Elections in Lebanon, does political change stand a chance?

Al Jazeera discusses with analysts what lies ahead as power has shifted in Lebanon’s sectarian power-sharing system.

Analytics 12:40 19.05.2022
As Lebanon’s election frenzy cools down, the country has awoken to a new chapter in its dizzying political history.
After Sunday’s election result, shifts in the balance of power in the country’s 128-seat parliament and its fragile sectarian power-sharing system have occurred.
Lawmakers who for many decades were constant variables in Lebanon’s political equation were unseated. Unfamiliar faces, inspired by the country’s 2019 uprising, were elected and might now breathe new life into an often comatose political system.
But some of the election euphoria is already overshadowed by problems that continue to plague Lebanon for a third year, particularly the economy.
The Lebanese pound, with its value already decimated and down by 90 percent compared to the United States dollar, has plummeted further. Foreign reserves in the Banque du Liban or central bank are diminishing, and petrol and food prices continue to soar amidst fears of both fuel and wheat shortages.
Experts told Al Jazeera that while Lebanon’s election result marks a critical moment in the country’s troubled history, what lies ahead could determine whether Lebanon stands a chance at viability.
Allies let down Hezbollah
The powerful Iran-backed Shia party Hezbollah did not lose any of its seats, but the political allies that helped it maintain a parliamentary majority suffered major blows, both from traditional rival political parties and a new anti-establishment opposition.
Notably, a Greek Orthodox seat and a Druze seat in key areas of influence in southern Lebanon went to anti-establishment opposition candidates: a medical doctor Elias Jradeh and lawyer Firas Hamdan.
Hezbollah’s key Christian political ally, the Free Patriotic Movement, is no longer the biggest Christian party.
However, neither Hezbollah nor the Free Patriotic Movement have conceded defeat, and both have declared the elections a victory.
While political alliances in Lebanon can be fluid, experts say the vote was a huge blow to the once-dominant Christian party.
“I think the Aounists [Free Patriotic Movement] will have to admit that they have objectively lost – even if they’re trying to put a spin on it,” Arab Reform Initiative Executive Director Nadim Houry told Al Jazeera.
Hezbollah’s broad alliances were “weak and fragile”, and elections were one way of demonstrating loyalty, Carnegie Middle East Research Fellow Mohanad Hage Ali explained.
The election results might also indicate shifts in public opinion among Shia voters too, the researcher said, explaining that “alternative Shia votes” might have opted for candidates outside the Hezbollah political alliance.
“[Hezbollah] wanted no vote outside its own political choosing, and they did everything they can to intimidate voters, candidates, and their representatives in their constituencies,” Hage Ali told  Al Jazeera, citing numerous statements from Lebanese elections observers about the Shia party.

Political paralysis?

As the economy continues to spiral, the new parliament does not have much time to convene and start the process of appointing a new prime minister and forming a new government. But with no parliamentary majority that traditional factions can use to assume power together, experts believe a political deadlock is possible.
“That’s one scenario with potentially those in the middle [opposition] trying to mediate but not enough to impose an agenda,” the Arab Reform Initiative’s Houry told Al Jazeera.
Lebanon’s prime minister is a Sunni, and the government is divided along the country’s multitude of religious sects and different political forces in parliament. This fragile power-sharing system can quickly lead to paralysis.
“Lebanon is a very difficult country to govern, and it has a very divided parliament,” Houry said.
With Hezbollah’s rivals, the pro-Saudi and pro-US Christian Lebanese Forces, winning new seats and potentially forming an anti-Hezbollah alliance with other candidates, the two could be neck and neck in negotiations to form a new government. This comes less than a year after partisans of both parties clashed in Beirut, killing six people in scenes that resembled the country’s civil war.
And after almost a year of trading blows in the media and on the streets, both parties will now challenge each other in the political arena.
Hezbollah has already insisted on a “national unity government” that includes representatives of all political interests in the country, while the galvanised Christian Lebanese Forces want a government with minimal influence from their political adversaries.
Lebanon is no stranger to political paralysis.
It took politicians 13 months of negotiating to form the current government under Prime Minister Najib Mikati.
New political deadlocks will also come at a steep price, especially with the economy failing, and a caretaker government that will be unable to introduce new laws or do anything beyond the basics.
Houry says if there is no compromise from either side, then “complete blockage” can be expected in the political system.
“Hezbollah, I think, will have to make some compromise. The question will be is how much?”
There may be compromise on some domestic issues, such as corruption, rather than on Hezbollah’s military power or involvement in regional conflicts, he said.
“But another issue is whether or not Lebanese Forces and their allies decide to push things – you can’t corner Hezbollah because you have a majority in parliament. It just doesn’t work that way,” Houry said.
This is a political scenario that is eerily similar to Lebanon after 2005.
At that time, there were two clear factions divided in terms of their position in relation to Hezbollah’s weapons, and the movement’s allies in Syria and Iran. It was a period marked by political paralysis, large-scale protests, assassinations, and even some armed conflict.
“This could be a repeat of post-2005 where they either block things institutionally or through the streets,” Houry said.
“The ball is on their [Hezbollah’s] court whether they decide to facilitate or not.”
Lavrov: 3+3 platform initiated by President of Azerbaijan becoming more and more promising - VİDEO

News line

IDF releases photo of senior Hamas officials killed in Gaza military operation
20:55 07.12.2023
Denmark passes bill to stop Koran burnings
20:20 07.12.2023
Greek Prime Minister vows to support Türkiye in EU accession process
19:01 07.12.2023
Azerbaijan, UK mull perspectives of relations in banking and financial sectors
18:36 07.12.2023
BRI and Chinese values of Humanity and Humanism - ANALYSIS
18:02 07.12.2023
EU warns China of consequences of escalation in Taiwan
17:53 07.12.2023
Putin: Changes observed in system of international relations
17:15 07.12.2023
MFA: Number of victims of mine terrorism since end of 44-day war has reached 340
17:09 07.12.2023
Greece, Türkiye seek to restart relations
Greece, Türkiye seek to restart relations
16:47 07.12.2023
UN agency staff death toll in Gaza rises to 132
16:37 07.12.2023
Freight traffic by rail increases sharply between China, Azerbaijan
16:28 07.12.2023
Number of Azerbaijani citizens admitted to higher Ukrainian universityies over past two years announced
16:18 07.12.2023
UN agency staff death toll in Gaza rises to 132
16:08 07.12.2023
Bishkek hosts ICT Ministerial Meeting of OTS
Bishkek hosts ICT Ministerial Meeting of OTS
15:58 07.12.2023
Azerbaijani artists present paintings dedicated to history, culture of Poland
Azerbaijani artists present paintings dedicated to history, culture of Poland
15:50 07.12.2023
Chevron announces $15.5-$16.5B capex budget for 2024
Chevron announces $15.5-$16.5B capex budget for 2024
15:40 07.12.2023
Azerbaijan, Moldova sign memorandum of cooperation
Azerbaijan, Moldova sign memorandum of cooperation
15:30 07.12.2023
EU announces agenda of Eastern Partnership Foreign Affairs Ministerial meeting
EU announces agenda of Eastern Partnership Foreign Affairs Ministerial meeting
15:20 07.12.2023
Nepal arresting recruiters of country’s citizens into Russian army
15:10 07.12.2023
Georgia to get candidate status at next meeting of EU Council
15:00 07.12.2023
Armenian Parliament to hold extraordinary meeting next week
14:49 07.12.2023
Israel may extend age limit for reservists by another year
Israel may extend age limit for reservists by another year
14:40 07.12.2023
UK defense secretary to visit Middle East
14:32 07.12.2023
Washington Post journalists plan 24-hour strike amid prolonged contract talks
Washington Post journalists plan 24-hour strike amid prolonged contract talks
14:22 07.12.2023
Seychelles declares state of emergency after explosion, flooding
Seychelles declares state of emergency after explosion, flooding
14:12 07.12.2023
Israel: Hamas fires rockets from humanitarian zones
14:00 07.12.2023
Turkish President Erdogan visits Greece
Turkish President Erdogan visits Greece
13:47 07.12.2023
Azerbaijan, Armenia may sign peace treaty in coming days - Armenian Parliament Speaker
13:37 07.12.2023
February 7 to be non-working day in Azerbaijan next year
13:30 07.12.2023
Annual trade relations between Azerbaijan, Britain is worth GBP 1.3 billion - British Minister for Exports
13:21 07.12.2023
Meeting of Central Election Commission to be held related to extraordinary presidential elections in Azerbaijan
13:03 07.12.2023
EU reportedly reaches deal on AI law
EU reportedly reaches deal on AI law
12:45 07.12.2023
One injured in landmine explosion in Shusha
12:25 07.12.2023
Participants of international forum visit Aghdam Martyrs Alley
12:18 07.12.2023
Azerbaijan to hold snap presidential election in February
12:13 07.12.2023
Umud Mirzayev expressed his condolences to "Al-Jazeera" reporter Moamen Al-Sharaf
11:42 07.12.2023
UK deploys 1,000 more troops to Middle East
11:36 07.12.2023
Tractor hit by mine in Horadiz, one injured
11:30 07.12.2023
President declared Borrell's hypocritical character to the international community - MP Konul Nurullayeva
11:08 07.12.2023
President of Uzbekistan pardons over 300 prisoners on Constitution Day
President of Uzbekistan pardons over 300 prisoners on Constitution Day
10:56 07.12.2023