Can Kyrgyz-Tajik tensions spiral into a bigger crisis?

Conflicts 16:20 26.09.2022
Recent border clashes killed nearly 100 people from the two neighbouring Central Asian states, signalling their friction could destabilise the entire region.
While leaders of China, Russia and some Central Asian states met in Uzbekistan’s capital Samarkand for the annual meeting of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) ten days ago, intense border clashes broke out between two member-states Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan, killing at least 94 people of the two warring nations. 
 
Hundreds of cases of injury  to people were also reported from both sides until a ceasefire was agreed upon on Friday. Regional experts, however, are not too optimistic about the ceasefire transitioning into a lasting peace. 
 
“It’s interesting that Kyrgyz-Tajik clashes happened when the SCO meeting was on,” says Otabek Omonkulov, an Uzbek academic, whose work focuses on Central Asian politics. 
 
The silence maintained by Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan, the two Central states which have mediated between Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan during past clashes, has many experts wondering whether the regional rivalry has crossed the point of de-escalation, Omonkulov tells TRT World.
 
Both Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan, who are the two former Soviet republics, have recently chosen a careful political line in regard to their relations with Moscow, staying neutral on the Ukraine conflict. 
 
“No one is reining them in,” says Raffaello Pantucci, a senior associate fellow at the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI), a British think-tank, referring to how outsider Eurasian powers have chosen not to intervene in the Kyrgyz-Tajik conflict. 
 
The clashes have forced more than 137,000 Kyrgyz civilians to flee from border areas, which appears to indicate that the Tajiks have been more the aggressive side. 
 
But Tajikistan has accused Kyrgyzstan of provoking the recent fighting. 
 
Why now? 
 
Pantucci believes Tajikistan’s “aggressive” behaviour might be related to “a general attitude in government” because President Emomali Rahmon, who has led the former Soviet republic since 1994, has recently shown some signs that he might be stepping down soon. 
 
As a result, the ongoing succession process in Dushanbe, which has a lot to do with Rahmon’s legacy, might create some nervousness in the Tajik leadership, according to Pantucci. “They were similarly aggressive in the Gorno-Badakhshan Autonomous Region (GBAR),” says Pantucci, referring to recent tensions between the central Tajik government and local population in the GBAR. 
 
But he also adds that current tensions are not particularly new. “In fact, the clashes we have seen on the border recently really go back to even before the fall of Kabul,” he says. Contentious claims on border regions are the main source of continuing tensions between the two states, he says. 
 
The most recent reason for escalating tensions might be related to reciprocal accusations that one side is blocking the other side to access water sources, Pantucci informs. While it’s  difficult to know the real trigger, he believes recent tensions are “the continuation of what has been going on for a year and a bit now”.
 
The Kyrgyz-Tajik clashes are also a source of headache for Russia, which has appeared to be stuck in its offensive in Ukraine. Moscow has strong influence over both states. “I’m sure they don’t like to see a Kyrgyz-Tajik fight, but they haven’t done anything about it in the past,” says Pantucci. 
 
Russian President Vladimir Putin, a leading voice in the SCO, which he wants to turn into an alternative alliance against the Western domination, called both sides "take steps to resolve the situation as soon as possible”.
Kamal Alam, a military analyst and a non-resident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, sees a Western political motivation in recent border clashes between the two Central Asian states, which have close ties with Russia. 
 
“Some say it's connected to the general agitation of Russia inspired by the US to destabilise all of the Russian flank across Central Asia,” Alam tells TRT World. “I think they (the US) don't push them directly. But more of a strategy to unsettle Russia's underbelly,” he adds, referring to Central Asia, a critical region, which has been under Moscow’s influence since the 19th century. 
Lavrov: 3+3 platform initiated by President of Azerbaijan becoming more and more promising - VİDEO

News line

EAEU and Iran to sign free trade agreement soon
EAEU and Iran to sign free trade agreement soon
21:21 07.12.2023
IDF releases photo of senior Hamas officials killed in Gaza military operation
20:55 07.12.2023
Denmark passes bill to stop Koran burnings
20:20 07.12.2023
Greek Prime Minister vows to support Türkiye in EU accession process
19:01 07.12.2023
Azerbaijan, UK mull perspectives of relations in banking and financial sectors
18:36 07.12.2023
BRI and Chinese values of Humanity and Humanism - ANALYSIS
18:02 07.12.2023
EU warns China of consequences of escalation in Taiwan
17:53 07.12.2023
Putin: Changes observed in system of international relations
17:15 07.12.2023
MFA: Number of victims of mine terrorism since end of 44-day war has reached 340
17:09 07.12.2023
Greece, Türkiye seek to restart relations
Greece, Türkiye seek to restart relations
16:47 07.12.2023
UN agency staff death toll in Gaza rises to 132
16:37 07.12.2023
Freight traffic by rail increases sharply between China, Azerbaijan
16:28 07.12.2023
Number of Azerbaijani citizens admitted to higher Ukrainian universityies over past two years announced
16:18 07.12.2023
UN agency staff death toll in Gaza rises to 132
16:08 07.12.2023
Bishkek hosts ICT Ministerial Meeting of OTS
Bishkek hosts ICT Ministerial Meeting of OTS
15:58 07.12.2023
Azerbaijani artists present paintings dedicated to history, culture of Poland
Azerbaijani artists present paintings dedicated to history, culture of Poland
15:50 07.12.2023
Chevron announces $15.5-$16.5B capex budget for 2024
Chevron announces $15.5-$16.5B capex budget for 2024
15:40 07.12.2023
Azerbaijan, Moldova sign memorandum of cooperation
Azerbaijan, Moldova sign memorandum of cooperation
15:30 07.12.2023
EU announces agenda of Eastern Partnership Foreign Affairs Ministerial meeting
EU announces agenda of Eastern Partnership Foreign Affairs Ministerial meeting
15:20 07.12.2023
Nepal arresting recruiters of country’s citizens into Russian army
15:10 07.12.2023
Georgia to get candidate status at next meeting of EU Council
15:00 07.12.2023
Armenian Parliament to hold extraordinary meeting next week
14:49 07.12.2023
Israel may extend age limit for reservists by another year
Israel may extend age limit for reservists by another year
14:40 07.12.2023
UK defense secretary to visit Middle East
14:32 07.12.2023
Washington Post journalists plan 24-hour strike amid prolonged contract talks
Washington Post journalists plan 24-hour strike amid prolonged contract talks
14:22 07.12.2023
Seychelles declares state of emergency after explosion, flooding
Seychelles declares state of emergency after explosion, flooding
14:12 07.12.2023
Israel: Hamas fires rockets from humanitarian zones
14:00 07.12.2023
Turkish President Erdogan visits Greece
Turkish President Erdogan visits Greece
13:47 07.12.2023
Azerbaijan, Armenia may sign peace treaty in coming days - Armenian Parliament Speaker
13:37 07.12.2023
February 7 to be non-working day in Azerbaijan next year
13:30 07.12.2023
Annual trade relations between Azerbaijan, Britain is worth GBP 1.3 billion - British Minister for Exports
13:21 07.12.2023
Meeting of Central Election Commission to be held related to extraordinary presidential elections in Azerbaijan
13:03 07.12.2023
EU reportedly reaches deal on AI law
EU reportedly reaches deal on AI law
12:45 07.12.2023
One injured in landmine explosion in Shusha
12:25 07.12.2023
Participants of international forum visit Aghdam Martyrs Alley
12:18 07.12.2023
Azerbaijan to hold snap presidential election in February
12:13 07.12.2023
Umud Mirzayev expressed his condolences to "Al-Jazeera" reporter Moamen Al-Sharaf
11:42 07.12.2023
UK deploys 1,000 more troops to Middle East
11:36 07.12.2023
Tractor hit by mine in Horadiz, one injured
11:30 07.12.2023
President declared Borrell's hypocritical character to the international community - MP Konul Nurullayeva
11:08 07.12.2023
Hamısı