Elon Musk found not guilty of fraud in Tesla tweet trial

Jurors side with tycoon in trial over 2018 tweets

Interesting 13:33 04.02.2023
Jurors on Friday cleared Elon Musk of liability for investors' losses in a fraud trial over his 2018 tweets falsely claiming that he had funding in place to take Tesla private.
The tweets sent the Tesla share price on a rollercoaster ride, and Musk was sued by shareholders who said the tycoon acted recklessly in an effort to squeeze investors who had bet against the company.
Jurors deliberated for barely two hours before returning to the San Francisco courtroom to say they unanimously agreed that neither Musk nor the Tesla board perpetrated fraud with the tweets and in their aftermath.
"Thank goodness, the wisdom of the people has prevailed!" tweeted Musk, who had tried but failed to get the trial moved to Texas on the grounds jurors in California would be biased against him.
"I am deeply appreciative of the jury's unanimous finding of innocence in the Tesla 420 take-private case."
Attorney Nicholas Porritt, who represents Glen Littleton and other investors in Tesla, had argued in court that the case was about making sure the rich and powerful have to abide by the same stock market rules as everyone else.
"Elon Musk published tweets that were false with reckless disregard as to their truth," Porritt told the panel of nine jurors during closing arguments.
Porritt pointed to expert testimony estimating that Musk's claim about funding, which turned out not to be true, cost investors billions of dollars overall and that Musk and the Tesla board should be made to pay damages.
But Musk attorney Alex Spiro successfully countered that the billionaire may have erred on wording in a hasty tweet, but that he did not set out to deceive anyone.
Spiro also portrayed the mercurial entrepreneur, who now owns Twitter, as having had a troubled childhood and having come to the United States as a poor youth chasing dreams.
$420 price was 'no joke'
Musk testified during three days on the witness stand that his 2018 tweet about taking Tesla private at $420 a share was no joke and that Saudi Arabia's sovereign wealth fund was serious about helping him do it.
"To Elon Musk, if he believes it or even just thinks about it then it's true no matter how objectively false or exaggerated it may be," Porritt told jurors.
Tesla and its board were also to blame, because they let Musk use his Twitter account to post news about the company, Porritt argued.
The case revolved around a pair of tweets in which Musk said "funding secured" for a project to buy out the publicly-traded electric automaker, then in a second tweet added that "investor support is confirmed."
"He wrote two words 'funding secured' that were technically inaccurate," Spiro said of Musk while addressing jurors.
"Whatever you think of him, this isn't a bad tweeter trial, it's a 'did they prove this man committed fraud?' trial."
Musk did not intend to deceive anyone with the tweets, and had the connections and wealth to take Tesla private, Spiro contended.
During the trial playing out in federal court in San Francisco, Spiro said that even though the tweets may have been a "reckless choice of words," they were not fraud.
"I'm being accused of fraud; it's outrageous," Musk said while testifying in person.
Musk said he fired off the tweets at issue after learning of a Financial Times story about a Saudi Arabian investment fund wanting to acquire a stake in Tesla.
The trial came at a sensitive time for Musk, who has dominated the headlines for his chaotic takeover of Twitter where he has laid off more than half of the 7,500 employees and scaled down content moderation.
Al-Jazeera Live Broadcasts ANAMA's Landmine Conference in Zangilan - VIDEO

News line

Police detain 9 in downtown Yerevan
Police detain 9 in downtown Yerevan
14:10 30.05.2024
ANAMA, UNDP agree to establish Center of Excellence for Mine Action
13:42 30.05.2024
Azerbaijani FM: Delimitation agreement with Armenia positively affects normalization process
12:48 30.05.2024
Samir Poladov: Karabakh region contaminated with around 1.5 million mines and explosive remnants
12:41 30.05.2024
Heidi Kuhn: Mines are man-caused cancerous tumor on earth
12:37 30.05.2024
COP29 president: Mitigating impact of mines on environment important for safe and environmentally friendly future
12:33 30.05.2024
President Ilham Aliyev: 'Support from the international community for demining the affected areas is of utmost significance'
12:20 30.05.2024
Vugar Suleymanov: Participation of more than 300 guests testifies to importance of issues discussed
Vugar Suleymanov: Participation of more than 300 guests testifies to importance of issues discussed
12:12 30.05.2024
Geomagnetic storm expected tomorrow
Geomagnetic storm expected tomorrow
12:00 30.05.2024
UN Assistant Sec-Gen: Tackling mine problem requires collective action, comprehensive approach
11:52 30.05.2024
ANAMA chief advocates increased int'l support to tackle mine problem consequences
11:45 30.05.2024
Al-Jazeera Live Broadcasts ANAMA's Landmine Conference in Zangilan - VIDEO
11:39 30.05.2024
3rd int’l conference on demining kicks off in Azerbaijan's Zangilan - PHOTOS
11:20 30.05.2024
President addresses participants of international conference on mine action
11:10 30.05.2024
Erdogan Slams Netanyahu's Actions as "Barbarism" in Conquest Anniversary Speech
11:05 30.05.2024
Baku to host EducationUSA Alumni Fair
Baku to host EducationUSA Alumni Fair
10:50 30.05.2024
Islamabad hosts meeting of Azerbaijani, Pakistani FMs
10:38 30.05.2024
Official Baku slams EU spokesperson's statement on human rights situation in Azerbaijan
10:10 30.05.2024
Hikmat Hajiyev reveals latest number of mine victims before int'l conference on landmines
09:55 30.05.2024
Bayern appoint Kompany as head coach
Bayern appoint Kompany as head coach
09:43 30.05.2024
Haber Global airs new footage from 4 liberated Azerbaijani villages - VIDEO
09:30 30.05.2024
Antonio Guterres congratulates Ilham Aliyev
09:00 30.05.2024
EU ambassador in Azerbaijan flying to Zangilan today
08:34 30.05.2024
Defense Ministers of Azerbaijan and Türkiye hold meeting
21:00 29.05.2024
Israel says it controls 75% of Gaza-Egypt buffer zone
20:20 29.05.2024
Volcano in Iceland erupts again
Volcano in Iceland erupts again
19:40 29.05.2024
Ukrainian Army soldier of Azerbaijani descent goes missing
19:20 29.05.2024
Saudi Arabia expels Iranian media team sent for Hajj coverage
Saudi Arabia expels Iranian media team sent for Hajj coverage
19:00 29.05.2024
Azerbaijan, Iran agree on distribution of Araz river water resources
18:50 29.05.2024
Türkiye’s Erdoğan says ‘spirit of UN dead in Gaza’
18:32 29.05.2024
Israel hosts event dedicated to Azerbaijan's Independence Day
18:15 29.05.2024
Azerbaijan selects faculty deans for Karabakh University
17:50 29.05.2024
German Ambassador Observes Women Deminers in Action during Aghdam Visit - PHOTOS
17:35 29.05.2024
Azerbaijan Defense Ministry’s leadership is on a working visit to Türkiye
17:28 29.05.2024
Azerbaijani president's aide discusses regional situation with Turkish ambassador
17:15 29.05.2024
Azerbaijani FM embarks on official visit to Pakistan
17:00 29.05.2024
Ukrainian Army soldier of Azerbaijani descent goes missing
16:57 29.05.2024
Greens ‘will not back von der Leyen’ for re-election if she does deal with far right
16:40 29.05.2024
Picket staged at US Embassy in Moldova in anticipation of Blinken's visit
Picket staged at US Embassy in Moldova in anticipation of Blinken's visit
16:25 29.05.2024
Police search European parliament over possible Russian interference, prosecutors say
16:13 29.05.2024