The Babchenko Case, Post-Truth World and New American ‘Imperialism’ ANALYSIS - EXCLUSIVE

Interviews 11:42 04.06.2018
On May 29, Ukraine staged the murder of a Russian journalist, Arkady Babchenko, in Kiev which caused new tension between the West and Russia, as it raised a lot of questions. First question was who is going to take advantage of this "fake news"? How will be the reputation of both Ukrainian government and media after this issue in the country? How much was it harmful for trustworthiness of the local media and for journalist himself? 
 
Political analyst Bruno Surdel commented on Eurasia Diary’s question on this issue. 
 
Bruno Surdel: On May 30, I realized we live in a ‘post-truth’ age. It happened when I watched on my TV screen the scene with Arkady Babchenko who had been ‘raised from the dead’ and showed up alive at a news conference in Kiev. The ‘heroes’ who granted him a ‘new life’ were the head of Ukraine's SBU security service, Vasyl Hrytsak and the prosecutor general – Lutsenko. The next my thought was, however, that we also reached an era of post-journalism. I agree with Reporters Without Borders:  Babchenko’s ‘murder’  was just ‘part of an information war’ between Ukraine and Russia. 
 
Information war is nothing new, for sure, and both sides are quite good at it. What is fascinating, the former Russian and now Ukrainian journalist who played the main part in the ‘sting operation’ has had an interesting record as a soldier and ‘mercenary’ in Chechen wars, then war correspondent and investigative journalist. Now he says, he may dance on Putin’s grave in the future… He seems to think he has become a ‘hero’. Is this journalism at its best? I doubt it. 
 
The hoax he took part in, was not necessarily designed to (‘just’) save his life: it has very many layers, including what the Kremlin has called as ‘propaganda’. The question is: was Babchenko used or abused as a kind of useful ‘tool’ or anti-Russian weapon by the Ukrainian security service? If they (Ukrainians) staged the death of that Russian dissident journalist to achieve some PR goals, I’m not sure they got what they really wanted. Some may say: the Russians were right when they had warned beforehand it could be a ‘provocation’.
 
But Ukrainian officials: Hrytsak and Lutsenko claim faking the killing of Babchenko helped them to foil a Russian plot to assassinate not only him but also other – 30 or so - Russian and Ukrainian politicians and journalists as well. We learned that one of them reportedly was the famous "Echo of Moscow” journalist - Matvey Ganapolsky… The Ukrainian prosecutor general announced also that they got a ‘list’ of potential victims, as many as 47… So more than 30.
 
Furthermore, the businessman allegedly responsible for ‘plotting the killings’ had also been trying to arrange ‘arsenals’ of weapons to do his ‘job’. That’s a kind of political thriller and something very serious, indeed. OK, but should we trust those revelations are ‘real’ and not just another stunt and weapon in external and internal Ukrainian conflicts? Unfortunately, I’m not sure, especially, when I hear that the ‘would be’ murderer has been collaborating with Ukrainian security service since the very beginning and that the abovementioned businessman received his ‘license to kill’ from a ‘private Putin fund’ and that also he ‘was in touch’ (as Borys Herman claims) with the Ukrainian counterintelligence. That’s too much…
 
Who is going to take advantage of all this? Yes, this is Moscow. Out of the sudden, for many people – especially abroad - Russian president Vladimir Putin has become a kind of ‘victim’ of a Ukrainian ‘plot’. The situation is grotesque and tragic in the very same time. And it may support the Kremlin’s narrative of the conflict in the eastern Ukraine – however absurd it might be. 
 
This time, the Ukrainian government probably went too far in its efforts to ‘outsmart’ the Russians. For sure, many Ukrainians are proud of their SBU secret service and what they had ‘achieved’. No doubt about it as this was likely one of the stunt’s goals. But people abroad, in particular those who do know much about the Russia – Ukraine conflict and its background – they may be rather skeptical and wary in their reading of the Ukrainian government’s intentions.
 
However, when it comes to Ukraine’s media and their narrative of the staged killing, one cannot forget that this was Ukrainian authorities who had confirmed Babchenko’s ‘death’. So I’m not that ready to blame them. After all, there is still a bloody, cruel war in the east of Ukraine. It’s hard to paint the full picture without that very truth. 
 
Eurasia Diary: International Federation of Journalists described this case as "intolerable" and "inadmissible", while the Western media blamed Russia, and Russia called the staged assassination "anti-Russian provocation", as Skripal case still remains uncertain. The arrest of Bill Browder in Spain was also another reason for the west to keep accusing Russia. Last two cases caused tension between Russia and the West. How much Babchenko case will affect the "Cold War" between Russia and Europe?
 
Bruno Surdel: As I mentioned before, we live in strange and dangerous times. The US president Trump withdrew from the JCPOA – so-called Iran Nuclear deal and moved the American Embassy to Jerusalem.
 
On the other hand, he decided to threat with a global trade war both the West with his close allies and the East with the next superpower ‘in waiting’ – China. This is not the kind of ‘Cold War’ we got accustomed to in the 20th century.
 
This is an ‘imperial’ and ‘unipolar’ way of thinking and dealing with issues and countries perceived as a kind of ‘problem’ for the United States. This is ‘old-fashioned’ school of making foreign policy in our globalized world. But yes - it may work to some extent.
 
However, the side-effect - I’m sure the American administration doesn’t want - may be some tactical rapprochement between Europe, Russia and China against all odds – including the Skripal case. That’s nothing stable, but anyway it may happen.
 
On the other hand, however, we do not know what intelligence the Western countries have received relating to the Babchenko case. We do know nothing sure or certain, just conflicting narratives of interested ‘parties’. Nothing more, unfortunately. Most likely, however, the Babchenko case has good chances to strengthen ‘alert’ lights in Western capitals. I mean alleged Kremlin ‘threat’ and ‘meddling’.
 
Interviewed by Farid Hasanov
Bruno Surdel is a member of the Centre for International Relations in Warsaw.  Graduated from the University of Warsaw. 2011 - 2016 he was a lecturer at the Zirve University in Gaziantep - Turkey. Several times visiting professor at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences in Beijing - National Institute of International Strategy; in Shanghai: Shanghai International Studies University, and Renmin University (Beijing). He attended many international conferences on Asia and the Middle East. He has conducted research on international security in Turkey - Middle East - China, with particular focus on Syria and Iraq (political Islam, terrorism). His research interests involve also the New Silk Road initiative (OBOR). Twitter: @BrunoSurdel

 

IEPF issued a statement regarding Azerbaijani children at the UN Human Rights Council

News line

WB allocates $2M for preparation of sustainable development project in Baku
22:00 02.07.2025
Malaysia inviting Azerbaijan to participate in trade incentive program
21:45 02.07.2025
Malaysia expects further expansion of palm oil trade with Azerbaijan
21:30 02.07.2025
EBRD updates current portfolio of projects in Azerbaijan
21:30 02.07.2025
12 Georgian MPs lose parliamentary mandates
21:00 02.07.2025
Asan Jakishev: Kazakhstan strengthens status as key transit hub in region
20:40 02.07.2025
Zakharova: 'We call on Baku to take measures to return ties to level of strategic alliance'
20:30 02.07.2025
Kyrgyz ambassador to Azerbaijan also appointed as envoy to Georgia
20:20 02.07.2025
Bangladesh court sentences ex-Premier Hasina in contempt case; first conviction since ouster
20:00 02.07.2025
Russia says reduction or cessation of Western arms supplies to Ukraine brings conflict closer to its end
19:45 02.07.2025
Israeli prosecution cancels Netanyahu’s corruption trial sessions next week over US visit
19:30 02.07.2025
Mamasadyk Bakirov: Kyrgyzstan creates all necessary conditions for business
19:15 02.07.2025
Lachin holds panel session on Role of Women in Urban Development
19:00 02.07.2025
Central banks of Azerbaijan, Georgia mull implementation of systems supported by AI
18:45 02.07.2025
Azerbaijani military personnel participate in International Anatolian Eagle-2025
18:30 02.07.2025
Shavkat Mirziyoyev to open Uzbekistan park in Baku
18:15 02.07.2025
Peskov: Head of Russia's Investigative Committee, Azerbaijan's prosecutor general mull problematic issues
18:00 02.07.2025
South Korean ex-premier, minister summoned over Yoon’s martial law probe
17:45 02.07.2025
Trump says Israel has agreed to 'necessary conditions' to finalize 60-day ceasefire in Gaza
17:30 02.07.2025
DR Congo-Rwanda peace deal ‘does not address serious crimes committed in the east': Amnesty International
17:15 02.07.2025
China again urges its citizens to avoid travel to Iran
17:00 02.07.2025
Australia's Qantas says 6 million customer accounts accessed in cyber hack
16:45 02.07.2025
US accuses UN expert of ‘economic warfare’ over report on companies aiding Israeli occupation
16:30 02.07.2025
150 National Guard troops reassigned from Los Angeles security mission to wildfire response
16:00 02.07.2025
Israeli strikes kill another 29 Palestinians in Gaza Strip
15:45 02.07.2025
Revenue of China’s software industry grows by 11.2%
15:30 02.07.2025
President of Azerbaijan Ilham Aliyev’s one-on-one meeting with President of Uzbekistan Shavkat Mirziyoyev begins
15:20 02.07.2025
Zakharova: Friendly relations between Russia, Azerbaijan extremely important
15:15 02.07.2025
President of Northern Cyprus arrives in Azerbaijan
15:00 02.07.2025
COP29 president: US withdrawal from Paris agreement won't stop global climate movement
14:45 02.07.2025
President of Uzbekistan arrives in Azerbaijan on state visit
14:30 02.07.2025
Saudi Arabia receives written message from Iran
14:15 02.07.2025
Percentage of female students studying in Azerbaijan revealed
14:00 02.07.2025
Five of Russia's neighbors withdraw from Ottawa Treaty
13:45 02.07.2025
Bahar Muradova: Azerbaijan ready to share experience in expanding women's economic rights
13:30 02.07.2025
Prosecutor General's Office: Ziyaddin Safarov died in vehicle of Russian law enforcement agencies
13:15 02.07.2025
Adviser to Uzbek FM: Relations with Azerbaijan demonstrating steady growth in all areas
13:00 02.07.2025
ECO: Significant steps should be taken to increase women's digital skills
12:45 02.07.2025
Some Russian groups want to create crisis in relations with Azerbaijan
12:30 02.07.2025
Israel-Iran ceasefire set to drive oil prices toward $60 range: Experts
12:15 02.07.2025
Hamısı