'Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh are not separate nation but just a minority within Azerbaijan' Azerbaijani researcher

Analytics 14:27 30.01.2020

Armenians live in Nagorno-Karabakh have no right of self-determination, Azerbaijani researcher Kamal Makili-Aliyev told to Eurasia Diary.

Kamal Makili-Aliyev is an author of the book "Contested Territories and International Law: A Comparative Study of the Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict and the Aland Islands Precedent." Dr. Makili-Aliyev holds a Doctor of Laws degree (LL.D.) in International and Constitutional Law from the Institute on Human Rights of the National Academy of Sciences of Azerbaijan.

“One of the main problems in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict is understanding the concept of people in international law. Because only people have self-determination right,” he informed.

The researcher also explained that the so-called Nagorno-Karabakh state cannot be considered as a state, because, firstly, there is no seperate nation or people.

"The Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh are not the same people with Armenians live in Armenia. They are Azerbaijani, they are the minority. Armenians live in Armenia are people they have a state. The notion of people is political."

There are many ethnicities in Azerbaijan for example; lezgis, talyshs, but self-determination cannot be applied for them.

“People and nations are the same in the UN documents. Many does not know it, that’s why they confused

“Self-determination is not right to create state it doesn’t give you right to cede. It is only to raise the problem and holds a referendum," Kamal Makili-Aliyev noted.

Autonomies are formed for preserving minorities, cultures. It serves in preventing them from assimilation.

He also touched upon that the root of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict. According to him, the conflict emerged when USSR dissolved because during the creation of the USSR they had not solved the problem just froze.

 “Azerbaijan agrees for autonomy, but it is a decline of sovereignty. Because, Autonomy limits sovereignty, so, it is a great compromise by Azerbaijan.”

Kamal Makili-Aliyev reveals his attitude to Pashinyan's statement which claims that the resolution should be beneficial for both Azerbaijanis and Armenians. "There is not ultimate winner in peaceful resolution. If we want to win, we should lose a bit."

In my book, I evaluated Aaland model and Nagorno-Karabakh conflict. We should pay attention that in the Aaland case, League of Nations had been international guarantors, in the result, they could solve the problem in 1921. It set conditions for Finland if the government will not follow certain rules so, the Swedish minority of the island can hold a referendum for status.

Unfortunately, the same had not happened in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict. During that time USSR was not a member of the League of Nations. In conclusion, the international guarantor of the conflict could not have existed.

 

Kamal Makili-Aliyev (LL.D.) is an Affiliated Researcher at Raoul Wallenberg Institute for Human Rights and Humanitarian Law, specializing in international human rights law, public international law, conflict resolution and peace-building, non-discrimination, including gender equality issues and minority rights.

By Ulvi Ahmedli

IEPF issued a statement regarding Azerbaijani children at the UN Human Rights Council

News line

Drone attack in Russia's Udmurtia leaves three dead, dozens injured
20:15 01.07.2025
Billionaire Musk vows to launch new political party if controversial Trump bill passes Congress
20:00 01.07.2025
Broken Friendship: Azerbaijan–Russia Relations INTERVIEW
19:40 01.07.2025
Baku to host D-8 Youth Forum in July
19:30 01.07.2025
Speaker: Armenia should seriously begin discussing issue of stopping broadcasting Russian TV channels
19:20 01.07.2025
Russian Foreign Ministry: Azerbaijani envoy handed verbal note
19:15 01.07.2025
Azerbaijan signs $173.5M loan agreement with WB for renewable energy project
19:00 01.07.2025
Azerbaijan, Uzbekistan ink several documents to diversify economic partnership
18:45 01.07.2025
Another group of Ukrainian children arrive in Azerbaijan for rehabilitation
18:15 01.07.2025
IEPF Launches a Series of Trainings for NGOs
18:14 01.07.2025
Sahil Babayev: Azerbaijan aims to become green energy exporter
18:00 01.07.2025
Azerbaijani minister: Youth action plan to be drafted at international event in Aghdam
17:45 01.07.2025
Azerbaijan launches criminal case into killing of Azerbaijani brothers in Russia
17:30 01.07.2025
European diplomats visit West Bank town after deadly attack by Israeli settlers
17:15 01.07.2025
Poland’s president calls on gov’t to stop entry of migrants from Germany
17:00 01.07.2025
Artists, writers urge UK government not to ban pro-Palestine group
16:45 01.07.2025
China's Communist Party tops 100 million members in ‘significant milestone’
16:30 01.07.2025
China says ‘complicated’ boundary dispute with India will take time to resolve
16:15 01.07.2025
Severe weather batters Italy, leaving two dead and multiple regions on alert
16:00 01.07.2025
Azerbaijan detains Russian citizens in Baku suspected of drug trafficking, online fraud
15:50 01.07.2025
China sanctions former Philippines senator over 'egregious conduct' on Beijing-related issues
15:30 01.07.2025
Meta fined over $512,000 by Taiwan for lack of transparency over advertisers
15:15 01.07.2025
Trump says Musk would ‘head back to South Africa’ without US subsidies for EVs
15:00 01.07.2025
Azerbaijani brothers murdered in Russia hit with blunt instrument, examinations reveal
14:45 01.07.2025
Kazakhstan commends top-tier organization of ECO Youth Forum in Azerbaijan's Aghdam
14:30 01.07.2025
U.S. Charge d'Affaires hails Azerbaijan’s support in ensuring safe evacuation country's citizens from Iran
14:15 01.07.2025
Slovakia appoints Azerbaijani native as ambassador to Baku
14:00 01.07.2025
Fitch reveals forecast for Azerbaijan's state budget deficit in 2025
13:45 01.07.2025
WSJ: Amazon is on the cusp of using more robots than Humans in its warehouses
13:30 01.07.2025
Politico: EC ready to allow countries to restrict access to social networks by age
13:15 01.07.2025
Azerbaijani brothers murdered in Russia hit with blunt instrument, examinations reveal
13:00 01.07.2025
Azerbaijani official elected vice-president of international conference
12:45 01.07.2025
US approves $510M sale of munitions guidance kits to Israel
12:30 01.07.2025
Death toll in India factory blast rises to 34
12:25 01.07.2025
Azerbaijani ambassador leaves Russian Foreign Ministry building
12:15 01.07.2025
Iranian president to attend ECO summit in Azerbaijan's Khankandi
12:10 01.07.2025
Russia summons Azerbaijani ambassador
12:00 01.07.2025
Iran-linked hackers threaten to release Trump aides' emails
11:45 01.07.2025
Israeli strikes on Gaza Strip leave 95 Palestinians killed
11:30 01.07.2025
Israel shoots down over 1,000 Iranian drones — permanent representative to UN
11:15 01.07.2025
Hamısı