What is Israel's controversial Hannibal Directive allegedly deployed on October 7?

Analytics 18:00 27.07.2024

 lIsraeli news outlet Haaretz reported at the beginning of July, citing official documents and soldiers and officers of the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) of different ranks, that on October 7, when Hamas launched the attack on Israel's border communities, the Israeli army implemented a controversial procedure known as the Hannibal Directive.

But what exactly is this procedure, introduced in 1986? And what could it mean for the number of Israeli victims claimed at the beginning of the attack that led Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government to carry out such a violent offensive in response, which has left close to 40,000 victims in almost 10 months in the Gaza Strip alone?

To understand why it was implemented, we first need to acknowledge the events of October 7. On that day, Hamas launched a multi-pronged attack on Israel, firing over 3,000 rockets and conducting incursions using vehicles and powered paragliders. The attacks, which began early in the morning, were so unexpected that the IDF had difficulties understanding the situation, the magnitude of the incursion, and the necessary response during the initial hours, according to Ynet. The number of Hamas operatives attacking army strongholds and observation and communications facilities was so overwhelming that the IDF could not obtain clear and reliable information. Despite still lacking a complete picture of the events, the first use of the Hannibal Directive command was reported around 7:18 am, according to Haaretz.

It happened at the Erez border crossing when an "observation post at the Yiftah outpost reported that someone had been kidnapped" near an IDF liaison office, the media said. "Hannibal at Erez" was the command. Later, it would be heard many more times, including at the Re'im army base and the Nahal Oz outpost. By giving this command, the IDF aimed to prevent soldier abductions, even at the risk of harming Israeli forces and civilians.

Although the official documents of this protocol have not been formally disclosed and it is assumed that it was revoked in 2016, the directive stipulates that in the event a soldier is kidnapped or is being kidnapped, maximum force must be used to prevent it, even if that means causing death. In other words, it is equivalent to ordering the captured soldier to be shot to prevent them from being taken prisoner.

In another location of the clashes, at around 6:40 pm, military intelligence reported that Hamas gunmen planned to flee back to Gaza near Kibbutz Be'eri, Kfar Azza, and Kissufim. The order again was to block any vehicles from returning to Gaza, allowing open fire and without checking if civilians or Israeli soldiers may be in those vehicles. Who exactly gave those orders? The media suggested that fact would be likely revealed in post-war investigations.

A report by the United Nations Independent International Commission of Inquiry published in June found that the IDF applied the Hannibal Directive in several locations, killing at least 14 Israeli civilians. This finding further complicates the Israeli narrative surrounding the October 7 attacks, suggesting that the IDF's aggressive measures may have contributed to their own civilian casualties.

The UN and Haaretz investigations added more controversy to the implications of the reported casualties attributed to Hamas. While Hamas's actions did lead to significant loss of life, the use of the Hannibal Directive suggests that some deaths may have been caused by Israeli military actions. The debate over the directive's application raises critical questions about the accountability and accuracy of casualty reports in the aftermath of the October 7 attacks.

Of the 1,139 deaths, including 695 Israeli civilians, 71 foreign nationals, and 373 security personnel reported as casualties caused by Hamas on October 7, how many were caused by Israel? It is vital to clarify this and to remember that those deaths are used as the main reason to hit back at Hamas and incidentally the civilians who are unable to flee the horror of this war.

IEPF issued a statement regarding Azerbaijani children at the UN Human Rights Council

News line

Tomorrow in Abu Dhabi: Aliyev and Pashinyan Hold Crucial Peace Process Talks
12:30 09.07.2025
Heavy rainfall hits SW China, 5 missing in Sichuan
12:15 09.07.2025
U.S. Detaining Individuals from Three Continents at Guantanamo Immigration Facilities
12:00 09.07.2025
Israel eliminates Hamas commander in Lebanon — IDF
11:45 09.07.2025
South Korea sends 6 rescued North Koreans back across sea border
11:30 09.07.2025
US condemns Houthi attacks on cargo ships in Red Sea
11:15 09.07.2025
Trump says he considers agreeing to more sanctions on Russia
11:00 09.07.2025
Today is a Day of Diplomacy in Azerbaijan
10:45 09.07.2025
Mexico probes former president for allegedly taking millions in bribes from Israeli businessmen
10:30 09.07.2025
Trump, Israel’s Netanyahu meet for a second time about a ceasefire in Gaza
10:15 09.07.2025
Death toll surpasses 100, at least 160 missing in Texas
10:00 09.07.2025
Mediators move closer to securing Israel-Hamas ceasefire in Gaza
09:45 09.07.2025
FBI launches probes into former FBI, CIA directors
09:30 09.07.2025
Trump's envoy says US 'hopeful' 60-day Gaza ceasefire agreed upon 'by end of this week'
09:15 09.07.2025
Azerbaijan hosts official reception at Gulustan Palace on occasion of professional holiday of diplomats
09:00 09.07.2025
Organisation of Turkic States, TURKPA congratulate Azerbaijani diplomats on professional holiday
08:45 09.07.2025
Rubio: US waiting for signing of Azerbaijan-Armenia peace treaty
08:30 09.07.2025
Russia charges former deputy defense minister with fraud, illegal arms trafficking
20:45 08.07.2025
Far-right Israeli ministers call to block Gaza aid, enforce starvation, halt ceasefire talks
20:30 08.07.2025
Ukraine appeals to OPCW to investigate possible use of chemical weapons by Russia
20:00 08.07.2025
Minister: Slovenia considers Azerbaijan key partner in green transition
19:45 08.07.2025
Ukrainian forces push back and hold ground in Russian regions, army chief says
19:30 08.07.2025
Tajikistan, Kyrgyzstan open new border crossing point
19:15 08.07.2025
Azerbaijan, Slovenia discuss green energy collaboration
19:00 08.07.2025
Baku hosts conference on role of National Leader Heydar Aliyev in media development
18:45 08.07.2025
Another Training Session Held at IEPF Headquarters – Representation at the UN in Focus
18:15 08.07.2025
'We will de-risk our economies, but we do not want to decouple,' EU Commission president says on relations with China
18:15 08.07.2025
France’s Macron makes state visit to UK with migration and Ukraine on agenda
18:00 08.07.2025
Armenian Investigative Committee conducts searches at 51 addresses simultaneously
17:45 08.07.2025
4 killed, over 20 injured in Cairo data center fire
17:30 08.07.2025
Unknown individuals attack MPs in Armenian parliament
17:15 08.07.2025
Raids on illegal migrants in hostels, prayer houses in Moscow
17:00 08.07.2025
Hakan Fidan doesn’t rule out meeting of Russian, Ukrainian and US presidents in Türkiye
16:45 08.07.2025
Investigators raid head office of Electric Networks of Armenia
16:30 08.07.2025
Family of 4 killed after small plane crashes in North Carolina
16:15 08.07.2025
ASCO discusses port, logistics centers development with Chinese company
16:00 08.07.2025
Newcastle agree £55m fee for Forest winger Elanga
15:45 08.07.2025
Pashinyan says he will personally lead 'liberation' of Armenian church
15:30 08.07.2025
Russian emergencies minister thanks Azerbaijan for organizing evacuation of Russian citizens from Iran
15:15 08.07.2025
Azerbaijani parliament adopts in final reading improvement of requirements for services and work provided by NGOs
15:00 08.07.2025
Hamısı