Military Doctrine of Russia and the Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict

Analytics 13:30 13.04.2021

Eurasia Diary has published an article titled "Military Doctrine of Russia and Nagorno-Karabakh conflict" .  

Article is written by Mehmet Sukru Guzel, the co-founder of the Center for Peace and Reconcilation Studies. 

If we ask the question whether Russia is really interested in the solution of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict and prolonging it we first need to remember the known reality that Armenia could have avoided if agreed to negotiations on the basis of four resolutions of the UN Security Council (822/1993, 853/1993, 874/1993, 884/1993) prior to the outbreak of the conflict last year. But in fact negotiations were prevented not only by Armenia but by the Minsk Group as well which Russia is a member. Not only Armenia but the Minsk Group is the responsible for the last armed conflict.

Every state has its own fears and these fears are documented officially in their Military Doctrine by which they do warn other states in their policy towards themselves before any action. And on the other hand, every state has an unwritten non official secret text of its own defense doctrine. And every state decides its own foreign strategy accordingly these two concepts.

If we remember the near past experience of Russia in its West, we can well analyze the fears of Russia in the South Caucasus or in the post-Soviet space. Russia has the fears of an old empire state to survive as a big power. History had showed that weak states became long term empires if they managed to survive like Rome or Ottoman Empires. The reason of being an empire lies in its weaknesses. Russia is a weak state and Russia do know this. Why Russia is a weak state is a subject of another article. The fears of Russia are well written in its official Military Doctrine.

In the near past, the promises that had given to Mikhail Gorbachev by the NATO officials not to expand into the territories which are crucial for Russia`s security concept and in return, Russia removed its troops from Eastern Europe and the Baltic states. NATO did not keep its promise and the Czech Republic, Hungary and Poland (1999), Bulgaria, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Romania, Slovakia and Slovenia (2004), Albania and Croatia (2009), Montenegro (2017) and North Macedonia (2020) became the members of NATO.

As written in the 2010 Military Doctrine of Russia, conventional “realpolitik” considerations were written in the balance of power between the USAs, NATO and Russia. In the Military Doctrine, it asserted the possibility of Russia to take unilateral action, if it was required by its most vital national interests. NATO’s expansion policy was characterized as a potential danger to Russia’s security. The decision to annex Crimea was probably made in 2008, soon after the Bucharest summit where NATO promised Ukraine and Georgia future membership in the Alliance. After the Bucharest summit, Russia announced that it would no longer participate in the Commonwealth of Independent States economic sanctions imposed on Abkhazia in 1996 and established direct relations with the separatist authorities in Abkhazia and South Ossetia.  The 2014 Military Doctrine of Russia, it had given the message that Russia`s neighborhood should be regarded as its sphere of influence, which Moscow is ready to defend, by all means. The war in Donbass as well begun in 2014. Russia also threatened Moldova after 2014 by increasing its military exercises in Transnistria from a few dozen to a few hundred per year. Russia acts accordingly to its Military Doctrine.

Russia`s geopolitical interests in the South Caucasus that is Russia`s existence in this region on one side depends on the prolonging of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict forever by which Russia can reach its ally State Iran in a way or other as written in its Military Doctrine.

The 9 November Ceasefire Agreement does not address the status of Nagorno-Karabakh nor does it create a path to a final resolution of the conflict. It is a ceasefire agreement but at the same time, it is the realization of 3 of the Madrid Principles of the Minsk Group. These are; principle one, the return of the territories surrounding Nagorno-Karabakh to Azerbaijani control, principle three a corridor linking Armenia to Nagorno-Karabakh, and principle six international security guarantees that would include a peacekeeping operation. Principle two and four, an interim status for Nagorno-Karabakh providing guarantees for security and self-governance and principle, five future determination of the final legal status of Nagorno-Karabakh through a legally binding expression of will were not written in the 9 November Statement. The Russian peacekeeping operation as a fait accompli put two members of the Minsk Group US and France, out of the political balance game of South Caucasus. In reality, there exists no more Minks Group, with the peacekeeping operation, Russia has a mechanism to conduct direct mediation between Baku and Yerevan for a period of five years and this monopoly depends on the prolonging of the conflict. The peacekeeping operation of Russia does not share control with civil-society or any other actors and has no need for any external mandate of UN, OSCE, or CSTO for humanitarian, political, military power

Russia has a proven management of conflicts in the South Caucasus South Ossetia, and Abkhazia in Georgia now Russia is the only game player. Nagorno-Karabakh was the only conflict in the former Soviet Union with no Russian presence. Now, there is a known reality that there can be a military solution in Nagorno-Karabakh by Azerbaijan which means the end of the Russian presence in the South Caucasus in political sense. A solution of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict means the end of the effective political control of Russia in other words defeat of Russia in international politics. Russia by the peacekeeping force now has effective political control on the foreign politics of Armenia and Azerbaijan. A simple example, in June 2019, Armenian representative voted against the return of Russia to the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE). This can be never possible after the 9 November Ceasefire Agreement.

The 2014 Military Doctrine of Russia had given the message that Russia`s neighborhood should be regarded as its sphere of influence, preventing any future pro-Western Armenia and Azerbaijan governments and the influence of Russia depends on no solution based approach which was in fact the policy of Minsk Group.

 

IEPF issued a statement regarding Azerbaijani children at the UN Human Rights Council

News line

Palestinian man shot dead after stabbing Israeli soldier during West Bank raid
21:20 10.07.2025
Israel has agreed to 'significant steps' to improve humanitarian situation in Gaza: EU foreign policy chief
21:00 10.07.2025
EU aims to mobilize up to $11.7B in investments for Ukraine's reconstruction
20:45 10.07.2025
UNAIDS warns funding collapse could lead to 6M new HIV infections, 4M deaths
20:30 10.07.2025
UN report sounds alarm on climate health risks for world's aging population
20:00 10.07.2025
Merz: Germany fully supports Ukraine's plans to join EU
19:45 10.07.2025
Azerbaijani citizens involved in Wagner armed group arrested - State Security Service conducts operation
19:15 10.07.2025
Luka Modric signs one-year contract with Milan
19:00 10.07.2025
Rubio: US hopes to persuade NATO allies to transfer some Patriot systems to Ukraine
18:45 10.07.2025
Zelenskyy: 200 agreements with total value of over €10B ready to be signed
18:30 10.07.2025
Von der Leyen's EU Commission survives Parliament confidence vote
18:15 10.07.2025
SOCAR becomes jersey sponsor of Turkish First League side
18:00 10.07.2025
Azerbaijan takes leading postion in UN digital trade survey
17:45 10.07.2025
Ex-NBA player Ben McLemore sentenced to over 8 years in prison for rape
17:30 10.07.2025
Russia warns Armenia of sanctions risk
17:15 10.07.2025
COP29 President, COP30 President-designate hold discussions at OPEC seminar
17:00 10.07.2025
Ilham Aliyev's meeting with Nikol Pashinyan was constructive
16:55 10.07.2025
Baku says Azerbaijan, Armenia agreed to continue dialogue in bilateral format
16:45 10.07.2025
Peskov: Baku-Yerevan peace treaty will bring stability to South Caucasus
16:30 10.07.2025
Azerbaijan refunds over 94M manats of VAT to consumers
16:15 10.07.2025
Amnesty International slams US sanctions on UN Rapporteur Francesca Albanese
16:00 10.07.2025
China pushes back 50% US 'security' tariffs on copper imports
15:45 10.07.2025
Top Southeast Asian diplomats hold summit with China’s foreign minister
15:30 10.07.2025
Israeli strikes on Gaza leave 97 Palestinians killed, dozens more injured in past day
15:15 10.07.2025
Messi creates history in MLS, becomes first player to achieve rare feat
15:00 10.07.2025
Heavy rain delays over 300 flights in New Delhi
14:45 10.07.2025
Shamakhi to host conference on Modern Information Space and Freedom of Religious Belief
14:30 10.07.2025
At least 28 killed, dozens injured in pre-dawn Israeli strikes across Gaza Strip
14:15 10.07.2025
Court orders arrest of former South Korean president
14:00 10.07.2025
US nuclear-powered submarine makes first port call in Iceland
13:45 10.07.2025
Israeli soldier killed during attempted Hamas abduction in southern Gaza, IDF says
13:30 10.07.2025
ADY and China Railways reach agreement to increase BTK capacity
13:15 10.07.2025
U.S. measles cases hit highest level in 33 years,
13:00 10.07.2025
Azerbaijan, Saudi Arabia discuss co-op in hydrocarbon sector
12:45 10.07.2025
UK, France to order more Storm Shadow missiles, plan next-generation replacements
12:30 10.07.2025
Houthis kidnapped crew members of Eternity C vessel, US Embassy in Yemen says
12:15 10.07.2025
President Ilham Aliyev addresses participants of ICDO General Assembly session
12:00 10.07.2025
US to impose 50% tariffs on imports from Brazil starting August — Trump
11:45 10.07.2025
US resumes certain arms shipments to Ukraine
11:30 10.07.2025
SOCAR president participates in OPEC International Seminar
11:15 10.07.2025
Hamısı