Al Bab: 'When the tide is turning, ISIL go apocalyptic'

Conflicts 17:53 16.02.2017

Ankara's plans to push further east and south of Al Bab might face serious diplomatic challenges, say analysts.

In recent weeks, the Turkish-led Operation Euphrates Shield has made significant progress against ISIL around the city of Al Bab in northern Syria. Russia, a key ally during the operation, has provided Turkey with military and diplomatic support.

The takeover of Al Bab would effectively prevent Kurdish forces from establishing a land corridor between the two territories they control in northern Syria - one of the main goals of Turkey's military operation.

It would also provide Turkey with an important strategic advantage in possible operations against the ISIL, the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant, which is also known as ISIS, and Kurdish forces. But analysts say that Ankara's plans to push further east and south might face serious diplomatic challenges.

On Sunday during a press conference, President Recep Tayyip Erdogan announced that Turkish troops had entered Al Bab's city centre and that it was only "a matter of time" before they took it over completely.

According to Can Kasapoglu, a defence analyst at the Centre for Economics and Foreign Policy Studies in Istanbul, Euphrates Shield forces have already broken the first line of ISIL's defence. However, it will take a few weeks for them to take full control of Al Bab, he says.

I think it's fair to assume that Turkish reluctance to get further involved in the Aleppo fight was linked to its understanding with Russia regarding Euphrates Shield.

Noah Bonsey, Senior researcher, International Crisis Group

"As the Turkish operations go deeper into [fighting] street-by-street, […] there will be more intensified, nastier defence by the ISIS elements," said Kasapoglu. "We always see this. We saw this in Iraq, we saw this in Ramadi. When ISIS feel that the tide is turning against them they go apocalyptic, but it cannot stop the operation."

Turkey launched Operation Euphrates Shield in August 2016 with a coalition of Syrian Arab and Turkmen forces, backed by a few hundred Turkish troops. As fighting progressed, Ankara had to send reinforcements and currently, according to Kasapoglu, Turkish troops on the ground in northern Syria are in the thousands.

The Operation Euphrates Shield forces started their advance on Al Bab in November 2016. In early February, ISIL was completely encircled after armed forces fighting for Bashar al-Assad's regime cut off its last remaining supply route connecting it to the rest of its territories south and east of Al Bab.

This positioned regime forces in close proximity to FSA factions, and according to Kasapoglu, that resulted in minor clashes.

Osama al-Koshak, an independent Syrian researcher and activist, says there is very little risk of more serious clashes happening between FSA affiliates and regime forces in Al Bab. He added that there has been agreement between Turkey and Russia on Syrian regime forces halting their progress at the village of Tadif, just 2km southeast of Al Bab.

In mid-January Russia and Turkey launched their first joint air operations, hitting ISIL positions in Al Bab. The military cooperation between the two countries suffered a temporary setback, when Russian air strikes killed three Turkish soldiers.

Despite these issues, Koshak says Russian-Turkish cooperation in northern Syria has been growing and will continue to grow, as Turkey's western allies take a step back.

"This pushed Turkey to consider Russia a more suitable coalition partner in the pursuit of its interests. Russia offered air support against ISIL in Northern Syria, as the US retreated," explains Koshak.

According to Noah Bonsey, International Crisis Group's senior analyst on Syria, Russia's support of Turkey's operation in northern Syria is part of its strategy to "cash in" politically on the significant military progress it has made and also prevent overstretching of its military capabilities by seeking to de-escalate the conflict in certain places.

Aleppo could also have been part of a deal between Turkey and Russia on Al Bab.

"There are steps that Turkey could have taken to improve the rebel defences of Aleppo that it did not take," says Bonsey. "I think it's fair to assume that Turkish reluctance to get further involved in the Aleppo fight was linked to its understanding with Russia regarding Euphrates Shield."

 During Monday's press conference, Erdogan announced that the next goals for Operation Euphrates Shield are Manbij and Raqqa. The Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), led by Kurdish People's Protection Units (YPG), took over Manbij from ISIL in August 2016 with heavy air support by the US.

As an affiliate of the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK), the YPG is considered a terrorist organisation in Turkey. In the past, the Turkish air force has hit YPG positions in Manbij, but a full military offensive on the city against one of the US' key anti-ISIL allies would put Turkey in a complex diplomatic situation.

According to Kasapoglu, Turkey would not launch such an operation unless there are "favourable diplomatic conditions" to do so. After putting troops on the ground and waging a successful campaign against ISIL, Ankara's diplomatic leverage within the western anti-ISIL coalition has grown, he notes.

In his opinion, the Turkish military might also focus on an offensive on Raqqa, which would be a much larger operation than the one in al-Bab.

But Raqqa is also a major target for the US that has been supporting SDF forces advancing on the city.

According to Bonsey there are currently discussions in Washington on how to best approach taking over Raqqa.

"Most American officials that I have spoken to and I think the general opinion in Washington is that the YPG and its allies are best equipped to take the city in the short run," he says. "There are some in Washington who would rather take a more gradual approach and work with Turkey and Turkish backed-forces to take the city."

Bonsey says that the US in the end is more likely to work with the YPG, but it is still under question. If Turkey proceeds with its operation against the Kurdish forces in Manbij or ISIL in Raqqa, it risks overstretching, he says.

"As Turkish forces and their allies expand their areas of control, those areas may become more difficult to [control]. Maintaining security in these areas may become more difficult," he explains.

Bonsey points out that if Turkey launches an offensive on Manbij and the Kurds, that could give ISIL an advantage and allow it to attack both the Kurdish and Turkish forces while they are engaged in fighting each other.

Slovakia’s prime minister injured in shooting - VIDEO

News line

Solar storm reaches depths of Earth's oceans
Solar storm reaches depths of Earth's oceans
09:17 17.05.2024
US under secretary of state discusses shared priorities and COP29 with Hikmat Hajiyev
09:02 17.05.2024
ECB warns Europe of negative risks due to high public debt
21:27 16.05.2024
France to send another 1,000 gendarmes to New Caledonia
21:00 16.05.2024
Netanyahu Says Israel Can 'Win' Fight Against Hamas in Gaza Without US Help
20:26 16.05.2024
Kazakhstan and Latvia agree on developing Middle Corridor
20:00 16.05.2024
2 Hezbollah fighters killed in Israeli drone strike in southern Lebanon
19:30 16.05.2024
Climate activists dye luxury stores in Rome
19:00 16.05.2024
France to send another 1,000 gendarmes to New Caledonia
France to send another 1,000 gendarmes to New Caledonia
18:55 16.05.2024
Assessing Regional Protests: Expert Weighs Impact on Azerbaijan
18:30 16.05.2024
Incomes of Azerbaijani population rise by over 4%
18:00 16.05.2024
Azerbaijan uses colors in weather warning for first time
17:30 16.05.2024
Iran’s flood crisis: Rising waters claim lives
17:00 16.05.2024
Azerbaijani, Armenian parliament speakers have short conversation ahead of their main meeting
16:30 16.05.2024
Presidents of Azerbaijan and Belarus familiarize themselves with Caspian Agro and InterFood Azerbaijan exhibitions
16:00 16.05.2024
NGO chief: Armenia must obtain Azerbaijan's permission for cross-border mining activities
15:30 16.05.2024
Zelensky in Kharkiv: Situation 'difficult' but 'under control,' Russia suffers losses
15:00 16.05.2024
Azerbaijan and Belarus sign documents
14:41 16.05.2024
Insights from IEPF President Umud Mirzayev: Impact of Neighboring Processes on Azerbaijan
14:30 16.05.2024
Slovakia 'on the edge of civil war' from political tension, interior minister says
14:09 16.05.2024
Lukashenko: No closed topics in Belarus-Azerbaijan relations
13:56 16.05.2024
ADA University Hosts "Climate and Water Summit Towards COP29"
13:18 16.05.2024
Azerbaijan's Foreign Ministry retorts to French Minister of Interior
13:00 16.05.2024
Man arrested for threatening Serbian President Vucic
Man arrested for threatening Serbian President Vucic
12:48 16.05.2024
Kanako Mabuchi: UN fully committed to supporting COP29 Presidency
12:37 16.05.2024
MP Konul Nurullayeva: COP29 will rally nations worldwide to combat climate change
12:25 16.05.2024
Pashinyan calls signing of Armenia-Azerbaijan delimitation protocol great success
Pashinyan calls signing of Armenia-Azerbaijan delimitation protocol great success
11:55 16.05.2024
Armenia to open embassy in Cyprus
Armenia to open embassy in Cyprus
11:45 16.05.2024
One-on-one meeting between Azerbaijani and Belarusian Presidents starts
11:32 16.05.2024
Official welcome ceremony held for President of Belarus Aleksandr Lukashenko
11:22 16.05.2024
Moscow hosts concert program entitled "Azerbaijan and Russia: manifestation of friendship"
Moscow hosts concert program entitled "Azerbaijan and Russia: manifestation of friendship"
11:21 16.05.2024
Baku court was appealed over extension of Ruben Vardanyan's prison term
11:15 16.05.2024
Azerbaijan, Belarus expanding co-op in urban planning and architecture
11:15 16.05.2024
EDB allocates $1M to eliminate consequences of floods in Kazakhstan
EDB allocates $1M to eliminate consequences of floods in Kazakhstan
10:50 16.05.2024
Slovak PM Fico still in life-threatening condition
10:35 16.05.2024
Speaker of Milli Majlis Sahiba Gafarova arrives in Swiss Confederation on a Working visit
Speaker of Milli Majlis Sahiba Gafarova arrives in Swiss Confederation on a Working visit
10:30 16.05.2024
Oil price sees increase in world markets
Oil price sees increase in world markets
10:25 16.05.2024
New pillars to be installed on Azerbaijan-Armenia border
New pillars to be installed on Azerbaijan-Armenia border
10:16 16.05.2024
Jury selected in New York on case of pro-Armenian Senator Menendez
10:05 16.05.2024
Azerbaijan, Bulgaria discuss bilateral relations
09:55 16.05.2024
Hamısı