tougher stance after outcry over sexual deepfakes in Telegram chatrooms
South Korea vows tougher stance after outcry over sexual deepfakes in Telegram chatrooms
12:05 28.08.2024
Today marks anniversary of Balligaya massacre committed by Armenians
11:46 28.08.2024
Opening ceremony of Paris 2024 Paralympics to be held today
Opening ceremony of Paris 2024 Paralympics to be held today
11:00 28.08.2024
COP29 Organizing Committee assesses preparedness at Baku Olympic Stadium
10:35 28.08.2024
FM: Azerbaijan-Türkiye relations milestone of regional security
10:20 28.08.2024
Azerbaijan Army positions in Nakhchivan direction were subjected to fire
10:00 28.08.2024
Azerbaijani FM: Arms supplies to Armenia - source of threat to region
21:00 27.08.2024
Cristiano Ronaldo to be honored as UEFA Champions League All-Time Top Scorer
Cristiano Ronaldo to be honored as UEFA Champions League All-Time Top Scorer
18:00 27.08.2024
Azerbaijan, Commonwealth sign declaration on climate change
17:00 27.08.2024
Baku to host 2nd Gulf - Azerbaijan Economic Forum in September
Baku to host 2nd Gulf - Azerbaijan Economic Forum in September
17:00 27.08.2024
Ambassador: Parliament of Netherlands adopted 26 anti-Azerbaijani motions during past four years
15:57 27.08.2024
Azerbaijan weather forecast for August 28
Azerbaijan weather forecast for August 28
14:00 27.08.2024
Iranian and Turkish ambassadors in Baghdad discuss regional issues
13:30 27.08.2024
Ilham Aliyev congratulates President of Moldova
Ilham Aliyev congratulates President of Moldova
12:55 27.08.2024
Azerbaijan's MFA condemns terrorist attack in Pakistan
12:30 27.08.2024
Chaos in France after Macron refuses to name prime minister from leftwing coalition
12:05 27.08.2024
Russia launches fresh wave of deadly strikes on Ukraine
11:45 27.08.2024
Mukhtar Babayev meets with deputy PM of New Zealand
11:20 27.08.2024
Azerbaijan's First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva visits Bibiheybet Shrine Complex
10:57 27.08.2024
Biden: US supplies equipment for energy grid repair to Ukraine
10:40 27.08.2024
BIG submits report on France's colonial policy to UN Human Rights Committee
10:25 27.08.2024
First Vice-President Mehriban Aliyeva attends celebration organized for children by Heydar Aliyev Foundation
09:56 27.08.2024
Al Hilal reaches agreement with Man City for Cancelo
Al Hilal reaches agreement with Man City for Cancelo
09:00 27.08.2024
Peskov denies Putin-Durov encounter during Baku visit
19:00 26.08.2024
Russian intelligence claims that US plans ‘Color Revolution’ in Georgia
18:00 26.08.2024
COP29 president designate meets with UN secretary general
17:00 26.08.2024
Pakistan, Azerbaijan mull prospects for bilateral economic, trade ties
16:35 26.08.2024
FM Bayramov, Fidan to mull Azerbaijan-Armenia peace process in Ankara
16:00 26.08.2024
European Commission declines to comment on Durov's detention
15:30 26.08.2024
Telegram founder may be held in custody in France for 4 days without charges
Telegram founder may be held in custody in France for 4 days without charges
15:00 26.08.2024
Media: Bashar al-Assad refuses dialogue with Türkiye
13:00 26.08.2024
ICRC representatives visit detained Armenian separatist 'leaders' in Azerbaijan
12:58 26.08.2024
Khojaly resident: 'Voting in native land after 32 years fills me with pride'
12:36 26.08.2024
North Korea's Kim Jong Un oversees tests of 'suicide drones'
12:16 26.08.2024
President of Belarus congratulates Azerbaijan's First Vice President Mehriban Aliyeva
11:30 26.08.2024
Hamısı