Microsoft puts Qualcomm on blast

Science & Tech 22:47 21.12.2018

Microsoft has put modem and embedded processor rival Qualcomm on blast for, it claims, its attempts to 'stifle competition' through unfair licensing practices and aggressive yet unsuccessful patent lawsuits - ironic, given the company's history in this regard.

As well as attempting, and largely failing, to compete against Qualcomm's low-power system-on-chip products, Microsoft has been in a toe-to-toe battle with the company over who will get to supply modem parts to Apple for its iPhone and cellular iPad products. Qualcomm, for its part, accused Intel of receiving confidential information leaked by Apple while also claiming Apple artificially restricted the performance of Qualcomm modems to make Intel parts look better. Intel, naturally, denies these claims - and now is putting Qualcomm's own anticompetitive practices in the limelight.

'Competition authorities around the world have repeatedly found Qualcomm’s licensing practices unlawful, yet Qualcomm continues to try to achieve the same results through a campaign of patent lawsuits,' Intel's general counsel Steven R. Rodgers claims in an aggressive piece titled Another Attempt to Stifle Competition published late last night. 'These lawsuits have been largely unsuccessful, and at best would reduce innovation and raise prices. Qualcomm’s goal is not to vindicate its intellectual property rights, but rather to drive competition out of the market for premium modem chips, and to defend a business model that ultimately harms consumers. As we’ve noted before, in the last several years, Qualcomm has been fined nearly a billion dollars in China, $850 million in Korea, $1.2 billion by the European Commission and $773 million in Taiwan (later reduced in a settlement) for anti-competitive practices.

'Meanwhile, the U.S. Federal Trade Commission continues to pursue claims against Qualcomm in federal court for alleged violation of U.S. antitrust law. Just last month, the Northern California federal district court rejected Qualcomm’s arguments that it has a legal basis for its refusal to license its standards-essential patents to modem chip competitors. Judge Lucy Koh rejected Qualcomm’s strained arguments that its conduct has a basis in the rules of its standards bodies participation. She concluded that, “Qualcomm never attempts to explain how discrimination against modem chip suppliers is consistent with the stated purposes of the IPR policies.” Opening arguments in the Federal Trade Commission case will begin Jan. 4. We encourage everyone interested in the future of mobile communications to pay attention to this case.'

Rodgers' aggressive approach stands in stark contrast to Intel's own reputation in this area: Back in 2009 the company was hit with a record £948 million fine by the European Commission over its abuse of a dominant market position to exclude AMD and other competitors, offering hidden rebates - and, in one case, an outright cash bung - for companies to stock Intel parts exclusively, while also bribing manufacturers to cancel or delay the launch of products containing AMD processors. The company did, however, successfully request a review of the ruling, which it was granted in 2017 and which has yet to be completed. A similar case brought against Intel by the US Federal Trade Comission was settled in 2010, as was a Korean antitrust violation suit in 2008.

Qualcomm has not publicly responded to Microsoft's attack.

US never wanted Ukraine to win, american journalist says - VİDEO

News line

Azerbaijan and Russia jointly participate in implementation of North-South Transport Corridor - Putin
23:30 22.04.2024
Georgia welcomes Azerbaijan-Armenia agreement on border delimitation
22:22 22.04.2024
Azerbaijani and Russian Presidents Hold One-on-One Meeting - UPDATED
21:00 22.04.2024
Russian Forces Capture Most Powerful Model of Leopard 2 Transferred to Ukraine
20:00 22.04.2024
283 bodies allegedly found in mass grave in Gaza's Nasser hospital
19:19 22.04.2024
Azerbaijan, WB hold discussions on joint projects
Azerbaijan, WB hold discussions on joint projects
19:00 22.04.2024
German Chancellor: Support for Ukraine will not diminish
18:39 22.04.2024
Armenian PM, EU Special Representative discussed delimitation of borders with Azerbaijan
18:18 22.04.2024
Ljubljana welcomes agreement between Baku and Yerevan
Ljubljana welcomes agreement between Baku and Yerevan
17:55 22.04.2024
Netanyahu vows to fight US sanctions on IDF
17:42 22.04.2024
Russian NGO warns about Cholera and Hepatitis in flood zones in Russia
Russian NGO warns about Cholera and Hepatitis in flood zones in Russia
17:33 22.04.2024
Putin: Heydar Aliyev played significant role in construction of Baikal-Amur Mainline
17:20 22.04.2024
Scholz says era of fossil fuel will be over soon
Scholz says era of fossil fuel will be over soon
17:02 22.04.2024
Putin: Russia-Azerbaijan relations at high level and developing
16:45 22.04.2024
Pakistan-Azerbaijan Economic Integration Model: An Expert Opinion
16:30 22.04.2024
Fikret Sadigov: Peace is close to the South Caucasus
16:00 22.04.2024
US, Yemen Ink 5-Year Assistance Agreement For Economic Development
US, Yemen Ink 5-Year Assistance Agreement For Economic Development
15:44 22.04.2024
Pundit: If peace is not achieved, Azerbaijan will return its lands by force
15:39 22.04.2024
Malaysian Senate president to visit Azerbaijan
Malaysian Senate president to visit Azerbaijan
15:20 22.04.2024
51 mines found in liberated territories last week
51 mines found in liberated territories last week
15:08 22.04.2024
Peskov: Putin and Pashinyan will soon discuss departure of Russian border guards
Peskov: Putin and Pashinyan will soon discuss departure of Russian border guards
14:50 22.04.2024
Armenia clears the border with the Gazakh district of Azerbaijan of mines ahead of delimitation process - VİDEO
14:31 22.04.2024
Armenia, EU discuss regional situation
Armenia, EU discuss regional situation
14:00 22.04.2024
West balancing on edge of direct military confrontation between nuclear powers — Lavrov
West balancing on edge of direct military confrontation between nuclear powers — Lavrov
13:47 22.04.2024
CSTO Secretary-General: Baku alone will ensure security in Karabakh
13:23 22.04.2024
Armenian sappers start demining works in village of Lower Askipara
12:55 22.04.2024
President of Azerbaijan Ilham Aliyev arrives in Russia for working visit
12:21 22.04.2024
China may claim land on the Moon, NASA warns
12:12 22.04.2024
Pope: I am observing Middle East in awe
Pope: I am observing Middle East in awe
11:54 22.04.2024
Pashinyan to follow Ilham Aliyev's Moscow visit for crucial talks :report
11:40 22.04.2024
US never wanted Ukraine to win, american journalist says - VİDEO
11:25 22.04.2024
Chargé d'affaires of China: Historic opportunity has arisen to boost relations with Azerbaijan
11:12 22.04.2024
Expert: Azerbaijan has become an important factor for Eurasia
10:55 22.04.2024
Azerbaijani police found numerous weapons and ammunition in Khankandi
10:45 22.04.2024
Oil price sees decrease in world markets
Oil price sees decrease in world markets
10:33 22.04.2024
US secretary of state, Israeli defense minister discuss efforts to reach ceasefire
10:20 22.04.2024
NATO's Stoltenberg: US approval of aid package for Ukraine has not come too late
10:14 22.04.2024
Trump has only $6.8 million for legal fees with trial underway
09:55 22.04.2024
Norway becomes latest European state to boost defense spending
09:45 22.04.2024
Conflicts push military spending to 'all-time high' - REPORTS
09:33 22.04.2024
Hamısı