Microsoft's overseas privacy battle may be far from over

Conflicts 19:08 15.07.2016

Privacy advocates, especially those outside the U.S., can rest a little easier now.  A federal court has rebuked the U.S. government’s attempt to access emails stored on a Microsoft server in Ireland.

But the legal battle may be far from over. Thursday’s ruling could affect how the U.S. conducts surveillance over suspected criminals and terrorists overseas, so expect the government to appeal, said Roy Hadley, a lawyer at Thompson Hine who studies cybersecurity issues.

“There’s a fine line between privacy and national security,” he said. “And it’s a difficult line to walk.”

So far, the U.S. Department of Justice is remaining mum on what it might do. “We are disappointed with the court’s decision and are considering our options,” the department said on Thursday, without elaborating.

Hadley thinks the government will probably appeal the decision to another circuit court or the Supreme Court. It might also explore other legal means to force Microsoft to quickly hand over the emails.

“The U.S. government will always try to be in a position to gain access to that data,” he said.

Thursday’s ruling deals with a case that goes back to December 2013, when the U.S. government obtained a search warrant for emails belonging to Microsoft user who was under investigation. The subject’s identity hasn’t been revealed, but some news reports have said it was not a U.S. citizen.

The emails reside on a Microsoft server in Ireland. Microsoft objected to the search warrant and argued that the U.S. had no authority to conduct email searches in other countries.

On Thursday, Microsoft hailed the ruling as a win for privacy rights and said dozens of other tech and media companies have supported its legal battle.

The court’s decision “ensures that people’s privacy rights are protected by the laws of their own countries,” Microsoft said in a statement.

Craig Newman, a privacy attorney at Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler, said the tech industry is no doubt breathing a sigh of relief. Many U.S. companies, including Microsoft, have data centers around the world and serve millions of foreign customers.

Handing over any of their data to U.S. authorities could violate the privacy laws of those countries and hurt business for the companies that store it, he said.  

“The tech companies have really been put in an uncomfortable position,” he said.

Part of the problem is that some U.S. privacy laws may be outdated. At the center of Microsoft’s legal battle has been the Stored Communications Act, which the U.S. government argued gave it the authority to use a warrant to collect the emails.

The judges who ruled Thursday didn’t agree. The law was enacted in 1986, long before the mainstream Internet or any remote computing, wrote judge Gerard Lynch.

To avoid these legal disputes with the tech industry, Congress should modernize laws on data privacy and clearly define them, Newman said.

“You’re dealing with analog rules in a world that has totally changed,” he said. “Congress needs to roll up their sleeves and figure out the right balance.

IEPF organized a discussion at COP29 on the role of NGOs in combating the climate crisis

News line

50 Years of Silence: The Shocking Secret of Valentina Tereshkova Unveiled
08:15 26.03.2025
The Fermi Paradox: Unveiling the Secrets of the Universe
17:22 24.03.2025
U.S. Urges Peace and Prisoner Release
10:46 19.03.2025
The Impact of Climate Change on Urban Life: A Growing Global Challenge
13:18 18.03.2025
Israel Court Delays Netanyahu Hearing as Military Operations Resume in Gaza
10:58 18.03.2025
Statement by the International Eurasia Press Fund (IEPF) on the European Parliament Resolution of 13 March 2025
20:31 17.03.2025
Humanity’s Energy Odyssey: A Glimpse into the Future through the Kardashev Scale
09:56 14.03.2025
Ceasefire at a Crossroads
02:08 14.03.2025
Dyson Spheres: Is the Solution to Humanity’s Energy Needs in Space?
12:17 13.03.2025
The Mysterious Disapperance
11:46 13.03.2025
The Four Horsemen of Hell: Stress, Depression, Paranoia, and Panic Attacks
12:59 12.03.2025
USA set to present 30 day ceasefire offer to Russia
09:15 12.03.2025
A man who ran lenght of Africa
08:19 12.03.2025
Nepal want the monarchy back
12:08 11.03.2025
“We hope that heritage examples from Western Azerbaijan will be included in the unified national fund”
10:41 11.03.2025
The ancient city of Alexandria faces the risk of sinking
11:29 06.03.2025
The U.S. has stopped military aid. What does this mean for Ukraine?
21:00 04.03.2025
How the climate crisis fuels gender inequality
11:30 03.03.2025
37 years have passed since the Sumgayit events, which were caused by Armenian provocation
15:48 28.02.2025
Member of Azerbaijan Parliament wrote about Khojali Genocide
14:39 26.02.2025
"We did not forget what we saw" Dutch writer wrote about Khojali Genoside
16:09 25.02.2025
Merz won the German election .- Here’s what it means for Europe
00:19 24.02.2025
Chicago hosts second Global Dialogue Conference dedicated to Khojaly genocide
15:46 23.02.2025
How did Western Europe become a puppet?
12:10 15.02.2025
Why Trump’s assault on USAID could change US foreign policy forever
12:06 08.02.2025
Why Gorbochev’s Nobel Peace Prize should be rescinded -Rachel Avraham
15:26 04.02.2025
Parvana Valiyeva has given an interview to the Nigerian press
08:53 30.01.2025
The First Meeting of the IEPF Board of Trustees in 2025 Was Held
19:47 28.01.2025
The historical and cultural heritage of Azerbaijan in Armenia: Obligation of Armenia to preserve and restore
19:55 25.01.2025
"Deprive Gorbachev of the Peace Prize" Open Letter to the Chair and Members of the Norwegian Nobel Committee
16:14 18.01.2025
"Azerbaijan, representing itself in D-9 as a victorious nation, will further solidify its authority."
13:42 16.01.2025
Turning Landmines Into Grapevines In Post-War Azerbaijan -"Forbes" wrote...
16:05 26.12.2024
"Nine countries to become BRICS partners in 2025"
21:09 23.12.2024
"From Zero to Rise" – Umud Mirzayev's Next Meeting with Students Held
17:35 23.12.2024
IEPF Statement on the Resolution of the Lower House of the Swiss Parliament on “Nagorno-Karabakh: Peace Forum”
17:36 19.12.2024
BRI, threats, tariffs and Trump
09:03 04.12.2024
COP29: GLOBAL CALL TO ERADICATE LANDMINES IN AZERBAIJAN AND WORLDWIDE
17:56 18.11.2024
As Trump looms large, can Keir Starmer save the world? Analytics
12:49 17.11.2024
IEPF Holds Side Event at COP29
16:40 15.11.2024
Chief of NGO Branch, Office of Intergovernmental Support and Coordination for SDG, DESA, United Nations visited IEPF
18:08 14.11.2024
Hamısı