Does a new period of constitutional monarchy start for Russia?

Analytics 23:27 17.03.2020

Since the centuries nothing has much changed. When reading in the history book about kings of the lands it arose a strong feeling of aversion inside many of us - always asked why the lands are ruled by a single person in the order of hierarchy..?   

Finally, it lead us to modern century of creating republics, democratic states under rules of constitution and authority of not one eternal ruler, but the publicly chosen leader who has capacity and knowledge of managing problems of a state. Alas, it could not  fulfill more of what  the public were promised and unfortunately, it simply played a role of reflecting the silhouette of a democratic state. 

Despite very few media outlets spoke of rallies near the Kremlin where dozens of people were detained because of mainly protesting President Putin's plan of kingdom for 16 more years, it demonstrated how Russian people reacted to the oppression of their ruling government.

Besides that, some pro-government Russian TV channels were spurned by protesters addressing them foal words because of hiding truth from the public. This is the whole inside story of the past week in the capital of Russia. 

As regards the reforms in Russia, many politicians called it Putin's overt plan of bringing monarchy in Russia, which now in fact is a beginning of constitutional monarchy in the country.

Obviously, it is not difficult to discern the structural and substantive similarities between present-day Russia under Vladimir Putin and the reign of Nicholas I. However, there are two notions- one that feel it is hard to explain, the others feel that there is nothing really to explain, and it is something that occurs in instances when history seems to repeat itself.

We can say the world is full of chances but this time it seem to be more like a historical continuity, such parallels cannot be so easily dismissed. The common elements in question here are not merely superficial resemblances between disparate eras: they are deeply rooted long standing structural elements that have appeared and reappeared over hundreds of years.

Generally, if looked over the current processes through a wide angle, it's more like a Tsar regime, where people play less significant role to choose their leader, and as a result they are broken by police after understanding that they were bewildered with the dreams of democracy - so, welcome your king.

Today, a wide focus of the West is on the last week's rallies of demonstrators in Moscow outside the headquarters of the FSB, the state security service that Mr Putin, 67, used to lead. The protest came as Putin signed off on constitutional reforms that “resume history” on how long he can stay in the Kremlin. It also made it clear that President Putin is very decisive to protect his post until he is 83.

It's quite interesting and intrigues a question in minds what is that attracting the ruler of the former Soviet State to grip on his throne.   

So for more clues about Russia's current political situation, let's review the period of Putin's presidency who is in his fourth presidential term.  

In one of her essays, the Russian historian and political analyst Irina Pavlova has described the 23-yer-old plan of Putin as such:

Vladimir Putin’s arrangement to be president for life and his increasingly authoritarianism reflect his longstanding plans for dictatorial rule, plans that were openly acknowledged by his United Russia ideologists as early as 2007. They are not something new as some in Moscow and the West appear to believe.

According to her, even Abdul-Khakim Sultygov, the formerly Russian President's Special Representative for Human Rights in Chechnya on November 6, 2007, had laid out a programme for ensuring that Russia would not have been any “sovereign” or “administered” democracy but a dictatorship and that Putin would have been the one to head it.

She pointed this out in an essay published at that time, an essay which said that the injection of democratic values into Russia at the end of the 1980s and beginning of the 1990s “has turned out to be too weak to provide immunity” against the rise of a new dictatorship.

Supporting the Russian historian's words, the former official of the US Department of State and the political analyst Paul Globe also added that the vote in the Duma opening the way for Putin to remain in office for the rest of his life is just the final act of this unfortunate drama.

"Not surprisingly, she adds, as Putin has moved toward dictatorship, he and his regime have successfully shifted Russian public opinion on his role model, Joseph Stalin. And now 70 percent of Russians approve of the Soviet dictator," the expert stressed.  

According to other experts, President Putin may have less than 27 per cent voters after 2024 elections. So, Putin's prospect of remaining president does not carry any significance in Russia after his adoption of changes in the constitution. However this figure may not remain as fixed while Putin's plans become more real for Russians. Considering the anxieties that already displayed symptoms with rallies in Moscow, Russian authorities said to have a strong shield to defend themselves from the rising outrage of mass opposition. For the time being, it is certainly, the COVID-19 outbreak that are best for use of keeping protesters' mouths shut - like the one they did last week.

So, what politicians conclude their analysis, given the current political situation in Russia, it still seems quite uncertain, despite a little of drama in Moscow streets. It means hopes for serious political change any time soon may be very little or not at all.  

 

by Elnur Enveroglu
Ilham Aliyev participates in High Level Segment of 15th Petersberg Climate Dialogue in Berlin - VİDEO

News line

Germany's Scholz says new approach to combating climate change needed
13:29 26.04.2024
"Are NATO Forces Planning an Attack on Russia?" - Insightful Commentary from British Politician
13:14 26.04.2024
Tensions Rise as Chad Considers Expelling US Forces: US influence in Africa tumbles
Tensions Rise as Chad Considers Expelling US Forces: US influence in Africa tumbles
13:00 26.04.2024
President Ilham Aliyev: As the host country of COP29, Azerbaijan is in active phase of preparation
12:45 26.04.2024
Ilham Aliyev participates in High Level Segment of 15th Petersberg Climate Dialogue in Berlin - VİDEO
12:32 26.04.2024
Details of the expected peace agreement are explained by a political scientist
12:20 26.04.2024
The anniversary of the so-called "Armenian genocide" was held in Iran - PHOTOS
12:09 26.04.2024
Blinken expected in Israel on Tuesday to discuss Rafah operation, hostage deal - Media
Blinken expected in Israel on Tuesday to discuss Rafah operation, hostage deal - Media
11:54 26.04.2024
COP29 delegation meets Spanish minister for ecological transition
11:53 26.04.2024
Russian-Turkish Monitoring Centre in Azerbaijan's Aghdam ceased its activity - VİDEO
11:40 26.04.2024
ISW: If Russia captures Chasov Yar, this will open the way for it to the “defense belt”
11:22 26.04.2024
Chinese FM warns about possible risk of further expansion of Ukraine war
10:50 26.04.2024
Zelensky: 'NATO countries are afraid of Russia'
10:38 26.04.2024
Azerbaijani police discovered explosive devices in Khojavand
10:23 26.04.2024
Greece refuses to provide Ukraine with Patriot systems
10:12 26.04.2024
Price of Azerbaijan oil drops
Price of Azerbaijan oil drops
10:00 26.04.2024
Azerbaijani minister mulls preparations for COP29 with Annalena Baerbock
09:50 26.04.2024
US expands its sanctions list on Iran
US expands its sanctions list on Iran
09:38 26.04.2024
Azerbaijan relocates another 39 families to Fuzuli city
09:26 26.04.2024
Media: US Embassy in Russia is testing water quality to avoid being poisoned
09:00 26.04.2024
Armenian lobby plans provocative rally during Azerbaijani President's Germany visit
00:35 26.04.2024
Xavi agrees to remain Barcelona coach
Xavi agrees to remain Barcelona coach
22:00 25.04.2024
Plane of Azerbaijani President leaves for Berlin from Fuzuli Airport for first time
21:00 25.04.2024
20 border posts installed on Azerbaijan-Armenia border
20:00 25.04.2024
This could be the end of the world economy - Predictions from English politologue
19:25 25.04.2024
Anti-Azerbaijan and Türkiye banners raised in Ukraine on Anniversary of So-Called Armenian Genocide - VİDEO
Anti-Azerbaijan and Türkiye banners raised in Ukraine on Anniversary of So-Called Armenian Genocide - VİDEO
18:50 25.04.2024
Deadly floods wreak havoc in Kenya’s capital
18:29 25.04.2024
Armenia Continues Unsubstantiated Claims Against Azerbaijan in The Hague Court - VİDEO
18:08 25.04.2024
Polish FM: Russia's attack on NATO will result in Moscow's defeat
17:55 25.04.2024
China Facilitates Arms Trade Route Between North Korea and Russia, US Satellite Observations Reveal
17:48 25.04.2024
More than 100 prisoners escaped from prison due to rains in Nigeria
More than 100 prisoners escaped from prison due to rains in Nigeria
17:32 25.04.2024
Kobakhidze: Georgia to soon become member of European Union
17:12 25.04.2024
Kyrgyz President Zhaparov concludes his state visit to Azerbaijan
16:47 25.04.2024
Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev invites European Council President Charles Michel to COP29
16:34 25.04.2024
Macron: Europe must show that it is not a US vassal
16:12 25.04.2024
Credit investment in Azerbaijan’s economy increases by 23%
16:00 25.04.2024
Azerbaijan and Uzbekistan to cooperate in space field
Azerbaijan and Uzbekistan to cooperate in space field
15:49 25.04.2024
Protesters in Yerevan demand resignation of government
Protesters in Yerevan demand resignation of government
15:28 25.04.2024
Presidents Ilham Aliyev and Sadyr Zhaparov tour Shahbulag Castle in Aghdam
15:00 25.04.2024
Second meeting of Foreign Affairs Committee Chairs of Parliaments of Turkic States to be held in Türkiye
Second meeting of Foreign Affairs Committee Chairs of Parliaments of Turkic States to be held in Türkiye
14:30 25.04.2024
Hamısı