Microsoft's overseas privacy battle may be far from over

Conflicts 19:08 15.07.2016

Privacy advocates, especially those outside the U.S., can rest a little easier now.  A federal court has rebuked the U.S. government’s attempt to access emails stored on a Microsoft server in Ireland.

But the legal battle may be far from over. Thursday’s ruling could affect how the U.S. conducts surveillance over suspected criminals and terrorists overseas, so expect the government to appeal, said Roy Hadley, a lawyer at Thompson Hine who studies cybersecurity issues.

“There’s a fine line between privacy and national security,” he said. “And it’s a difficult line to walk.”

So far, the U.S. Department of Justice is remaining mum on what it might do. “We are disappointed with the court’s decision and are considering our options,” the department said on Thursday, without elaborating.

Hadley thinks the government will probably appeal the decision to another circuit court or the Supreme Court. It might also explore other legal means to force Microsoft to quickly hand over the emails.

“The U.S. government will always try to be in a position to gain access to that data,” he said.

Thursday’s ruling deals with a case that goes back to December 2013, when the U.S. government obtained a search warrant for emails belonging to Microsoft user who was under investigation. The subject’s identity hasn’t been revealed, but some news reports have said it was not a U.S. citizen.

The emails reside on a Microsoft server in Ireland. Microsoft objected to the search warrant and argued that the U.S. had no authority to conduct email searches in other countries.

On Thursday, Microsoft hailed the ruling as a win for privacy rights and said dozens of other tech and media companies have supported its legal battle.

The court’s decision “ensures that people’s privacy rights are protected by the laws of their own countries,” Microsoft said in a statement.

Craig Newman, a privacy attorney at Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler, said the tech industry is no doubt breathing a sigh of relief. Many U.S. companies, including Microsoft, have data centers around the world and serve millions of foreign customers.

Handing over any of their data to U.S. authorities could violate the privacy laws of those countries and hurt business for the companies that store it, he said.  

“The tech companies have really been put in an uncomfortable position,” he said.

Part of the problem is that some U.S. privacy laws may be outdated. At the center of Microsoft’s legal battle has been the Stored Communications Act, which the U.S. government argued gave it the authority to use a warrant to collect the emails.

The judges who ruled Thursday didn’t agree. The law was enacted in 1986, long before the mainstream Internet or any remote computing, wrote judge Gerard Lynch.

To avoid these legal disputes with the tech industry, Congress should modernize laws on data privacy and clearly define them, Newman said.

“You’re dealing with analog rules in a world that has totally changed,” he said. “Congress needs to roll up their sleeves and figure out the right balance.

Unseen Footage from Nariman Narimanov's Funeral in Moscow Surfaces - VIDEO

News line

Lufthansa extends Tehran flights suspension until April 18
Lufthansa extends Tehran flights suspension until April 18
13:33 13.04.2024
Knife attack in Australia leaves 5 dead, 9 injured -PHOTO
13:16 13.04.2024
Elon Musk and Javier Milei share their love of free markets in first meeting
12:00 13.04.2024
Hraparak: Pashinyan keeps details of Brussels meeting in secret
11:48 13.04.2024
Ammunition found in Khankandi
11:32 13.04.2024
Delphin Pronk: Time has come for concrete steps to ensure peace and stability in South Caucasus
10:51 13.04.2024
Polish MPs vote to move forward with legislation to lift near-total abortion ban
Polish MPs vote to move forward with legislation to lift near-total abortion ban
10:30 13.04.2024
Putin reportedly wants to restart Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant
10:05 13.04.2024
Germany eases gender change rules
Germany eases gender change rules
09:48 13.04.2024
US reportedly sends backup to Middle East amid Iranian threat
09:26 13.04.2024
UK laser weapon could be sent to Ukraine war zone
09:00 13.04.2024
Threat of Iranian attack on Israel is 'real' - White House
23:59 12.04.2024
Armenia appoints military attaché to embassy in UK
Armenia appoints military attaché to embassy in UK
23:25 12.04.2024
Invitation letter addressed to Slovenian President regarding COP29 delivered to the opposite side
Invitation letter addressed to Slovenian President regarding COP29 delivered to the opposite side
22:55 12.04.2024
Tajik President to embark a visit to Azerbaijan next month
22:22 12.04.2024
Georgia and Germany mull security issues in South Caucasus
21:51 12.04.2024
MFA: International support is necessary to address the Armenian landmine threat against Azerbaijan
21:35 12.04.2024
Vehicle transporting military personnel fell into a ravine in Armenia, leaving 4 killed
21:22 12.04.2024
Deputy FM of Azerbaijan visits Greece, holds several meetings
Deputy FM of Azerbaijan visits Greece, holds several meetings
20:24 12.04.2024
Azerbaijan Army positions once again subjected to fire
19:25 12.04.2024
EC announces record gas reserves in EU storage facilities after winter
EC announces record gas reserves in EU storage facilities after winter
18:39 12.04.2024
Azerbaijan's Ganja to be CIS sports capital
18:00 12.04.2024
Moscow to host upcoming meeting of CIS Council of Foreign Ministers
Moscow to host upcoming meeting of CIS Council of Foreign Ministers
17:05 12.04.2024
Russia floods leave houses almost submerged
16:45 12.04.2024
Russia declares Slovenian embassy worker persona - non - grata as measure of retaliation
Russia declares Slovenian embassy worker persona - non - grata as measure of retaliation
16:14 12.04.2024
Georgian foreign agent law protester sentenced to nine years
15:50 12.04.2024
Germany faces domestic lawsuit over its arms sales to Israel
15:27 12.04.2024
Another dangerous consequence of childhood obesity named
Another dangerous consequence of childhood obesity named
15:09 12.04.2024
US restricts travel for diplomats in Israel
14:45 12.04.2024
Toivo Klaar’s spox.: Elements are in place to ensure a sustainable peace between Armenia, Azerbaijan
14:34 12.04.2024
Iran aims to contain fallout in Israel response, will not be hasty, sources say
13:25 12.04.2024
FMs of Azerbaijan, Belarus meet in Minsk
13:07 12.04.2024
Azerbaijani oil price increases slightly
Azerbaijani oil price increases slightly
12:45 12.04.2024
Armenian side admits opening fire on Azerbaijani border guards
12:06 12.04.2024
Hamas says they do not have the hostages for ceasefire deal
10:58 12.04.2024
UN: Almost 11,000 civilians killed in Ukraine war, including 600 children
10:25 12.04.2024
Expansion of Azerbaijan-Moldova cooperation discussed in Chisinau
10:00 12.04.2024
Iran could retaliate ‘on Israeli soil’ in next 24 to 48 hours, according to US intelligence
09:47 12.04.2024
Norway to send 22 F-16 fighter jets to Ukraine
Norway to send 22 F-16 fighter jets to Ukraine
09:33 12.04.2024
Western Azerbaijan Community appeals to WH regarding US Ambassador's statement
09:05 12.04.2024
Hamısı