Myanmar using 'oppressive laws' against peaceful critics HRW

Rights group says freedom of expression deteriorating since Aung San Suu Kyi's government took office in 2016.

World 15:55 01.02.2019

The Myanmar government under Aung San Suu Kyi has continued using oppressive, military rule-era laws to prosecute peaceful critics, quashing hopes the country's first democratic leader in decades would safeguard free speech, according to a damning new report by a prominent rights group.

Freedom of expression has been worsening since the Nobel peace laureate's administration took office in 2016, with prosecutions creating a "climate of fear" among journalists, Human Rights Watch (HRW) said on Friday.

"Aung San Suu Kyi and the National League for Democracy promised a new Myanmar but the government still prosecutes peaceful speech and protests and has failed to revise old oppressive laws," Linda Lakhdhir, Asia legal adviser at HRW and the report's author, said in a statement.

There was no immediate comment from the Myanmar government.

'Tools of oppression'

Under nearly 50 years of notorious military rule, the country's government had placed severe restrictions on freedom of expression.

Reforms undertaken by the quasi-civilian administration that came to power in 2010, including the abolition of censorship, had "positive implications for speech and assembly", HRW said in its report, titled Dashed Hopes: The Criminalisation of Peaceful Expression in Myanmar.

However, the government led by de facto civilian leader Aung San Suu Kyi had made "only marginal changes" to oppressive legislation and continued to use "overly broad, vague, and abusive laws" to prosecute peaceful speech and assembly, it said.

"Aung San Suu Kyi's government has had a real opportunity to abolish the tools of oppression used by the military juntas, but has instead used them against peaceful critics and protesters," Lakhdhir said, urging the government to reverse course and take steps to protect freedom of speech and assembly. 

Speaking to Al Jazeera from Yangon in southern Myanmar, Lakhdhir focused on the plight of journalists in Myanmar, specifically when they cover issues considered sensitive by the government.

"There are certain topics that seems to be off limits such as criticising the military, talking about military abuses, criticising the government or government officials and talking bout corruption," said Lakhdhir.

"If you report on ethnic armed groups or travel to conflict areas to report then you risk getting arrested."

'Climate of fear'

Myanmar free speech group Athan, whose report was quoted by HRW, said some 140 cases had been filed since 2016 under the Telecommunications Act, at least half of which involved prosecution for peaceful speech.

Parliament made some amendments to section 66(d) of the act, which punishes anyone who "defames" someone using a telecommunications network with up to two years in prison, but rejected calls to repeal the provision.

Reporters were especially vulnerable to prosecution and attacks, HRW said, with threats coming from authorities as well as nationalists and "militant" supporters of the government or army.

"The result has been a climate of fear among local journalists," the HRW report said.

Laws criminalising defamation, the Official Secrets Act, the Unlawful Associations Act, the 1934 Aircraft Act, and section 131 of the Myanmar Penal Code have all been used against journalists in recent years.

Reuters news agency reporters Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo were sentenced to seven years in prison in September 2018 under the colonial-era Official Secrets Act. They had been working on an investigation into the massacre of 10 Rohingya Muslim men and boys in Rakhine state.

The duo's sentence provoked international outcry over media freedom in Myanmar with calls echoing across the world for their immediate release.

On Friday, weeks after Yangon's High Court rejected an appeal by the journalists, their lawyers filed an appeal with the country's highest court to overturn the convictions - the last chance of a reprieve through the legal system.

Under Myanmar law, Supreme Court judges hear appeals individually, giving lawyers for the journalists several options.

The process is expected to take several months. The only other chance of early release comes from a presidential pardon.

Rights groups have heaped pressure on Aung San Suu Kyi to use her leverage to secure a pardon.

But she has refused to intervene in the case in favor of the reporters, describing it as an issue for the courts.

Police officer released

Wa Lone and Kyaw Soe Oo insist they were victims of a police set-up, and testimony during the trial from a whistleblowing officer appeared to validate their claim.

Moe Yan Naing was initially called as a prosecution witness but stunned the court by saying superiors had ordered police to entrap the reporters. His breaking of the ranks was extremely rare from a serving member of Myanmar's secretive security apparatus and he was jailed for a year after giving testimony.

On Friday, the ex-police officer walked free after serving his sentence at Yangon's Insein prison - where the Reuters reporters are also doing their time.

"I've never broken any police regulations in my life, but the police regulations are not perfect," he told reporters as he left the jail.

"Members of the police force are suffering under these," he said, calling for reform "as part of the transition to democracy".

Uzbek Representative IEPF Shukhrat Barlas Receives "100th Anniversary of Heydar Aliyev" Jubilee Medal - PHOTOS/VIDEO

News line

President, First Lady participate in opening of Kharibulbul Music Festival in Shusha
16:51 11.05.2024
Head of UN NGO Branch to Visit Azerbaijan - PHOTOS
14:00 11.05.2024
Mbappé announces PSG exit ahead of likely Real Madrid move
13:23 11.05.2024
Former Armenian MP detained in Russia
Former Armenian MP detained in Russia
12:59 11.05.2024
Actions of disobedience resume in Yerevan and several Armenian regions
12:38 11.05.2024
Price of Azerbaijan oil drops
Price of Azerbaijan oil drops
12:19 11.05.2024
Azerbaijani and Armenian FMs to continue negotiations in Almaty today
11:55 11.05.2024
President Ilham Aliyev receives ICESCO Director General in Shusha
11:42 11.05.2024
Uzbek Representative IEPF Shukhrat Barlas Receives "100th Anniversary of Heydar Aliyev" Jubilee Medal - PHOTOS/VIDEO
11:25 11.05.2024
President: We never wanted war, and we don't want it today either
10:50 11.05.2024
Kharibulbul International Music Festival to kick off in Shusha today
10:35 11.05.2024
President of COP29 visits COMSATS headquarters in Pakistan
10:13 11.05.2024
School bus accident in Antalya, Türkiye: 25 injured as student transport plunges into ravine
09:58 11.05.2024
United Nations General Assembly backs Palestinian bid for membership
09:00 11.05.2024
President Ilham Aliyev congratulates Shusha residents on their returning to native land
President Ilham Aliyev congratulates Shusha residents on their returning to native land
23:00 10.05.2024
President: A new history of Shusha begins today
22:33 10.05.2024
Azerbaijani President: The war could not have ended successfully without Shusha
21:45 10.05.2024
Is a Peace Agreement Between Azerbaijan and Armenia Possible by November?
21:00 10.05.2024
Spain, Ireland intend to recognize Palestine, Borrell says
20:00 10.05.2024
Brazilian flood death toll reaches 107
Brazilian flood death toll reaches 107
19:40 10.05.2024
Napoli star Kvaratskhelia ‘top priority’ for PSG to replace Mbappe
Napoli star Kvaratskhelia ‘top priority’ for PSG to replace Mbappe
19:20 10.05.2024
Participation of Swiss companies in restoration work in Karabakh and Eastern Zangazur discussed
19:00 10.05.2024
Green technology online platform to be established in Azerbaijan
18:40 10.05.2024
Alparslan Bayraktar: Türkiye aims to deepen energy cooperation with US
18:20 10.05.2024
Bilateral Meeting Commences: Azerbaijani and Armenian Foreign Ministers Discuss Peace Agreement in Almaty
17:45 10.05.2024
COP29 president mulls consequences of climate change in Pakistan
17:22 10.05.2024
Azerbaijan Army holds Military Oath-taking ceremonies - VİDEO
Azerbaijan Army holds Military Oath-taking ceremonies - VİDEO
17:05 10.05.2024
Ilham Aliyev views works done on Khankandi-Shusha-Lachin highway
Ilham Aliyev views works done on Khankandi-Shusha-Lachin highway
17:03 10.05.2024
President Ilham Aliyev lays foundation of Turshsu settlement of Shusha district
16:57 10.05.2024
President, First Lady attend opening of first residential complex in Shusha
16:38 10.05.2024
Armenian FM Mirzoyan: Yerevan aimed at signing peace treaty
16:05 10.05.2024
Scotland's first minister says independence from UK 'can be achieved in five years'
Scotland's first minister says independence from UK 'can be achieved in five years'
15:48 10.05.2024
Russian Analyst Offers Insights on Armenian Border Guard Situation and Foreign Policy Dynamics
15:30 10.05.2024
Azerbaijani FM Bayramov hopes two days of work in Almaty will be positive
15:24 10.05.2024
President, First Lady view reconstruction work at Chol Gala Mosque in Shusha
15:15 10.05.2024
Iranian Government Attempting to Persianize Nizami Ganjavi
15:02 10.05.2024
Iran Unveils Discovery of New Oil and Gas Reserves
Iran Unveils Discovery of New Oil and Gas Reserves
14:45 10.05.2024
Umud Mirzayev: "Heydar Aliyev is an eternal leader"
14:33 10.05.2024
Meeting of Azerbaijani, Armenian foreign ministers kicks off in Almaty
14:22 10.05.2024
Azerbaijani CEC Chairman says parliamentary elections may be pushed forward for COP29
14:10 10.05.2024
Hamısı